Nonna Artemisia’s Pizzeria

Peanut Butter pizza is actually pretty good! Only gave 3 stars for the simple fact I haven’t tried anything else there yet!

Good food, good prices. I wasn’t sure what to expect with this place but I was pleasantly surprised. The pizza was really tasty! Great cheese to crust ratio with a little bit of sauce. The pepperoni is laughably large but still delicious.
My grandmother tried the buffalo chicken pizza and she said it was very spicy but delicious nonetheless.
The calzone was a bit odd… overload of cheese with verrryy little crust which was disappointing. It was more like a one-​adds crust pizza folded in half with no sauce and a pound of cheese. When I think of a calzones, I picture a huge crust not some flimsy cheese bread. Would not order again. It didn’t taste bad – just not my style.

Awesome!!! Ordered a cheese pizza, sausage pizza, garlic parm wings and the Southington masher. All very delicious! Wings are much bigger than usual. Plus nice delivery guy bringing my food, even though it is the coldest day yet in CT. My only request, a few more choices of mild wing sauces, like maybe a honey bbq. My new favorite pizza place.

A family of three adults came in for the Southington Masher (potato/​bacon). It was to die for. We all loved it. Everything was fresh and tasty. We started out with the house salad and finished with two cannolis. My life is complete.

I’ll preface this review by saying the only thing I’ve tried from this place is the Garlic Parmesan wings and that’s why I didn’t give them 1 star. No restaurant deserves a 1 star review based solely on 1 menu item, but dear lord these wings were horrible. They are nothing like what you expect from garlic Parmesan wings. Every place makes them, they’re all the same and they’re all delicious. These were wings sitting in what can only be described as a thick white unappealing looking sauce. You could barely taste the garlic and you could barely taste the Parmesan because of a very prominent vinegar flavor. The vast majority of these wings went right to the trash. Again, I’ll give 3 stars because obviously it’s just one menu item… But if the rest of the food is done as poorly as these wings I would be shocked.

Finally got to try Nonna’s this weekend. I am a pizza snob. I’d rather have no pizza than mediocre pizza and I’m glad to say that Nonna Artemisia’s is worth the trip for me. I ordered a chopped salad and a large cheese pizza. Both were enjoyable. The salad had a nice selection of fresh veggies and hit the spot. The pizza had some plusses too. The sauce and cheese were very good although the cheese was a little salty. The crust had very nice flavor to it and a nice chew to the end crust pieces. The crust underneath was not as crispy as I like, it quite soft actually but it was improved greatly upon reheating (stove top in a skillet of course) the next day. There are some other items on the menu that interest me so I’ll be going back to Nonna’s in the future.

Wings are impressive, bigger than the ones you’d get on average at Buffalo Wild Wings.
Their pizzas have delicious flavor, well-​textured crusts, and reheat to nearly the same consistency as when fresh! (complete with not-​too-​chewy crusts!) Also, they provide very good quality parmesan with each pizza as well as house-​made blue cheese (with wings) that’s made me an instant convert.
They deliver within Southington for ~free~, have really generous specials that mustn’t be missed, and are not afraid to lay down the spice, so be ready if you order anything spicier than traditional buffalo!

Closest we have had to a new haven style pizza in Southington! Delicious pizza, reasonable prices, fast delivery.

The sausage and mushroom pizza was good. I just wish the toppings would stay on the pizza.

Wow! What a great find. Don’t let the size of the restaurant fool you — the food and the service is top notch. Although, they only do have 4 tables for dine in, it appears that most of their business is take out and delivery.
My husband and I ordered the Nonna Stixx and chopped salads for appetizers. Both were amazing and very unique! A lot of the times I easily get bored w/​a salad, but the finely chopped ingredients made this so tasty! The Nonna stixx were huge! I was not expecting that much (bonus: leftovers!) They were very flavorful.
Although, they have a great variety of specialty pizzas, we kept it basic and ordered a small pepperoni pizza. Again, very flavorful and the crust was perfect.
When they brought out our appetizers, they went above and beyond by asking things we might require, extra dressing, extra plates, cheese, type of cheese, etc. (it was the lady from the kitchen — maybe the owner?) It’s the little things like that that I really appreciate they went the extra mile. We did want grated cheese — and one thing that I loved is when they look it out, they took it out from the refrigerator.
Our waitress was just as sweet and joked around w/​us as well. We never had an empty glass, and she made sure we had everything we needed. You can tell she really enjoyed her job, which is always a good sign.
We do live ½ hr away, but we will be back for sure.

quick delivery, quality pizza

Nonna’s pizza was excellent! True Neopolitan pizza. Perfect ratio of toppings to crust. We will certainly order from them again. Highly recommended!!!

I tried Nonnas for the first time last night and it was awesome. Finally there is a pizza place in Southington that’s worth going too. Pizza was perfectly well done, all very high quality ingredients. I would definitely recommend Nonnas to anyone who like traditional Neapolitan style pizza.

I’ve been enjoying their pizza for months now, and their Neapolitan pizza is genius. Give it a try.
The quality of their sauce and the delicious thin crust really makes their pizza stand out. Delivery is timely, and I can’t say enough about their fare. Their sandwiches are good as well, but really, their pizza is outstanding. If you enjoy really great thin crust NH style Neapolitan pie, try one.

After searching for an Italian style, thin crust pizza place in the Southington area, I was SO excited to try Nonna Artemisia’s. I honestly think it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had in my life. Thin crust, lots of cheese, a flavorful (but not chunky) pizza sauce, and the customer service was great as well. They have such an extensive pizza menu too that I can’t wait to try more! I would absolutely recommend this place and will order from them again.

Heard the pizza at this place was fantastic so my mom and I decided to give it a try for lunch. It’s true! The pizza is amazing! The sauce is so good with just the right blend of herbs and spices. We started off with Nonna Stixx which are basically strips of fried dough served with marinara sauce. These were HUGE and so delicious. Then we had a large Margherita pizza with chicken. Due to the large portion sizes there were plenty of leftovers to take home for lunch/​snacks the next day. The place itself is small, clean, and the atmosphere is great. If you plan to dine in get there early because there aren’t a lot of seats and you don’t want to miss out! Good stuff!

My boyfriend and I had $ 50 worth of food delivered to us. It was not good so we called them. The woman who answered the phone was very polite but when my boyfriend asked for the owner he heard him say, «I’m not dealing with this bulls***.» The woman remedied the situation by refunding our entire order. I wouldn’t have even written a review had the owner not disrespected us, but now I don’t care — both the food and the owner suck. This was a very bad experience but that woman made it slightly less horrible. She has got to be the only reason this place is still in business.