Lorenzo’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

The whole menu is great, however they have the best Sicilian pie you can get anywhere in north jersey. It hasn’t changed at all in at least 20 years, gotta love it. The big Sicilian will take almost an hour to make, so order ahead. Also this pie should be eaten ASAP, for max-​perfection.

Order took 43 minutes. When I took it home it was overcooked, dry and burnt. To top it off the food leaked and the bag broke! Lots of other places in the area are much better.

Delicious pizza. Best in the county, even. Most everything else here is good. Family run place, has been for years and years. Never been disappointed.

Typical pizza place, but strangely addictive pizza. …the NEXT DAY. I always order a pie to go, and the day if it can be a little doughy and chewy. (It should be noted that I order the pepperoni pizza, which seems a little salty, even for pepperoni) I’m never really blown away the night I get it. But the next day, after being toasted up in a 400 degree oven, it is supremely crunchy, savory and delish. It’s also a bargain at 14 $ for a large. I advise reheating it, or maybe ordering your pie well done.

As a New Yorker, I can honestly say this is the best pizza in the area. I was very happy to have found this place. Crust is nice a thin but not too thin. Sauce and cheese are delicious. Staff are also very friendly!
Check them out!

Fabulous! You WILL NOT find a better pizzeria anywhere. I no longer live in the area, but when I visit, you will find me here a few times a week. I can’t say enough good things about the staff and food. Simply the best!

This place got Readers Choice «best pizza» awards in 2013 & 2014.
I ordered a ham salami cheese wrap, and the size was double what I expected. Generous meat inside. The pizza was a yummy thin crust which one could bend in half to eat as you would expect an Italian to do. My hubby the pizza expert felt that the crust could be a little crispier, but the balance of crust-​sauce-​cheese was very good.
It’s a casual interior, perfect for families. Crayons are available for children if you ask. The staff was friendly and helpful. We would definitely come back when in the area.

Lorenzo’s is my favorite pizza in Sussex and Northern Morris County. It is the closest you will find to «NY style» pizza out this way taste wise. The dough is just the right thickness and texture and it is not too sweet. The sauce is perfectly seasoned. It has the right amount of basil and even a little kick to it. It has the perfect amount of cheese for a regular slice. The extra-​cheese pie is loaded if you’re feeling adventurous. If you choose to order a pie with toppings, they have just the right amount placed on the pie. They are not skimpy nor do they overload the slice so you can’t fold it while you’re eating.
The pasta at Lorenzo’s is decent too. I usually do not eat this here since my dad likes to cook. Sorry guys. Gotta eat at home when I can. I endorse the eggplant parm sandwich whole heartedly.
Call ahead and order take out. They will have your pizza fresh and piping hot for you when you arrive.
My family has been ordering from here every Friday night for 25 years. It’s a great local business.

This is one of the best pizza places in the area. We had a large mushroom pizza and the crust was cooked just right. Not too thin. Not too thick. The sauce was subtly seasoned, and there was a generous serving of mushrooms.
The cheese wasn’t too oily like you sometimes get in other places.
We were impressed. Best so far in this area.