Bagel Station Deli

I love their chicken salad. The one with the dried cranberries and walnuts. It has just enough mayo. I have tried to make my own but it’s just not the same. I like their bagels a lot. No they are not as good as NYC bagels, but the best in the area. I like the French toast one and blueberry one. The service is always pleasant, and quick. The store itself is rather small and there is usually congestion in the parking lot. But that should tell you something right there. They have fresh coffee and hot water for tea, that you can fix the way you like it. I can’t wait to go back. I think I’m going today. Not a great place to go when you’re watching your carbs.

Never go there for cold cuts!!! I bought $ 35.00+ worth of cold cuts there. I asked for American cheese sliced thin and they pulled off a chunk of pre sliced cheese product, wrapped it in paper and put it at the bottom of my bag. I didn’t realize what happened until I got home. I called and asked to speak with the owner and he said «the other cheese is for sandwiches !!! I gosh ! What? Don’t go there for cold cuts! Yuck!

Right on the way to Mongaup, in and out in a minute ’cause I’m always late and a fresh bagel and good coffee when you need it. Get’s me fueled right for the river. Did i mention it’s right on the way to the river.

Went there on the recommendation of a regular patron who offered to buy lunch for our group. Ordered 2 sandwiches, two bagels — one with butter, one with cream cheese and two donuts. Took the bag they handed us and went home.
Got both sandwiches, which were very large and very tasty. I would almost say a little too big for the hard roll they were on, as the rolls had a difficult time keeping the contents inside. Expect a messy, over-​sized sandwich if you go.
Got the bagel with butter, a bagel with lox (which none of our party cares for) and no donuts.
Went back to complain, they told us we were not being truthful as the member of our party, who is a regular here, is in every morning with her boyfriend and orders a bagel with lox every day. Both the member of our party and her boyfriend assured them they have never ordered a bagel with lox.
To make a long story short, they offered to give us the donuts, but we refused. We felt the lack of customer service, the angry attitudes and flat out untruthfulness of their statements was so outrageous we felt uncomfortable and have decided, as a group to never return.

Bagels, bagels, bagels! Delicious bagels. Everything else is sub-​par. When I’m forced to work in Port Jervis I stop by here for a bagel. I’m a sucker for scallion cream cheese and Bagel Station does it justice. I dislike the location and space, the menu isn’t the best. It’s not on my top 5 for bagels but it’s the best in Port if you must stay within a 5 mile radius.

The help is pleasant and quick to take your order and order came out quickly. Had a bagel sandwich and it was very good. This is probably not a place I would go for just bagels as they are not up to the caliber of what a call an excellent bagel but I would certainly try their baked goods and other sandwiches. The place was pretty full with the locals dining in and taking out.

Coming from the city you sort of expect a place like this to have friendly people behind the counter. This is not the case at Bagel Station. The cashier was so incredibly rude to me and my two companions – first, she was annoyed because she didn’t charge for the 2 bottles of water I set in front of her upon ordering, accusing me of not telling her I wanted to buy them (but despite this I left a generous tip); then she and her staff rolled their eyes when I asked if it wasn’t too late to use cheddar cheese on my breakfast sandwich. All three of them just stared at me and refused to do anything… it was actually bizarre. I walked out of this restaurant with a bad attitude and an inedible, american cheesy-​breakfast that ended up in the car garbage 10 minutes later. Still hungry :(

The bagel sandwiches here = pretty good. Hearty and good value. The bagels themselves = pretty average and actually kinda tasteless, especially the wholewheat ones. A bit of a shame, but this place is definitely very handy.

We’ve been here a few times and the food is always excellent. You get a lot for what you pay for, service is great, and the blueberry bagels are the best bagels I’ve ever had!