Wise Guys Diner

Nice little family run restaurant that is very accommodating has a good selection on their menu they are biker friendly so if you should arrive on motorcycles you will be welcomed. This is not repeat NOT a biker hang out but don’t be surprised if you see motorcycles in the parking lot they are also great supporters of American veterans and the Patriot Guard Riders of New York I can tell you from experience that their omelets are awesome and your coffee cup never goes dry I would highly recommend this restaurant for anyone looking for a great meal at a reasonable price

Small family run– but dirty and in need of major updating. Been here 2x and just wont go back!

1.5 /​5
Surprised this place hasn’t been reviewed yet, it’s been around a while.
Place seems like a nice little diner, and it is. Upon walking in I noticed it was one of those «regular» places. 3 tables, each with older people, all who knew eachother, 2 waitresses (one was the owner I believe?), and just a decent seeming place. The place itself is «mafia» themed, thus the name. I was excited to find what I thought might be a place to come by frequently. Pretty soon I realized, UNLESS I’m frequent, my service was going to suck.
After sitting, it took me 5 minutes to receive a menu, 10 minutes for my drink to come, 15 minutes for her to come take my food order after telling me «one minute and I’ll be back» after putting the drink down to go and bring someone their food that came up, then stay and chat for about 15 more minutes, and I saw my food sitting on the counter for another 10 minutes before it was brought over. All in all, service will lack terribly if you come in while regulars are there.
While looking through the menu I noticed it was pretty basic overall, burgers, sandwiches, plates.
So, I, being from Rochester, did the most Rochester thing I could. I tried their plate out.
After finally being able to order the food, and seeing it put in quite a bit later, I looked at my phone to realize I had ALREADY spent about 45 minutes here and gotten almost nowhere. When my food came up a bit later, I looked at my phone, then again, it took 10 minutes for her to actually bring the food to me… I was incredibly disappointed in the wait, and fairly disappointed in the food.
Now, it may have been from sitting out for a bit, but the burger was incredibly rough and dry, and honestly a bit hard to cut with a knife (Which made this awkward sawing sound that food probably shouldn’t make), I tried to take the flavors in, but honestly there wasn’t many. The sauce tasted like it was premade & purchased, not made fresh (I could be wrong, just going off the flavor). The Homefries were all incredibly soggy and lacking any form of flavor. The one redeeming thing was the mac salad which I could tell was probably pretty tasty before becoming warm from sitting out so long.
All in all my meal here took about an hour and a half, and only 15 minutes of that was eating.
I give it a 1.5 because for the regulars of the establishment, it seems like one of those nice places. And I could tell they all enjoyed their service. The place itself was clean. And the food came up quickly (Although getting to me took some effort.). The pricing all seemed very reasonable as well.
I would really like to come back on a day without regulars being there to try some food as soon as it is done, however, I personally won’t be eating here again.

Family owned diner. Friendly and fast service. I am there 3 to 4 times a week. The best hot sauce in town