Brickyard Pizzeria

Stellar service, scrumptious pies, consistent yummers. I live for coming here to pop in for a delicious lunch. 6 dollar options give the menu a ton of frugal play room. I enjoyed a blue cheese salad with a fulfilling slice of spinach pie. This convenient location makes for a perfect weekend stop spot. Local food on the table from a local business. What a luxury!

If you like a thin authentic pizza, this is the place. Delicious pure pizza flavor. Reasonably priced, and fresh ingredients. Great little whole in the wall to have a slice and drink a cold beer. Guilty pleasure :-)

I liked this place, but I felt like I was going to die before I get my food. Once I got the garlic knots I knew this place it’s gonna be good. Then when u get my pizza it filled me up to the brim. I felt like I’m like 30 mins pregnant. I will recommend this to anyone. I haven’t been here in year and I think it’s a wonderful comeback! 4 stars

I love this place. Good food good prices nice an cozy. And the kids love it.

One of the best Italian restaurants I’ve ever been to! I can’t believe I waited this long to try it. Such a cute, family frendly, and local place to get some delicious food. Although pizza is their specialty, the Baked Meat Ziti I got was wonderful (and enough to feed 2)!! After seeing other patrons get a salad, I know what I want next time. The salads are huge, topped with fresh ingredients, and look incredible. My boyfriend got a stromboli and it was delicious too! The service was great and everything is reasonably priced!

This place hands down makes the BEST Eggplant Parmigiana and Pizza in Tallahassee. The staff is friendly and the restaurant is always clean. It’s one of those neighborhood restaurants that you are glad is nearby. Casual dining, good atmosphere, and the great food!

Best lunch value in town. always fresh and cooked to order. Sam makes the best pies…

I am reluctant to say good things about this restaurant because the next time I go it will be overcrowded. Seriously it has the best pizza in Tallahassee.

Last time i went to eat here we pulled in parking lot and I’m not sure if it was manager or owner outside establishment, but he was yelling and cussing at employee (young female). A few men in parking lot tried to defuse the situation and then manager or owner became irrate. Don’t care if your pizza is decent, people are now scared to eat there.

I’ve been happy with everything I’ve eaten from here. Always get friendly servers and have had no complaints about my food. It is what you expect it to be — not the most authentic rustic Italian but it is good for what it is.

Best White Pizza I have had in Tallahassee thus far! Chicken parm was better than most, but I feel the sauce was missing just a little something. Prices are a little high, but I was not left disappointed.

Found this place on Unilocal while passing thru on route to Pensacola. Not that far off the expressway, if you want something really good without going to out the way. We had pizza and pasta dishes. All were flavorful and delicious. The garlic knots they served with my twice baked spaghetti were wonderful little balls of crispy, cheesy, garlic butter heaven! Not a very big place, but very big on the portions and taste of food. Thanks Brickyard Pizzeria for making are first meal on vacation a good one.

Brickyard has the best pizza I’ve had since I left New Jersey. Quality ingredients, excellent tomato sauce, and the essence of good pizza — good baking! The dough has the wonderful taste and texture that comes from slow rising. We’ve gotten pizza there once a week ever since they’ve opened. Also good antipasto and pasta dishes. The eggplant rollatini is also a favorite. And there’s always great service from a friendly staff. And they’ve just added made-​to-​order cannoli!

This is for the pizza. Recently moved into the area and have been in search of a decent pizza place. To me this was the second worse pizza I have ever had. It had no flavor whatsoever. I would like to try the other dishes but will not get the pizza again. Tallahassee seems to have trouble making good pizza from what I have found so far.

We just left brickyard and it was excellent… between the amazing food and service we couldn’t have been more pleased. Our server, Jordan was wonderful. We look forward to future visits!

Cute place, great pizza. My husband enjoyed his calzone & kids enjoyed the food as well. Service was good and fast. Would definitely take the family to eat there again!

