The Sweet Tooth Fairy

Literally the best cupcakes I have ever had the privilege of consuming (and I don’t use the word «literally» very often because I’m not really sure what it means). The Samoa is my favorite, followed by whatever raspberry-​chocolate delight I had this week! Unfortunately, it’s a little above my cost range.

I love the look of their cupcakes and their décor, but that’s about it. I don’t love the taste. They’re okay, but always seem a bit dry to me and heavy on the frosting. They’ve recently moved to Center St. in Provo across from the new temple, and it’s a cute little stop, but there was no music playing when we went in, and it was so quiet and awkward with them waiting for us to order. I mentioned how awkward it was probably 5 times but I’m not sure they understood. Just turn on your iPod or something…

We were visiting from WA and someone pointed us here because they thought the cookies were better than Ruby Snap’s cookies. So, we decided to see for ourselves. We got half a dozen, which was basically one of everything in the case. My first bite was a sugar cookie — it oddly tasted like coconut. The second bite I had was a black and white (chocolate cookie with white frosting), it tasted like coconut. The chocolate with chocolate frosting tasted like coconut. After that, I stopped tasting them. I don’t know if they use coconut oil in their frosting or what, but every cookie had a coconut after-​taste. We should have headed to Ruby Snap where every cookie tastes like whatever it’s supposed to taste like and is thick and chewy. We ended up leaving the rest of these at a relative’s house for her kids to eat. They didn’t seem to care.

Terrible on everything the service was terrible. We walked in and the girl came put from the back and didn’t even welcome us. Didn’t ask me what I wanted didn’t try to explain anything after a few minutes I had read over everything decided to try a peanut butter cup cupcake. The girl didn’t even tell me the total until I handed her my card she didn’t say thank you or enjoy or anything. Then she promptly retreated while I sat down and tried to gag down my Betty crocker cake mix cupcake that was dry and the frosting left a terrible taste in my mouth. I looked for the clerk to ask her how they make the cupcakes. She was gone. I was very disappointed in my $ 3 cupcake that would’ve taken me $ 3 to make a dozen that would’ve tasted way better!

Just ok. Really expensive for what you get. You can buy sweets that taste better for more than half the price at a local bakery.

So far I’ve only had the cakebites. They LOOK really good and they have a wide variety of flavors. I’m always slightly disappointed once I bite into one, though. The cake is really really rich and not in a good way. You’ll feel like you ate a pound of fudge after just a few. $ 2 a pop is also a lot… you’re basically getting ONE Oreo sized piece of cake for that price.

Most all of the treats here are too sugary if there is such a thing. My wife loves them though so we end up here a lot. The one treat that is not too sugary? the coconut cake-​bite. Very enjoyable but too pricey for my liking.

Super cute place for cupcakes. They were good, not the best I’ve ever had but tasty. Lots of different choices of cookies, cakes and cupcakes
I
Give it a try

Golly, this place is precious. I got a new cavity just waiting in line.
The cupcakes and cakebites… okay. Flavor options are plentiful; yeah, they’ve got Red Velvet and Salted Caramel — all the fads are represented. The cupcakes are beautiful. Even the cakebites are pretty. So beautifully decorated, you almost forget that you’re paying $ 2.35 each, and a buck for a literal BITE of cake covered in frosting.
For a Friday afternoon, the place was relatively busy. The ordering process was delayed only due to those who couldn’t decide what to order. The counter service was acceptable, but definitely failed to harmonize with the overall theme which, to me, screamed «friendly and sweet.» The attitude here was more like «hurried and bothered.» No matter — we got our Salted Caramel and Chocolate Peanut Butter cupcakes for the grown-​ups, and a Dulce de Leche cakebite for the little guy, and left.
The first «issue» was getting the cupcake out of its super cute packaging: a plastic cup with a lid, basically. It fit so tightly in there that the only means of removing it is by tipping it upside down and catching it in the air.
Did I mention that the lidded plastic cup is also fully decorated in STF attire, as well? My second problem with this is the fact that at least $ 1 of the cost of this cupcake is very likely its over the top packaging. In my reality, «cute» is worth about 10 cents.
I attempted to eat my cupcake in one sitting — this was a mistake. Despite the unobjectionable flavor, I reached sugar overload after four bites. The other ²⁄₃ of my cupcake had to be reserved and eaten over a period of four hours. The cupcake itself, without all the décor, was quite standard. It’s obvious here that presentation is paramount over taste.
Bottom line: the items I’ve tried at STF are far cuter than they are actually delicious. Will I come back and try more? Probably. I’m still looking for the one that lives up to the hype.

