Teresa’s Pizza

First and last time. I ordered online.
I ordered a 4 slice THIN crust pizza that would almost have bought me a large Papa John’s pizza. Got a thick crust that the sauce tasted strange.
Ordered Fries with cheese sauce. I I got Cheese Sticks.
Ordered Garlic Parmesan Wings. They were like plain wings in about 2 tbsp of a very runny tasteless liquid.
They insisted on a store credit or replacement. No adjustment on my credit card. The person I was speaking to (said there was no manager on duty) hung up on me.
Do yourself a favor. DON’T EVER!!!

We love this place. We order the pizza & mozzarella sticks all the time, you can tell they use good fresh cheese on their pizzas and subs. Everything we’ve tried has been delicious. The staff is extremely friendly and I recommend them to people all the time.

I attempted to place an order last night. After giving up on their terrible online ordering system, my husband called to place our order over the phone. The woman who answered was incredibly RUDE and obviously didn’t want our large order placed one hour before closing. We live less than a mile away and she said they couldn’t deliver to us because our address could not be located-​although we have placed orders for delivery before. She eventually told us she wasn’t going to take our order! I will never support this business again.

We had Teresa’s Pizza for the first time with a salad, my husband and I LOVED IT! The pizza crust was flavorful and crispy perfectly and the pizza was full of cheese and toppings as was the salad (I’m a cheese freak). Needless to say this is our new fav, don’t hesitate to give it a try you won’t be sorry.

When people say their pizzas are smaller than you expect, they aren’t kidding. We ordered a large two topping with green peppers and onions and it was the size of a small or medium elsewhere. Even Romeo’s pizzas are larger and they’re on the small size. That said, there was a ton of cheese as expected and the crust was nice and crispy. The pizza was a gigantic mess however because there was entirely too much sauce on half the pizza and because of the vast amount of cheese the pieces wouldn’t pull apart properly. The sauce wasn’t very good in my opinion and tasted more like a cheap spaghetti sauce than a proper pizza sauce. The pizza wasn’t bad, just disappointing. Very disappointing. Ordered some cheese breadsticks which were okay, but really ugly. The end pieces barely had cheese on them and the middle ones had so much that it pulled off the bread stick when we ripped them apart. Not going to be getting them again and I highly doubt I’ll ever come here again. Incredibly disappointing, especially for the price.

Ordered the 3 cheese pizza and added chicken and mushrooms. Pleasantly surprised at how good it was. Also got a side salad, which was pretty good. Really good pizza option… Takeout/​delivery only.

Just moved into the area, saw it on my way home, thought I’d give them a shot.
It was Monday, so I ordered two large pizzas for their special: a Spinach Florentine and a Three Cheese. The crust on both was nice and crispy, and definitely appreciated the amount of cheese on each pie; this is what you pay for.
I’m interested in trying out more of their menu items, and the free delivery will probably serve me well when I’m in the middle of programming hell.
One thing that happened while I was at the restaurant that I overheard: someone called in wanting a pizza done half pepperoni, half barbecue chicken. They wouldn’t do the order, and I applaud them for saying no, because that would not have ended well… someone would have wound up with either a burnt pepperoni half or an undercooked barbecue chicken half.
I’ll definitely be back.

Lent Dinner Review
We got a flyer in the mail with pretty glossy pictures of 3 limited time lent special dinners… fried haddock… butterflied fried shrimp… and baked whitefish… all $ 9.99.
We have had such inconsistent food and service that I have never tried to sort it out for a review… but this time it wad pure meh!
Single piece of haddock was moist but smothered in greasy batter with a pool of grease at the bottom of the container.
The shrimp were small… also over breaded… and swimming in grease… and came with a tiny cup of ketchup… no cocktail sauce?
The krinkle cut fries were nice and crispy since we saved them from the grease with paper towels once we got home.
I would love to like this place… but they make it difficult.

Don’t go. As a resident Theresa’s pizza was welcome. It was (was) a good pie. Now we have rude employees with less than mediocre food. If you’re in the area go anywhere else for pizza. Even the Mexican place next door!

Found it wasacross the street from the hotel we were staying in, and tried the spinach Florentine calzone with bacon. It was definitely greasy, but crispy, and absolutely STUFFED with buttery, melty, creamy cheeses, flavorful spinach and artichokes, and plenty of bacon. The sauce was mediocre, somewhat salty, but I prefer sweeter sauce. Not bad, I’d try them again when in the area.

Got a flyer for Teresa’s when we moved into our new place and decided to try them out on Mad Monday, when they have a BOGO deal on large pizzas.
The girl on the phone was very sweet, and the pizzas arrived quickly. We decided to try out a Spinach Florentine (spinach and artichoke w/​Italian cheeses) and a chicken pizza with broccoli. I asked for garlic on the chicken pizza as well, and the girl gave me the idea to try white garlic sauce instead. Since I’m not a huge fan of tomato sauce, I figured that’d work out well.
The first thing that struck us was that the pizzas are SMALL! Their «large» looks like what most place’s medium looks like. We also noticed a severe lack of artichoke on the Spinach Florentine. Other than that, everything was pretty good. They really pile on the cheese, so it’s a bit greasy, but it is nice for those who prefer more cheese. They went very light on the sauce on both pizzas, so if you’re big on sauce, you may want to ask for extra. My chicken pizza had plenty of chunks of chicken and broccoli. Very nice crust, too — I rarely find a crust that I like, but this seemed very authentic. It was just the right thickness — nice and crunchy, but not brittle. Great taste.
The only other issue for us was the price. It was about $ 13 for each pizza. With the size being so small, it definitely made me think twice about ordering from here again. But I think if they keep doing the Mad Monday deal, $ 13 for two pizzas is more than worth it, so we’ll order then.

Meh. That about sums it up. They definitely live up to their nickname «Grease-a’s»
If it wasn’t for the $ 5 lunch deal for two large slices of pizza and a 20oz soda this place would get a solo star.