Coleman’s Corner

Great food and service all around. Great place to go have a drink on a friday or saturday night if you like less active environments.

Waitress didn’t seem too happy to have a table of 7 in her section that only ordered water… sorry we drink healthy. Food was ehh… ok. When you have an item on the menu that you don’t serve year round, it might be nice to mention that in the menu. I was set on beef stew, but when I ordered it, the waitress told me it was just for the winter. So I ordered the Corned beef and it was super salty, and the veggies were bland.

The food was average except the wings. The wings were so good. Also the customer service was great. Customer service and the wings was the reason for 3 stars take away that I would easily given them 1 or 2 stars

Great vibe and very friendly staff. Good selection of Irish and non-​Irish food, and a decent selection of beer. I have the corn beef and cabbage and it was a dead ringer for a carefully homemade corn beef and cabbage.

My husband and I have been making this restaurant our stop before heading to the boat in Alexandra Bay for over 5 years. Our dog has always been welcome on their patio, he basically lays under the table and naps. We came in this afternoon and the same waitress that had waited on us for at least the past summer told us he had to be a service dog. Under further research my husband found the law that Governor Cuomo had passed in October that dogs were indeed welcomed on patios with a stipulation that restaurants could refuse. So off to Bella’s in Clayton where our pooch is welcomed with a water dish and some croutons to munch on.

I totally did not expect such a nice Irish themed pub. I loved the set up. The Shepard’s Pie was excellent and the Parmesan garlic wings were delicious. I will definitely go back. Our server was friendly and great on suggesting food. The IPA beer that I had was really good! And I got a free beer too because the gave me the wrong beer at first.

Long wait but it was worth the wait! Great food, beer selection and service wasn’t bad. Try the Harvest Salad… Soooo delish!

Irish nachos. Enough said.
This place is always very clean and the servers are so friendly. Definitely a staple place in Watertown!

This was overall a nice restaurant. I loved the interior decorating. It was very authentic looking. The menu had some excellent choices. It even had an old favorites section if you’re feeling really in the mood to eat some old Irish food. Service was good and friendly. There was almost no wait time and the waitress visited the table frequently.

My husband and I have eaten here a few times and the food is decent but nothing overly special. It is reasonably priced but it is not a top choice. There are other places I could go to get a better sandwich at.

Had the fish and chips with clam chowder soup. The chips were delicious with the gravy. However everything is just decently okay. Its not something that blew your mind. the clam chowder was a little too sweet for me.
I hard the sweet chilli burger is good though. Might give it a try next time.

Chowder — really creamy, clams were too
Soft
Fish and chips — really are fried chips, not steak fries
Monday night — small crowd but good
Music needs work
Really appreciate the interior décor
Great local place, good food and Baileys cheesecake
So glad to have finally been there

I’ve gotta give Coleman’s five stars. Each of the handful of times I’ve patronized this pub, I’ve left more than fat and happy. Everything I’ve ever ordered, from steak and shepherd’s pie, to steamed clams and salads, has been delectable, and the presentation noteworthy. (THE SHEPHERD’S PIE IS PERFECT! …I dream of Coleman’s shepherd’s pie.) Yes, it is a pub, but superbly kept, clean, and family-​friendly. The food and service seem more the focus than it’s function as a watering hole. I love this place!

First off, place is small. I’m sure there is a wait during peak times. Nice atmosphere, typical Irish pub feel.
Prices were very reasonable. We had a huge stuffed mushroom and their version of nachos. The mushroom was not your typical 5 little things on a plate. It was a giant portobello with all the trimmings on top, Excellent!!! Their version of nachos was their circular fries topped with the regular nacho stuff, cheese, peppers etc. Can’t pick at it with your hands needed a fork to get anything off the huge plate.
Wife had Shepard pie and she said it was great. My table also had fish and chips that appeared to be very large portions of fish. I had the ribeye. The mash was good and I liked how the steak was sitting on some bread. Only complaint was that it was a little dry and not ax juicy as other ribeye I have had. Overall I would come back in a heart beat.

Went out to lunch while visiting with family. Portions are huge. Nice atmosphere, server was great and left with a super full stomach. I just hate I wasn’t able to try out any desserts or speciality coffees because I was so full.
I had the Bangers on a Bun sandwich, it was nicely priced for the amount of food that I received.

This place was a great find! We were coming back to PA from Montréal and stopped in. Wings were enormous and tasty with sweet chil sauce. The mister and I each got burgers which were done perfectly with big flavor. Glad I didn’t listen to Unilocal on this one. Kids menu at an Irish pub are you kidding me?

Expensive for the quality. Veggies of the day seemed to have been pre-​frozen and were like styrofoam. Not kid friendly — no kids menu. Chicken fingers were good — so perhaps their specialty is more bar food and beer? I don’t know, but there’s better options for good food in the area.

Great Irish food! Friendly service, tvs everywhere for football. I posted a pic of our appetizer and the pile of potato «chips». It was amazing. Food was great, tasted really fresh. My wife loved her salad, really good flavor with everything they add. We look forward to going back soon.

Came in for lunch after visiting someone in the hospital. It’s very convenient to the hospital and the fairgrounds and I was so pleasantly surprised by this little gem. Beautiful little patio with lots of flowers to distract from the view of the parking lot and the inside has a very authentic Irish pub look. Dark wood paneling, mahogany bar, high top seating and and very high ceiling all add to the charm. We had seafood, so our lunch was on the pricey side, but the shrimp in the cocktail were big and fresh and the fish and chips appetizer was a huge portion for my half pint. The «chips» are fries sliced like chips, which was cute in theory, but a little disappointing in execution. Very good beer selection with the local 1812 and others on tap. Our server was awesome and very accommodating to my embarrassingly-​behaved daughter. Zero stars for my kid, 4 five for Coleman’s Corner.

Definitely one of the better restaurants in the Watertown area, although its close enough to some hotels that out-​of-​towners might come in with big expectations and be disappointed. Look, it’s not a big city, alright? If you’re from Manhattan or whatnot, just keep in mind that the house wine is INGLENOOK for only $ 4.50 a glass with generous pours, and wash your criticism down with that.
Seafood dishes are a particular specialty here, with very authentic fish’n’chips (the appetizer portion will be enough food for most people), some hearty chowders, and my personal favorite, the scallops, sold either as an entrée or as a salad topping.
A whole page of the menu is devoted to sandwiches, but honestly I’d avoid them, as they’re pretty much the same sandwiches you can get at any Coleman family restaurant, which is like half of them in Watertown.
The décor and ambience are pretty much the best you’re gonna get in Watertown, despite the bar atmosphere. Service is usually super friendly and attentive. I’ve never had a bad experience, but on the other hand I am Irish. A previous reviewer reported bad treatment and suspected it was due to being non-​white, and yeah, unfortunately I could believe that, though I very much doubt it’s unique to Colemans Corner.