Decent Desserts but found that he employees were not interested and not helpful. After my wife asked for a sugar cookie the girl asked what I wanted and I asked what cupcake was good in a cupshake she stated that she didn’t like them but maybe chocolate if I liked chocolate. It kind of just turned me off before I even tasted there product. Cocoa Bean has a better Cupcake.

Their cupcakes are VERY overly sugary, they are gross. My kids and I love cupcakes, but really don’t like this place. The only reason I give it two stars is for the cute décor. Save the calories and go some place better!

I go there for the red velvet cake balls. Amazing. Best cake balls I have ever had anywhere.

Ehhhhh I have never fully embraced the cupcake trend. I love me some sweets, and the cupcake is cute but tends to leave me wishing for a different dessert.
This store is adorably decorated and clean and bright, so good in that regard. The cupcakes are as good as any other cupcakes from a cupcakery– equal parts cake and dense frosting. For me, it’s way too sweet and heavy. And what is with those stupid cake bites that I keep seeing? Smooshed up cake mixed with frosting?! Covered in candy coating?!? For heavens’ sake people! Just writing about this stuff is almost making me reach for an insulin injection.
Overall, as good as anywhere if you love cupcakes. I just wish someone would make cupcake flavors that aren’t quite so sugary and a little more original.

Really disappointed in the cupcakes here. I have been here twice ordering more than a few both times and I never finish them! They just don’t have the right flavor or texture for me. The cake bites seem to be covered in candy coating made with shortening, not my fav. I highly recommend Cupcake Chic close by at the University Mall area.

I really don’t get all the fuss? I wanted to try this place because the cupcakes LOOK so delicious, but the taste is just bleh. I was really surprised, and disappointed
I have tried other places that are cheaper and better than this place. Bummer. :(

Naming a store for 2 forces that have such a racket over dentistry is a delicious irony. I found it to be the most delicious part of my visit.
One would think a store devoted to all things sweet would have through all other concerns to the wind and develop the best treats, bar none. One would be wrong.
I got a baker’s dozen cookies and for me and the men at my office. We sampled the full variety of offerings, but in the end they were just store bought cookies. Most were unoffensive, but to think I could have gotten Keebler Elfencookies just as good for a quarter of the price made me sad.

Love the cupcakes and the flavor is amazing. Certainly a splurge, which is fine because the frosting is so rich you might have to eat just a half of the cupcake and save the rest for later!
My only complaint was the service. One time we had to wait for a bit for someone to come out and help us, and they seemed annoyed to have to serve us instead of continue the conversation they were having in the back. The other time the service was prompt, but also not very friendly.
Still, can’t beat the flavors of the cupcakes!

This is a cute little sweets shop located in a strip mall. We bought an assortment of cupcakes :
=Strawberry Shortcake-​yummy-​I like that the real strawberry on top of this cupcake was dipped in chocolate (it shows that they go the extra mile)
=Black and White– Very moist-​good-​my sisters favorite
=Vanilla– Basic –good
=Key Lime– I was excited for this one but I thought it could have been more citrusy, a little bit more tangy.
=Red Velvet-​good –I’ve had better
=Dulce De Leche– Good– moist– needs a more stronger flavor
I also got a yummy butter cookie decorated like a cute flower!
All in all I liked this place, I was excited to read that they are opening up a location in St. George which is an hour and a half away from Vegas. (St. George is a quick Vegas get away!!) However, when I was in St. George earlier this month they weren’t open yet. I hope they open soon…

Ahhh… I wish I lived closer to this slice of heaven! Delicious baked everything… and the place is SO STINKIN cute! I’m their fan on FB and they are always making my mouth water with pictures of all the yummy baked goods coming out of the oven.

I thought my shake had coconut in it, until I was halfway finished and realized that it was a wrapper. still tasted kinda good though.