Cape Cod Creamery

Very good ice cream and a decent selection. Liked all the Adirondack chairs outside — very nice.

Certainly one of the best ice creams I have had. Way better than Toscanini’s in Boston which is so overrated. If you are ever in South Yarmouth you better go to Cape Cod Creamery.
Its fresh ice cream that is totally on a different level.
If you are into amazing ice cream in the East Coast try these places:
Vandervende Farm Cremeary, Seashore Hwy Delaware
Bent Spoon, Princeton NJ

Found this on Unilocal and decided to try. Worth the trip.
Had a very interesting double chocolate with cinnamon. Unique and delicious.
Highly recommend.

Tough to dislike an ice cream place and I’m not about to start.
The unique flavors and friendly servers make this place a win-​win. Try the Oreo (which was chock full of that wonderful cookie) and the butter pecan. My two-​year-​old got the cotton candy and, even without a sweet tooth, ate most of it. I had a bite and found it way, way, way too sweet, but I suppose that’s the point.
Fantastic idea for business to line the comfortable and colorful Adirondack chairs along the road. On a hot summer day, a bunch of people devouring delicious ice cream is an engaging advertisement.

Absolutely delicious ice cream. Their cookie dough ice cream, though a bit unconventional, was wonderful. Instead of the large chunks of cookie dough, there were small chunks in ice cream actually flavored like cookie dough! Outside there are comfortable Adirondack chairs to sit in while eating your ice cream. A New Yorker, I am no stranger to places like The Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory, but this is far and wide the greatest ice cream I have ever had. Absolutely perfect!!!

My fiancé and I decided to try the three main ice cream shops (school house, sundae school and CCC) that make their own in the Dennis Area!
Cape Cod creamery was by far the best! We have tried Oreo ice cream almost everywhere this was on par if not just as good as peaceful meadows which is our benchmark! Parking is a little hard and there is a bit of a wait but it’s worth it!

Best strawberry ice cream I’ve ever had. The line is brutal, but it was worth the wait. Go later when the line dies down.

The ice cream was okay. Variety of flavors, nothing too special though. The girls behind the counter seemed a little immature and were giggling about something (maybe my ridic sunburn) while staring at us until I glared back at one of them and she turned away. Plenty of Adirondack chairs lined up outside to sit and eat. If in the area again, would try somewhere else next time.

Excellent Ice cream with wonderful Cape Cod flavors. Long lines, but worth it. Parking is a bit of a challenge too. Needs more explanation of flavors, but all the flavors I had were excellent.

A key attribute that defines an above average ice cream parlour is a solid flavour selection. Here, I spent about 5 minutes pacing back and forth in front of the ice cream, as I struggled to make a decision — Cape Cod Creamery passed my first test. I finally settled on a Regular sized portion of Cake Batter and Sandbar Swirl in a waffle cone. I don’t know if it was the large waffle cone that I purchased for an extra $ 1.20, but the «regular» portion was definitely bigger than expected. Above average portions? Cape Cod Creamery passed my second test. The final and most important test — the taste test — was passed with flying colours as I vacuumed up the cone. The ice cream was beyond creamy and tasted phenomenal. When I found a golf ball sized chunk of peanut butter in the middle of my cone, I felt a small tear of joy leak out of the corner of my eye. Thank you Cape Cod Creamery

Absolutley delicious homemade ice cream! Creative flavors with cute Cape Cod names. The line was long but moved very quickly and was worth the wait!

Cape Cod Creamery, you’re such a dream.
Let me start by talking about the actual venue. 3 words come to mind: cute, fun, and energized. The ladies that work there are super adorable and friendly, especially considering how busy it is.
Now let’s talk about the ice cream. It’s the bee’s knees. Their flavors are unique, yet traditional (the only way to understand this statement is to visit the creamery). The ice cream is smooth and the helpings are huge. After reiterating that I wanted a small serving, the server assured me she gave me what I ordered. As the shock set in of thinking, ‘I have to eat all this??’ The server laughed. An hour later, I was in a food coma.
There’s ample seating outside if you want to enjoy your ice cream there.
This place is a must-​visit when visiting Yarmouth/​Hyannis. Enjoy!

I love this ice cream so much!!! Back where I live I have a farm I go to for ice cream. I’d never think I would find a place that compares to the farm but oh my!!! This ice cream is one of my favorites!!! I got the Oreo flavor today and it was out of this world. Colorful place, nice workers, great seating area outside, and lots of happy people. Please go here!!!

Very nice place to enjoy and ice cream treat. We got the twix and almond joy Icecream both were amazing. The employees were very nice and the have waffles and tons of different toppings. There is an awesome porch to sit on with adirondack chairs. Worth the stop!

Love the ice cream flavors… Love that there was no line when we went there (wednesday afternoon around 4pm)…love the plentiful outdoor seating… staff was friendly… Can’t wait to go back and try all the other ice cream flavors!

OH yes, truly excellent ice cream, although still a bit shy of Herrell’s in Northampton, MA, definitely a contender. Excellent service and layout and probably way too good a seating arrangement outside considering the view is of Route 28. (Although the mulch on the side seems a bit over the top. But we don’t put mulch in cones, do we?)
Only the extreme pricing keeps me from wanting to pin that fifth star on, because when I can’t feed two kids ice cream for less than $ 10, I am constitutionally compelled to start my old fart routine and think fondly of when our ice cream choices on the Cape consisted of vanilla or chocolate soft-​serv and if we were really lucky, a swirl as a third option, and we paid a nickel for three cones, and the cone machine was steam-​powered and we really enjoyed it even after walking uphill both ways to and from the Ice Cream Parlor. Because that really is just a tetch expensive.
Also, I can’t visit this place between July 4^th and Labor Day, because once you turn left on 28 into the parking lot you can never turn left again. Because the side street the Creamery is on leads to a dead end, you can’t escape. It’s like Charlie on the MTA, only being stuck on the T is far more pleasant than turning left on 28.
BTW, I’m fond of their raspberry lime rickey here, which is also hideously expensive but they put in a half a lime unsqueezed on top of the lime juice that was already in there, which is obviously meant for old sourpusses such as myself but which is soooo refreshing on the days when ice cream isn’t doing it for me. For that, at least, I am thankful and count it as sustenance when counting my pennies like Scrooge and waiting eleven hours for the traffic on 28 to let me exit.

We are ice cream afficonados and found the Creamery to have some of the best ice cream around. The menu is all named after towns on the Cape so we felt a little unsure and pressured to order when we finally got to the front, but it turned out to offer some of the best and most original flavor combinations we’ve seen. It’s also a good value as you get a boatload of ice cream, even for a small.