Pieroni’s Pizza

We have tried the pizza here in the past because they have some great offers via text so we decided to try it for a quick lunch since we were in the area. We tried the lunch specials. I got the chicken sandwich, a soft drink and fries for $ 7.00. I wanted the chicken pasta salad but was told it would taKe 25 minutes to prepare so i passed. My husband got the special with a beef sandwich. He added cheese to it for an extra $ 1. The sandwiches were a nice size and tasted ok. The bread on my chicken sandwich did not seem very fresh but the chicken was seasoned good and they put 2 breasts on the sandwich. My husbands beef was good but too spicy for me. We decided at the end of our meal to grab a couple beefs to go for parents. We did not order anything special just beef on bread. It took 25 minutes to get our to go order. He apologized and said he was the only one working but honestly it was not very buisy and I just dont understand why it took 25 minutes to put beef on bread and wrap it up. When he finally prepared it i watched him and it took all of 2 minutes.

This is the best local pizza I have found. Great cheese sticks too.
I liked their thinner crust, but get a bigger size because it not as filling.
Their calzones are awesome.

Friendly staff, dead on the delivery window, but the pizza is just so-​so. Bland sauce and crust, and a bit on the greasy side. Sorry, but Life is too short to eat mediocre pizza…

Great pizza and great service! They always get the pizza to me in a fair time and the prices are fair, I think it’s so much better than most places around here.

They post prices for pizza combos, but then ring up a cheese pizza & charge for each topping individually (at $ 1.70 each).
I ordered a medium ½ Mexican ½ Ham & Pineapple — the menu says (both online and on the huge chalk board hanging there) that a medium «specialty pizza» is $ 15.40.
When I get there, she charged me $ 18.55 for the pizza (plus I ordered wings & got my kiddos a soda while we waited, but this is just about the pizza price so I’m not including that).
I asked her about the price difference (it’s obviously more about principle than the measly $ 3.00) & she said «oh that’s because we have to ring up the toppings individually… because of our system.» To which I replied «that’s lame.»
Our pizza wasn’t ready yet so we waited a few minutes, which was just enough time for me to actually get mad about the whole situation. When the order was up, I asked her to speak to the manager. She said «that’s me.» I told her I was having a problem with the price being changed.
First she tried to argue with me & show me a little chart that shows the tax, then we went back & forth a couple of times — at one point she also started to mumble something about «well you also got a half and half» (the other half was 2 toppings… so by that logic, I really should have received ½ of the cost of 2 toppings discount. Kidding, but you get it).
So I said «come on, you’re telling me that the other half, with less toppings should cost me $ 3 more?» Then she jerked a drawer forcefully open, pulled out $ 1.85, & chucked it across the counter at me (while she’s doing this I said «you know that you have reviews on Unilocal exactly about this, claiming that you charge incorrectly, right?» And she sputters «WELL! That guy… was WRONG!» [Me: uh ok]
Then she turned around, pinkish-​purplish hair & all, & stomped (literally, & loudly) into the kitchen & slammed something down. Then I started laughing & left.
But really… shouldn’t she have given me $ 3.15 back?
The worse part is I actually loved the pizza!

I just moved out here to Plainfield and I’ve been trying to find a decent pizza place (and believe me, there is A LOT of pizza places going on). Based on the Unilocal reviews I decided to give this place a shot and had a pizza delivered.
They said the delivery was going to be an hour to an hour and a half and although I was a bit upset about the long delivery wait, I couldn’t be too mad. I think the Blackhawks were playing that day. Anyway, I called to check up on our order an hour later and they said they were making it and it’ll be on its way.
I was VERY happy about this because at least I knew the pizza would be hot and fresh and it wasn’t sitting and waiting on a counter for delivery. It’s nice they care about the small details!
I ordered their super peroni in their traditional crust. Pizza was pretty delicious and the price wasn’t too bad. I’d definitely order from them again.

