Brooklynn’s Pizzeria

Delicious thin crust pizza. It’s mostly take out, but they have a few seats. Price is reasonable. And they have Chaco Tacos!!!

We ordered The Max and it was delicious! They had it ready for us in under 15 minutes. They also sell pizza by the slice (cheese and pepperoni) for only $ 3. We tried going to two other pizza places before finding this hole in the wall that turned it to be just what we were looking for. Good, flavorful, quick pizza!

Tasty, Expensive pizza. If you’re into that go for it. We’ve ordered delivery several times in the past year. Always feel like we’ve paid too much. If you’re walking by and just need slice it’s not bad.

Great place with an awesome feel. Best pizza in the Boat and the cheese steak sandwiches are da bomb. Keep it up Brooklynn’s!

These guys are great. We ordered our food at the counter and it came out pretty fast. The food was decent as well and the service was very friendly. No complaints here!

Eh. Ordered in spite of Domino’s to try something local. Got the cheese steak pizza. It lacked sauce and the flavor was trying to be good but could be improved. $ 24 on below average pizza that didn’t satisfy my craving.

I spent 6 years in NJ with frequent tips into NYC so I’ve had great pizza. Brooklynn’s ranks right up there; it’s my favorite pizza outside of the NYC area. We get it at least once every time we come to town. Tip: call in your order when you are 15 – 20 minutes from arriving. It will be ready when you get there for picnic table eating out front or to take home.

Good pizza. Good service. Cute place. Cheese steak was tasty and cheeseey. Get it with extra cheese. Loved the pickles! Would eat here again.

Great pizza!!! The worker came out to cut my sisters pizza and he was hilarious! Also, the lettuce was fresh and delicious.

Literally nothing good to say about this pizza. I wish we had ordered from Domino’s instead.

Love me some Brooklynns Za !!!
Free delivery, stroms, slices for lunch, can’t beat it for lunch !!

Only reason why they received one star is because I have to rate it. First, lets start with the service. As someone who deals with guests daily I have never received such crappy service. So after waiting 45 mins for a pizza, they call back and were told they haven’t start making it yet because they weren’t sure where that address was and they said they had the wrong number after being provided with a valid address and phone number. Then they say another 30 mins and and we have to be more specific about our were about. They once we finally received the pizza it was cold, barely and cheese and frankly not all that good. Don’t think I would give it to my dog.

Solid pizza, sauce was zesty, could have used more toppings, fast delivery. 16″ just barely fed a hungry family of 3.

Have tried this place twice and so far the pizza did not let me down, It is slightly above average. The service was good.
* consistent good service gets another star.

Small pizza/​sandwich place with some indoor seating. Best part is the fresh ingredients and dough (I had a Stromboli). The flavors were what I expected with the ingredients. Would recommend.

Pretty damn good. If you want some pizza or Stromboli, and you don’t want to pay a pretty penny, this is your spot. Sometimes a little inconsistent, but they do it right. I usually get the 18-​inch pepperoni and green pepper, and the peppers are fresh, the roni is crisp, the crust is thin with a crisp outside and a chewy inside, and the sauce and cheese are tasty and plentiful. I’ll also get a Stromboli every once in a while, and it’s probably the best deal.
Plus, if you get a sub, it comes with chips and it’s reasonably priced.
Let’s put it this way. The contact named «pizza» in my phone points to Brooklyn’s.

Pizza was horrible, dry and tasted old!!! The worst pizza I have ever had!!! It was also for delivery, it is stone cold. Not to mention the girl taking my order was unfriendly over the phone!

Yuck! Ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza last night and was not impressed. There was almost no cheese and toppings were sparse. The sauce tasted like ketchup and the dough was not good. I will say that delivery was prompt. Moving on.

This was our first time here for dinner. It was located on the main drag in Steamboat Springs. The restaurant’s website said that they were open until 1pm. We called to make sure they were open. The gal who answered the phone said it’s supposed to say open until 1am.
We ordered at the counter and then sat on small stools at a bar. We asked for a cloth to wipe down the counter. The gal at the counter handed us a rag.
They did not have complimentary tap water. They only sell bottled beverages like Coke products, Gatorade, ice tea, and bottled water. We ordered a 16″ pizza and it came out in less than 15 minutes. The crust was crispy. The toppings were evenly distributed and generous. I did not care for the thin dried out slices of sausage. I prefer ground sausage. The sauce was bland but I added a bunch of red pepper flakes to add some zing.

It seems every place in town advertises itself as «The Best of the Boat,» and it’s sometimes difficult to tell how they earned it, or if they still deserve it. This one is a Best of the Boat that is probably earned.
We were walking by on our Happy Hour Pub Crawl, saw that they sold pizza by the slice, and decided to try one just for comparison sake. You can get cheese or pepperoni pizza by the slice for $ 3.00 all day long, (they say all night, too, but I don’t know).
If you decide to go here, know that it seems they do most of their business with deliveries, so there’s not really much sit down room for dining at the restaurant — maybe room for about eight inside, and a table or two outside. They offer free delivery, and they have some pretty good values on pizza. I love how every place in Steamboat has huge, 18″ pizzas that you can get for under $ 24 completely loaded. This place is no exception. I know that we had a 14″, and it was big enough for two. I suspect when they say 18″, it really is that big.
Anyway, back to the pizza. I ordered up a slice, they cut it off, and ran it through the oven again to warm it up. It is a thin crust pizza with a good crust, and a good sauce. I could actually taste the pizza and the sauce, unlike another place I went to a few days earlier. I enjoyed this pizza, and, after having sampled a slice, I would be willing to take advantage of their free delivery. This pizza met my mark of approval. I liked the pizza, I was OK with the price, and I liked the service. That’s a good combination. It wasn’t the best thin crust pizza I’ve ever had, and not even the best I’ve had in Steamboat, but it was pretty darned good.