Kind of a love/​hate relationship with this place… love the pizza and the other Italian Dishes they have ;but can’t stand the owner and some of his employees. the pizza is by far the best in town. as close as you can come to real authentic New York Pizza without heading up to the city. crust is the right size and crispness. sauce is correct. cheese and toppings are generous and the pie has the requisite amount of grease on top. in other words perfect for folding… the other Italian Dishes including all the Pastas and Sandwiches are good as well. that’s the good. as for the bad the owner Sal is loud and abrasive like a lot of New Yorkers. I have seen him be rude to customers and employees and he uses the F Word liberally. he needs to realize he is in Tally not New York. that stuff may be kosher up there but certainly not down here. the girl that answers the phone to take to-​go orders is a complete disaster cause more often than not she is rude and unresponsive on the phone. I know a couple people that have stopped ordering from here strictly because of her… if you go there to eat it’s a pretty slow process cause the service is usually pretty poor and slow. it’s not that great of a dining environment either with no ambience at all. the only people who are nice are the people making the pizza and meals. my advice is get your pizza to go cause it’s great. you just have to put up with the rude phone girl and then hope when you pick it up the owner is not there. honestly I would probably go to this place every few weeks if not for my disdain for the people running the show. that keeps my visits down to a few times a year.5 stars for the food. one star for the people working there so 3 stars overall

Boyfriend’s parents recently discovered this place, and his Dad says its the best manicotti he’s ever had. So the other night when he suggested we meet there for dinner, we were all about it.
Boyfriend started us off with a BC Bomb — breadsticks (basically a small pizza crust) smothered with cheddar and bacon, served with ranch on the side. Its as good as it sounds.
His Dad, of course, had the manicotti, Mom had the lasagna, boyfriend had a calzone, and I had the eggplant rollatini. I ordered the appetizer size — only difference is the entrée comes with one more roll, a side of spaghetti, and garlic knots. But we had an order of knots anyway, so that was covered, and spaghetti would have just been filler.
Three of the four of us cleaned our plates. The calzone was ginormous, so half of it came home for later, and we’ve been munching on it ever since. Everything was excellent.
They have a pretty good beer selection, but watch the expiration dates on the bottles — I got to the bottom of my Sweetwater Blue (oh, how I miss living where Sweetwater distributes) before I realized that it had a best by date of August 2010. Overall though, great food, great prices, and a great atmosphere. I would definitely condone a return!

This was my first visit to Brickyard. The place is rather small, or I thought it was until I was leaving and noticed the other room. On another Unilocaler’s recommendation I ordered the garlic rolls. These were brought to the table hot and fresh. They were tender inside, slight crunch on the outside. I loved these. Hubby ordered a meat pizza that he thought was «ok». He really is a carnivore when it comes to pizza. No spinich or basil onion for him. My meal was simply DELISH. Eggplant Rollatini with a side of spaghetti and meat sauce– along with another one of those mouthwatering rolls. There was so much food, I had it for breakfast the next day. Evev leftover the eggplant was wonderful. It was very lightly battered and fried, then rolled around a riccotta cheese and herb mixture that was just right, then topped with mozzarella and baked. I want to go again very soon!

Once again, my fellow Unilocalers have not failed me. Based on the previous two positive recommendations, I had dinner with my boyfriend at Brickyard Pizza tonight. I immediately loved the atmosphere there. It’s very casual, with a few tables near the to-​go pick up area and many more tables and a few booths next door in a small room. It’s fairly quiet, although Christmas music was already playing (!). We enjoyed garlic knots (excellent and under $ 2 for six of them!) before splitting a large pizza, half meatball, half pepperoni. The total, including two sodas, came to $ 22 and change, which is remarkably cheap for a table service dinner out for two. Our service was fine. At times the server could have been more attentive, but it wasn’t enough to bother me (plus she was charming!). The pizza was great, and we had a wonderful meal there together. I’ve looked at the menu, and just about all the individual entrees are $ 10 or less. Of course, larger pizzas are more than that, but you can get a ten inch pizza for $ 6.99!
Awesome, and I will definitely go back. It was phenomenal.