Amalfi Restaurant & Pizzeria

This place had me worried in the beginning. After the workers had given our party plates and utensils I said «grazie». The worker corrected me and said it’s «gracias». I thought, «oh no. it’s a Italian restaurant but they are Spanish!»
When we got our food, all was well. They were delicious and the portions were big. I would definitely return if I am in the area again.

One of several pizza places in Port… definitely not Port’s best.
Things it has going for it:
— decent atmosphere
— plenty of parking, if shopping center isn’t crowded
— seems clean
— wait staff is friendly
Things it has going against it:
— food is only average
— can get crowded on weekends
— you must tip in cash. If you tip on your credit card the waitstaff does not get the tip… they do have a small sign stating that but if you go there a sit down and order you wouldn’t know.
Will not be going here again. Don’t want to go in depth with this place since I learned what they do with the waitstaff’s tips. There are too many choices in Port to settle for this place.

Everything we order from here is delicious! I ordered a salad today, I forget the name, but it had avocados, craisins, walnuts, and fresh mozzarella chunks. It hit the spot, order one!

I’m telling you, this place has better Italian food then some of the more expensive places in town. You can’t beat the prices here for what you get and the service is always great as well. I would recommend this place to anyone!

This is one of the most wonderful local eatery in America. The owner and his staff show tremendous courtesy and attentive service to all. While professionally egalitarian, owner and crew exhibit do rarely seen anymore in Restaurantland: loyalty to frequent customers. Great food? Friendly ambience, cleanliness,!fast service and ’ small’ town service makes Amalfi one of the gems of the dining world.

I love the Mac N cheese pizza and most of their pizzeria items. The guys making the pizzas are friendly. The reason why I’m giving only one star is because I found out they tried to charge an extra $ 110 on my card in addition to my actual bill, which of course I will be canceling with my credit card company. As much as I enjoy the food, if you’re going to steal my money, I can’t respect you anymore.
*EDIT*
Turns out the reason why they charged an extra $ 110 was because they used my card for someone else’s order. THIS IS VERY SHADY because I used my card during lunch, and they charged the $ 110 in the evening for dinner orders. Why in the world did they have my credit card information saved?! DO NOT USE YOUR CREDIT OR DEBIT CARD AT THIS LOCATION.

Great Gluten free pizza! Worth trying if you have not, it takes 15 – 20 min for them to make it, so have time.

Ventured into Amalfi after seeing its high rating and positive reviews on Unilocal.I must say, we were a bit surprised after our experience there. While it is a neighborhood joint and a pizza place at that, amalfi is presented as a restaurant. I found the service to be mediocre, lacked knowledge of the menu and was inattentive.
Chef’s salad was unimpressive and perhaps a bit skimpy. We ordered two pasta dishes as well, sadly both were a bit overdone. Pesto was also a big disappointment, i didn’t inquire but it seemed canned/​bottled and was lacking in taste.
Would potentially give another try but would much sooner suggest Ginos or Peppe Rosso on manorhaven blvd for a similar restaurant experience.

My favorite Italian food in Port Washington Area.
Friendly Staff, Huge restaurant with over 40 tables available.
From Pizzas, to Pastas, Salads, Soups, Sandwich. This place has a Huge menu.
My Favorite is their Fried Calamari (Fresh and not chewy).
My Entrée varies every time I come here (Since I want to try everything). Their Linguine with Clam on White sauce is my top spot.
Sometimes I order the Chicken roll which is pretty Big and delicious.
But nothing have failed me, Everything what I order here is pretty solid.
I always Skip Desserts because i get so full (portions are pretty big).
Staff is very prompt and friendly.
Food comes pretty quick

This is my favorite pizzeria in Port Washington.
The staff is wonderful, the food is delicious and the prices are very reasonable.
I have never had a bad experience here. Many different slices and Italian dishes. You can’t go wrong with anything you choose.
Be careful about going midday though, the place turns into a nursery with all the children running around. My mom loves this place and my GF does too, what other women in the world do you need to keep happy?
The really exceptional thing about this place is even if you come in for a quick slice. Servers will attend to you. It’s not needed, but it’s great. It makes you feel extra special.
If you want a flavorful meal, this is the place to go!

Pizza and select pasta dishes I’ve tried are delicious. Bread is okay, I wish it was cooked a little more. Other than that, I do like coming here once in a while.

Lots of delicious pizza, buffalo slices are good, lots of place for seating, ample parking, friendly staff, fast service, great selection.

LOVE LOVE LOVE Amalfi. We have been going since it first opened and go at least once every two weeks. Whether its take out or eating there we’ve never had a bad meal. My fav is their chicken parm I could eat it everyday. It’s always so fresh, the chicken is perfectly fried and the marinara is delish. It’s also smothered in cheese for all you cheese lovers out there. You can tell its cooked to order. My brother loves the penne ala vodka with grilled chicken. I want some chicken parm right now. The portions are huge and you always have left overs. The staff is super friendly and Raphael the owner always has a smile on his face and you can tell he appreciates your business. Go to amalfi you won’t be disappointed!!!

High-​class pizza place. The restaurant is a pretty cute place. Good for casual family dinners. The pasta dishes are wonderful. A bit too oily so I like to ask to use as little oil as possible. My favorites are the ravioli, baked ziti, and lasagna. Salads are amazinggggggg! It’s odd how some of the best salads I’ve ever had are from Amalfi. Also their bread is warm gooey amazingness.

I come here often after working late to pick up dinner.
My go-​to dishes are eggplant parmesan, angel hair with bolognese sauce and rigatoni pesto (add grilled chicken). Their pesto is one of the best I’ve ever had (very creamy though) but their eggplant parm and bolognese are hit or miss. I’ve had them VERY fresh and also a bit undercooked. Overall, I enjoy my meal from here and always have leftovers.

Really sub par Italian food. If you are looking for a full pizzeria menu, go to Gino’s uptown. The food in general is just better. After reading the other comments of children in the restaurant i realized my parents only took me there when i was little… thinking about it now because the food is cheap and the food was so-​so

The staff are very friendly, the pizza and linguini with clam sauce are very good, I would give 3 stars except the wine was spoiled. And the service was a bit inattentive. Though nice.
Someone else mentioned that mothers with small children seem to like this place, I found this to be true too, the dining room was a playroom for a few kids.

Great little Italian restaurant tucked into a strip with Home Goods and Stop and Shop. Don’t be fooled by the location. The food is homemade and a great value. The service is off the charts with the staff constantly monitoring all of the tables. Chicken Parm, Pastas, Soups and even the Pizza are all worthy of mention. Best of all you won’t spend a lot to eat well!

I remember coming here when it was La Stella… Post-​renovations, this place is beautiful. The staff is extremely friendly and the food is top-​notch. Most times you walk-​in, the place is crowded, which definitely proves the pizza is one of the best in town, along with their pasta dishes.
On any given day, the variety of pizza slices is so tempting, that while an order heats up, i tend to add to that order just out of temptation, lol.
The regular pizza is above average, but their buffalo chicken slices, along with the salad slice (w/​balsalmic vinegar topping) is amazing.

Yum! The staff is pretty friendly, and the place is always bubbling with people. I forget exactly what I’ve had there in addition to the pizza/​rolls, etc. But I remember a black spagetti, with spicy red sauce with squid — it was deliciousss.
Totally a fan, for sit down or take out.