Brother’s Pizzeria

When I come here, I don’t always come for the pizza. They heave a great hot dish menu. Today I ordered ravioli with vodka sauce and cheese. (I asked them to go light on the sauce and cheese and they did.) Before my meal arrived, they brought out hot crusty bread and butter. Brother’s may be famous for their pizza, but I love their hot meals. Oh, BRING CASH! They do not accept credit cards.

Fast & accurate customer service ! Great fried calamari, it was super fresh ! Bangin pizza loaded w cheese. Staff is friendly & very easy on the eyes ! :-P large seating area makes it great to dine in.

I was transferred to staten from Brooklyn over a year ago and have been going to brothers since. I am addicted to their Sicilians. I can go through half a pie on my own… I have eaten a few different items on their menu and have not been let down. Their chicken parm heroes are delicious! The staff is always friendly and joking around. If it is your 1^st time or 10^th time there, you always feel welcomed. Only downfall is not with their food or staff, they don’t take credit cards, cash only…
I look forward to my cheat days so i can go devour 2 Sicilians and a cream soda!
Recommend to anyone in staten !

Best pizza ever I’ve probably been eating her since birth. Also their chicken parm rolls are delicious. But since I have up meat I went to their spinach rolls which are just as good.

One of the best pizza places on Staten Island! The square slices and chicken rolls are to die for!
The owners are friendly even when it’s busy. Give this place a try, you won’t regret eating the food here.

In town a few weeks, had to stop at the BEST pizza place on the island. My 2 Sicilian slices were perfect ! And the Vodka pie was also delicious. Will go back again when we’re on the island soon !

One of my favorite pizza spots on the island. This is our go to spot when we are craving a deep dish pizza slices, mozzarella sticks and potato crockets. Staff are So friendly here and the food is good. I also love the spinach roll and the grandma slices. This is a cash only pizzeria but they have an ATM inside that has a two dollar fee. Overall very good pizzeria!

The Sicilian Pizza Pie is the only thing I’ll eat from this place. Other than that, I have a few other spots where I can go to for specialty pies.
All other kinds of pizza pies, I cannot even get myself to enjoy a slice or two. The cheese on the pie has a funny taste and texture. Whatever they do the pizza pies, there will be so much oil dripping and most of the pies I’ll order is cheese or meatless. Where is the oil coming from?
My parents and I usually order Eggplant Parma, I couldn’t believe the oil that would be sitting in the dish and I would have to pour out the oil into a different dish in order to enjoy my meal. After awhile, I couldn’t finish my meal and the eggplant would be so tasteless.
One day, I happened to wait for a pizza pie and one of the counter guys opened the oven, I couldn’t not believe how dirty the oven were. I saw every food spills, ingredients and everything else that was in the oven, all black, It grossed me out. Not even have the nerve to sweep the oven occasionally. It is one of the reasons why I stopped ordering pizzas from them.
Another reason why I stopped going, I cannot stand the attitudes I would get from counter guys and they think they are all that or above all customers. Like wooopbeedoo, you had a few famous people or had best ratings in this pizza place. Show some respect to the customers and that will help you in the long run. Not pick and choose who to be friendly to.

Everything is always fresh and that chicken roll… TO DIE FOR! The counter boys are always in good spirits and willing to tell a joke or two while you wait. No other pizza spot for me on the Island.

They have been my families go to spot for the last 10 years, but the last two times we purchased a pie we were disappointed. Not sure what they did, but their pizza just doesn’t taste the same.

I love this pizza. The only thing that I can complain about is that they cut back on the size of the slices. You used to get a nice big slice of pizza. Now, they raised the prices and the slices are smaller. It’s still good, but you have to buy 3 slices instead of 2. The last time I went there, I ordered 1 slice. When I saw how small the slice was, I said «forget it» and walked out. I seems like instead of raising the prices, they lowered the quantity. The quality is still there though. I would rather they raise the prices again, and bring back the healthy size slices. I would have given it 4 stars if they didn’t have such small slices.

The best pan slices on the island I love this place it’s a Little pricey but it’s worth it … i been coming here for at least 10yrs I feel like family I walk it they know my name. Very nice guys nice place to sit down and talk with friends any day of the week.

Im dreaming of … Brother’s pizza. For just $ 2.50ish a slice you can get a square slice and a lot of satisfaction. Think that nice, thin crust, yummy warm cheese, welcoming tomato sauce, all topped with a bit of basil — and that’s how this pizza is like. It’s cash only, so be sure to have cash in hand people!
There’s also a sitting area if you want to have a larger meal, but I don’t mind walking out with it in my hand, making its way to my mouth.

The vodka pizza was very yummy and prices are very reasonable. They work fast to heat up your pizza and the place is clean. But bring your cash because they don’t take card.

Pretty great vodka pies at this place, their regular pies are good but nothing unique on an island flooded with pizzerias. They take cash only because apparently they don’t like to pay taxes, and they do not deliver. I find this to be a snobbish «we are above that» attribute. I mean really how many fucking pizza places don’t deliver?!
Anyway, the food is good. Staff is a bit jerky but that’s like 98% of the staff in any pizza place on Staten Island. They are known for their square pies but I find Frank and Danny’s to be the #1 champ of square slices, Brothers’ square pizza is good but nothing life changing.

What can I say they are the absolute best pizza on Staten Island.
It’s like family owned, once you go they always remember you, they always show so much love to me an my family. My boys love this place.
All fresh food.
Delicious

I like everything these guys make. Whenever I come back to visit NY I make my way over to Brothers Pizza place.

— over priced !!!
— Can’t stand the Staten Island Attitude from the owners family …
— pizza it’s alright for emergencies nothing else.
— sandwiches are ⁶⁄₁₀
Never going back!

Sicilian slice is on point. My friend had the lentil soup which was good. The place is a bit of the experience side but I recommend it.

Another Staten Island food institution
Famous for their sicilian slice, cannot go wrong provided you enjoy a thick slice of pizza
Eggplant rolls are fantastic
Reasonable prices given the quality of the food
Very busy at lunch time
Plan accordingly