Godfathers Pizza

Great place for casual date or when you’re in the mood for pizza. Don’t let the small amount of customers deter you from enjoying this wonderful establishment. When you walk in you are greeted and then you can order. The menu is simple and well laid out with sizes for the pizzas demonstrated on the walls. A medium pizza would be great for two people, especially if you plan on getting desert. You can then pick a seat for yourself in a great seating area. If your heart is set on a booth you will be out of luck: there’s only tables at Godfather’s Pizza in Redwing. Service is prompt and the pizzas are hot and delicious. I really enjoy the pizzas themselves but I know that most customers are more excited about the desert pizza. This is likely my favorite desert pizza ever. Its density is perfect, just sweet enough, and you can eat it without getting too sticky. Normally, I’ll spend around $ 23 here for my girlfriend and I and we will be adequately stuffed. A great location for those looking for a great value on pizza, a quiet place to eat, and the best desert pizza you’ll ever eat.

Great pizza and delicious desert pizza
Friendly staff
Clean restaurant
Great atmosphere being in the old restored pottery building. You can antique shop after eating in the neighboring stored in the same building too.

Great pizza for delivery or in the restaurant. Employees have always been very nice. Love the historic and clean atmosphere in the old pottery building.

Decent pizza, but HORRIBLE hours!
What pizza place closes at 800pm on weekdays and 900 on weekends?
I have gotten attitude from most of the phone people when I call. Try Liberty’s. A bit more spendy, but MUCH better pizza and hours!

The guy who took my phone order was an a55 hole. The pizza was ok, but that was the last one I’ll be ordering from them.

We have been to Godfathers other locations for the lunch buffet and have always been pleased, we were in Redwing and stopped in at 1:30 for lunch buffet and we encountered one of the rudest persons we have come across in a while, he said if you people want the buffet fine but were not going to be putting out anything else… o.k. pizza that was out looked so so (not much out) my friend ran to the restroom and I was standing at the counter waiting to see what we wanted to do, the whole time he stood there breathing hard and rolling his eyes at me. When my friend got back and we figured maybe get a reduced price on the cold leftovers and he snapped at us 1.30 per slice, we were treated so rude that we looked at each other and laughed as we walked out the door. By the way there buffet is supposed to be open until 2:00. If this person hates working there so much why not get another job? If I owned the place that jackass would be fired… by the way we are very polite people. Anyways I would suggest another pizza place, we will never go back there again

Stopped by for lunch and had the all you can eat buffet. Pizza was nothing spectacular but above average and tasty fresh. Good value!