Villaggio Pizzaria Restaurante

If I could give them a zero I would. The owner charges a different price every time. It’s never the same price. And to boot I saw a customer eat a slice today that had pesto on it. The menu doesn’t list pesto and she was allergic to nuts. The owner was smiling at her as she stood there and thought she was going to die. I’ll never go back. He was completely inconsiderate and could have honestly killed this woman.

My family goes to Villagios all the time for a quick slice of pizza or we have it delivered. Service is quick and the pizza never disappoints.

If there’s one thing I miss most about Staten Island, its the food. Sure my entire family and all of my friends still live there but, well… Food still trumps those things.
Had to head down to SI for a friends wedding rehearsal at a nearby church followed by dinner at Villagio. Growing up I remember several different businesses here, and this location has seen quite a bit of turnover. My buddies father seems to think parking makes an impact here. Perhaps he’s right as its all street parking on Amboy road and that can be a bit obnoxious in this location.
As for the restaurant itself, the meal was fantastic. It was a typical catered events with bread, salad, pasta (penne ala vodka), main course (veal parm) and dessert. The staff was extremely attentive and very polite. The food was exactly what I’ve come to miss. The «best» Italian spots by me can’t even compare to this small neighborhood location on SI. The veal parm and sauce were excellent and left me wanting to order a second to bring home for the next day. Sure the island is filled with restaurants that I’d consider my favorites, and the amount of time i spend there is limited (am only able to frequent my favorites) but I would definitely come by and have Villagio again.

We come here for our NY italian food fix! They never disappoint! The staff is great and the food even better! We have been to other Restaurants in the area but this is tops!

I’m sorry I ordered lasagna and the meat wasn’t fresh then for $ 10 u think they would have the courtesy to let u know it’s not coming with bread or give me option to wait till they make some .The delivery boy didn’t even have change when they should no matter what wether it’s slow or not. there’s always a way.

Great Sicilian pie from over here. Great sauce and a nice thin crust, very tasty pie! I highly recommend it. Plus there’s a restaurant on the other side if ur in the mood to sit down and have a great meal with ur family.. Great food n service. Family owned and operated. There’s a pistachio crusted chicken is out of this world.

Food was just ok. Delivery was on time but food was cold. I’d recommend reggianos which is right down the block. To order in or deliver. If I stop in I will revise my review but for now I will stick to the many other options in tottenville. Nucci’s, Villa Monte… etc.

Neighborhood Gem: tottenville is full of Italian restaurants and I have to give 5 stars to Villagio for the quality of food they use. The chicken is always a good quality and fresh. Other restaurants in the area do not seem to use the best quality of meats. I am not going to pay for inferior food. Friendly and comfortable staff and restaurant.

Nice restaurant, very fairly priced. My favorite dish is the chicken piccata and it never disappoints me. I like their pizza only I always ask to add more sauce, but that’s my preference. Staff is always nice and friendly and when I get an order delivered it comes fast.

Good selection on menu. Food took forever at off hour with few people in restaurant. Specials looked amazing but turned out to be a misprint so food came with chicken unexpectedly and unhappily for this vegetarian. Issue was quickly& kindly resolved but still included pieces of chicken. Pity because it all looked so good. Salads were great. Charged full price+ some. Wouldn’t eat here again but probably ok In a pinch if dominos is closed.

I really am hesitant on reviewing this restaurant selfishly, because I am afraid it will become packed and I won’t be able to eat here without a long wait: D
Restaurant Side:
Pros:
Their food! They are my favorite in all of Staten Island
Best
–Mozzarella Corozza (Never enough)
–Rigatoni Butera
–Penne Vodka
–Chicken Parm with Potato Croquette and Vegetables
–Risotto Primavera
–Specialty Salads
–Fish Dishes
–Bread and Butter!
-$ 22 Dollar Lunch Menu for 4 courses
Cons:
Can be a bit expensive
Pizza side can be a bit distracting if curtains are open
Usually no wait to eat (Although sometimes the line can be outside the door)
Friendly Staff
Feeling like being at home
Great Italian ambiance

This is only for the pizza side, not the sit-​down restaurant.
The chicken parm sandwich disappointed slightly, with good cheese and bread offset by an inadequate amount of sauce and chicken. However, the plain slice was a revelation. The modest-​looking layer of cheese at the top gave way to gushing, enticing tomato sauce.
While you wouldn’t necessarily travel more than two hours solely for the pizza, the slice as another fun part of a «local tourism» journey to the last stop on the SIRT and the empty beach at Conference House Park.

We go to Villagios often only once I can say that I wasn’t very happy with my meal, I was happy but not very happy. The service is very good, they take their time and don’t rush you. If you need to get out in a hurry just let them know and they will take care of you. The food is very very good. The pasta is always cook perfect never mushy or hard just right. We have had quite a few different dinners from the weekday specials at 22.00 for everything from salad to coffee and dessert to ala carte dinners it’s all good. Fish always fresh Veal can cut with a fork. Rigitoni Butera with hot and sweet sausage is my favorite. You won’t be disappointed.

I live 5 blocks away and the one and only time I ordered from there my wife’s broccoli rabe was watery beyond belief and my meatball parm hero had 3 yes THREE small meatballs sliced onto it. I basically paid $ 8.00 for a footlong roll with cheese and sauce on it. Would NEVER go back.

I really like villagios. Good pizza and good rolls. They also have a restaurant area which I have not gone in, but it seemed nice enough.

I am pissed!
I flew 2600 miles across the country to get pizza in NY and KNEW from living here that you have to go to Brooklyn or John’s on Bleeker in the city. That seems to have not changed in the last 15 years since I left.
Unfortunately, I just landed in Newark, people I was staying with live in Staten Island, and we were crunched for time.
Yea, if you were to compare their pizza to the crap you get on Hollywood Blvd in LA, it would rate higher, but since this is NY, we are in a whole different league of rating pizza joints.
Go to Brooklyn, even if you live on SI. That’s what I did for 25 years when I lived here, and that’s where I’m hopefully headed tomorrow for a good slice before I have to fly back to LA.

5 stars for this family-​run restaurant with excellent food and wonderful service. Villagio did an outstanding job to ensure that every detail was perfect for our family’s special day. Highly recommend– and we will definitely be back!

My friend and I really enjoyed our meal here. Service was excellent! We had a pasta dish which was cooked perfectly and very tasty. Great garlic rolls served hot which I loved. I used to come here when it was Antonio’s. I will be coming back!

Very cozy spot! You can close your eyes and pick from their menu, chef knows what he’s doing. You have the try a chicken roll OR a brooklyn slice from the pizzeria. They have awesome weekly specials on the restaurant side. I love the «pollo vincenza» (chicken, spinach, and grilled veggies!)Deeelishhhh!

I moved to the island last year and tried many of the different pizzeria’s in totenville. Villaggio was by far the best. I have 2 children, one of my daughters is extremely picky about her sauce, so i was thrilled when she loved Villaggios pizza (no more cooking for me on friday)!!! They also make homemade pannino’s which i am a big fan off! My favorite is the chicken focaccia, which consists of fresh mozzarella, grilled chicken, and roasted peppers. They also have a restaurant which is very welcoming and cozy, The food is delicious and the service is impeccable. For all who haven’t tried this pizzeria/​restaurant i highly recommend it!