Love, love, love this pizza! After moving away from my old go-​to pizza delivery place, I was on the hunt for a new favorite. I tried a few places in the area, but had not found quite what I was looking for. This place fit the bill! Great thin crust with an a amazing texture, delicious sauce, and every topping I have tried has been great! Also, the delivery is pretty fast. I’ve never waited longer than 45 minutes. I definitely recommend this place to any pizza snobs looking for the real deal.

Best pizza in Plainfield! I have been a customer for about 5 years and never had any issues. Great place and awesome text specials!

Ordered a pizza about an hour and 20 minutes ago. It just arrived and it SEVERALLY under cooked. We order from here all the time and it is normally cooked well. We called to speak with a manger and instead, we heard the person who answered the phone say «here, want to talk to this guy, he wants to speak with a manger» the young kid named Brandon proceeded to answer the phone and when we voiced our concern and stated we would like someone to come pick it up, Brandon proceeded to say «sorry for your convenience» and he hung up with phone. This will be our LAST time calling this pizza place.

great consistent ZA!!! good pricing with the coupons… ive tried all the joints in naoerville, this is the best for the money in my opinion. fast friendly and always very polite. if you want a good thin crust go here you will be pleasantly surprised… between 4;30−6;30 it is very busy if you can wait go after the rush…

You know I love there pizza, but I tried to call them 5 times this evening (Plainfield) and kept getting voicemail and I left phone number for a call back and I received no call back. Not sure how you can let that happen so I had to buy from someone else.

I use to love this place however last night will be our last time. I don’t know if it was because of buy one get one but the pizza was thrown together like they didn’t care. Dry and burnt. Yuck!

The boy and I were out shopping and we used our trusty Unilocal app to find a pizza joint, and we landed at Pieroni’s. I wasn’t expecting too much because the burbs has let me down MAJORLY for pizza. Well Pieroni’s proved me WAY wrong.
I love when pizza places sell their pie by the slice because from that piece you know if you want to A) Evacuate the premises or B) fall in love. Well B was my pick. I ordered a slice of pepperoni. It was perfection! The crust was nice and thin, with a nice crispness to it! I wanted to slap my mama, and then go dig up my granny and slap her! (Sorry granny lol!!) I so wanted another slice, but that would’ve been pushing it because the slice I ate was big enough!
Pieroni’s I love you, and will be back in the future. There are tons of pizza places, but they don’t do it like this! #Boom

Best Italian beef outside the city.

All in all it was pretty good. Delivery was fast, and the pizza arrived hot. The pizza was good, it just wasn’t the best I’ve had. Really no complaints.

One of my favorite pizza places in Plainfield. They use a stone oven instead of running it through a belt or a spinning thingy like most places do. I personally get their «Veggie» special well done and it’s delicious. Sauce is sweet and dough/​crust is quite good as well. Good selection of appetizers if that’s your fancy, and their Italian beef sandwiches? Delicious, highly recommend them. And I don’t know about the guy who said they charged for pie cut, but I got it pie cut for a relative and saw no price difference.
check ‘em out, if anything try one of their slices!

Best pizza in Plainfield. It’s my Go-​To.

We eat pizza approximately once a week and either the reviewers in the past don’t know what GOOD pizza really is or there is an imposter in our midst!
This pizza was cold dry and somewhat flavorless. I have had better frozen pizza. It was like getting a slice from a discount mall vender.
Sorry to say it but I would not return. I am always open to new pizza purveyors but have to give this one a thumbs DOWN!

After trying many pizza places, my husband and I have decided that Pieroni’s is the best by far. I have only ordered the thin crust, and it is always crispy. The sauce is flavorful and like the other ingredients, is the perfect amount. Their pizza is consistent. We have yet to get a bad one. If your looking for a new pizza place, I highly recommend Pieroni’s. They deliver to Oswego too!

The thin crust pizza is great. I must admit thought that we haven’t tried any other crusts. The sauce is very good as is the quality of the toppings. We always get a pizza and a side of sausage with sauce.
Delivery is pretty quick and the people are nice, but the pizza is expensive and they charge more to have it pie cut. We like the pizza, but we haven’t been back since we found out they charged more money to cut it less. The price of the pizza + charge for pie cut + delivery charge, makes it even less of a value.