Kings New York Pizza

KING’S is the BEST In Shepherdstown, WV. Never had a bad experience or bad food eating here. The staff are very pleasant and helpful with ordering your food. The menu has a wide variety of selections to pick from, (I’m sure you’ll find your favorite). My favorites are the Grilled Chicken Salad (a must if you never had this), Italian Sub, Steak and Cheese (plenty of meat) & the Garlic Bows (served warm with sauce, very good, tasty). I tried the Jumbo Tiger Shrimp Scampi, (the flavor was delicious, the shrimp definitely Jumbo). Come in and enjoy a sit down dinner or grab pizza and subs to go. Definitely worth the wait when enjoying a great meal in a very clean restaurant such as KING’S.

Went in tonight and tried their NY style pizza. Ordered a medium cheese ($ 11.75). It was okay, but a bit too chewy for my tastes. The crust was thin, as NY style is, but it seems like they use of those machines roll/​press the dough — the crust was perfectly even all around. Right amount of sauce, and a good amount of cheese.

Great Steak Stromboli
This pizza shop is located at the end of the Food Lion shopping center. I arrived at 2pm on Saturday with the family, the pizza shop was empty. One other couple came in while we were there, they sat outside. There are a lot of tables to sit at inside and a few tables with umbrellas outside. They have some cool paintings and custom art on the walls.
We ordered garlic knots, the King’s Deluxe NY style large pizza, and a steak stromboli. The pizza was good NY style pizza, the end crust was a little tough and bland, but not terrible; the rest of the pizza slice was very good. All of the toppings were very fresh. For pizza, this wasn’t greesy at all, which was good.
The large pizza was $ 20. The garlic knots had very soft dough, they were brushed with garlic butter and topped with fresh garlic. You get 6 knots for a reasonable price.
The best score here was the steak stromboli, you can get a large or small stromboli. We ordered the small for $ 10 and it was great. It was like a cheesesteak wrapped in pizza dough. You can add peppers, onions, and mushrooms to make it just like a cheesesteak. This stromboli was loaded with cheese!
This place was pretty good, we will most likly return.

The food is great and the pizza pretty amazing for a small town. The service is generally slow but everyone is very pleasant and customer focused — except for tonight when I left my hat and sunglasses there — I called as soon as I realized this and the person on the phone found them. Yay! When I told her I’d be in tomorrow to pick them up she bizarrely replied «I’ll put them up but if they aren’t here tomorrow when you come back we’re not responsible.» Really? Let’s just say I reacted less than favorably to that boneheaded example of how to effectively convert a very delighted customer into a profoundly disappointed one. Admittedly, I need to be more careful with my hat and sunglasses but that was a major customer service fail.

The pizza is pretty good, closer to NY style than other places in Shepherdstown. The subs are good, though they have a tendency to overcook their meats. I used to get the chicken cheese steak but after too much dried-​out chicken, I usually get the Super Italian sub, which is loaded with deli meats and cheese.
The stuffed meat lovers pizza is ridiculous (in a good way). One slice, filled with sausage pepperoni bacon and other pork products, is a huge meal in itself; a full pie will give your entire family «the itis» for a couple of days.

Came in tonight with the kids. Ordered garlic knots and calamari. Garlic knots were burnt and calamari was over cooked by a minute, therefore a little rubbery.
When we ordered for dinner our server, who was very polite and friendly ordered my daughters adult dinners instead of kid dinners and placed a dinner order for me instead of sandwich. She did square it away and did a great job at fixing the order.
She left plates pile up but through training I’m sure she will understand how to clear the table. Chicken Parmesan sandwich was good, and kids pasta and chicken fingers were good. It’s odd that the kids ravioli had 4 pieces of pasta and the Chicken tenders and fries had 5 chicken tenders with a huge plate of fries. Both were the same cost, yet I’m puzzled as to why the difference in sizes. They lost money on chicken tenders but made up for it on the pasta, plus charging full drink prices for each kid. Certainly not an economic choice to eat out with kids. Pizza was excellent according to my son and priced accordingly. The sauce is different than the NY pizza I’ve had but the cheese and dough were pretty close
It was not a busy evening in the restaurant, perhaps they had a lot of pizza orders and take out which threw off the kitchen.

This kings has the edge over the other ones. Pizza, Pasta, Salads and Subs are great, but there service and interaction sets them apart. Good Place!

Been biking all day and stayed in Comfort Inn who recommended this place. Very short walk. Nice décor. Great staff. Very friendly and helpful! Absolutely great food! Spaghetti and sausage was huge. Came with bread and house salad. Great! Seafood platter was very good too. Prices very reasonable. We never ran out of water or tea. Could not eat it all. Very satisfied!

Great sub for a great price. Ordered the Super Italian Sub lunch combo. Came with fries and drink, all for $ 8 including tax. It was a full 8″ sub. They baked the sub so the roll was hot and crusty and they had hot pepper relish– a must for Italian subs. Fries were hot and crispy. Very clean establishment. If you are looking for an less expensive lunch alternative in Shepherdstown, King’s is great.

Great subs, cold or hot! I got a cold veggie sub and a toasted eggplant and both were worth coming back for. The Pizza is ok. Prices are a bit high.

Worst Kings in the Area. Garlic knots and eggplant parm sub both had a microwaved, soggy bread kind of taste going on. Garlic knots seemed deep-​fried and tasted of dehydrated garlic, not doused in fresh chopped garlic in butter as the Martinsburg locations do. Tomato sauce was too salty, not sweet, as the other locations carry. Tummy ache soon followed. Only decent thing was the salad.

Good for the area, but definitely not NY pizza. Prefer their subs/​dinners to the pizza.
Wish they wouldn’t overcook the pasta so much, and am not a fan of the mozzarella they use. However their sauce is quite good, and not overly sweet like most chains.

Really good! Huge, huge portions!

Oh, yes, authentic New York pizza pies and other dough delicacies with a HUGE portion and a big price. Definitely worth it.

Out of towner who dropped in for a late take-​out the night before Thanksgiving. King’s was folksy and customers were patient and cheery. Took a chance on ordering a Stromboli and was rewarded with a huge, perfectly cooked pizza turnover with ample cheese and good ingredients. Took a few minutes, but I didn’t mind. These people know what they’re doing.