Cormacks

Looking for the best sandwich in the area? Look no further. They have a wide selection of salads, soups, and sandwiches. Never leave hungry or disappointed.

Cannot believe this was my first time!!! We come to petoskey 2 – 3 times a year and I will definitely make this our lunch place every time we are there! The sunflower bread is amazing!!! Can’t wait to come back to try the chicken salad!!!

Very good sandwiches and soups — outstanding selection from a varied menu. It is worth the price to eat here if looking for a casual place for lunch. The place is only open during the week and closes at 6:00, which is fine. However, I went at 5:30 to pick up some carry out for dinner and they were already closing up for the night, putting chairs on tables and turning off lights. This does not make a patron feel welcome. If an establishment advertises to be open until 6:00, then it needs to be completely open until 6:00. If it wants to start closing at 5:30, then advertise it closes at 5:30.

Great sandwiches and deli items. Cabbage roll is good. Can’t go wrong with a turkey sandwich. A guy here said Nates Mitch is the best, but I haven’t tried it yet. Nice views of the lake. Can get pretty busy in the summer.

Terrific sandwich (chicken salad on sunflower bread) Huge sammie with lettuce tomato and tasty chicken salad. They make their own bread and holy cow; it is so fresh, tender and flavorful. I could only eat half — it was huge. We had a bowl of soup, which was also fresh and tasty. They have a ton of options, food in cold cases to take away as well as pies, cookies and other desserts. Located off hwy 31, open Monday thru Friday. Come here for lunch. You will not be disappointed!

Amazing… We ate here twice so so good. We highly recommend anything with the sunflower bread. But I had a Greek with turkey, feta and spinach ! So amazing my daughters loved theirs as well. Seriously GO EAT HERE!

Tons of great creative sandwich options served by a friendly and helpful staff. Don’t let the lines scare you. They make a custom sandwich quickly. The broccoli salad is weird. Who cares, you came in for the huge sandwich.

AMAZING I am a very tiny person 90% of the time I don’t finish all my food. I’m the annoying girl asking for a box with half my food still on my plate. The sandwiches here are so fantastic that I will keep on chowing down even when my stomach is telling me to stop. The Long Island is amazing. The bread is so perfect if you have never ate a sandwich with warm bread you are missing out.
If I lived closer I’d be here everyday.

Easily and consistently one of the best sandwiches I have ever had, I always enjoy eating here.
My one and only gripe: They are not open on the weekends, so I don’t get to go here as often as I would like.

First I have to confess I didn’t eat there. Stood in line and the menu and food looked great. As I approached the place to place my order we were told alternatively that it would take 25 or 45 minutes to get our food. That wasn’t going to fit the schedule, but what ticked me off was the delivery, neither one looked like they gave a crap whether I ever ate. I’m telling you, if I had a business that was that good I would deliver that kind of news with the biggest shit-​eatting grin you ever saw.

Love this place. Soup is amazing, love the Reuben sandwhich. It’s a little pricey but well worth it

This is… by FAR… the best deli/​sandwich shop I’ve ever been to. A huge variety of sandwich choices, usually at least 4 choices of delicious soups, equally delicious varieties of salad choices AND fantastic baked goods including unbelievable cookies and pies. The list goes on & on but the sandwiches are just incredibly delicious & HUGE! I always considered myself to have a fairly good appetite but ordering a small bowl of soup AND a sandwich — - the women who wait on me quickly say, ‘I’ll cut that sandwich in half so you can bring the rest home with you — you won’t be able to finish it’. I laughed the first time I went there and, low & behold — walked out with half the sandwich that I finished the next day! They must have like 30 – 40 sandwich offerings— all shown on the big wall above the working area. Can’t say enough great things about this place — - the only negative I can offer is they are only open Mon-​Fri— NO WKND’S! But there are other great eateries in Petoskey to try so no big deal…

We were visiting Petoskey and looking for a good deli. And we DEFINITELY found it! Food was made quickly and it was delicious. Big portions and great taste. We also had the cheesecake brownie which was out of this world. We liked the casual atmosphere. The only downside is that they are only open M-​F. We would have gone back again over the weekend. Definitely check this place out.

Amazing deli. Always busy around lunch for a reason. Family owned and its great to see the whole family in there year after year. The food is A LOT of food, so be prepared to share, which allows for more tasting options. Haven’t had a single thing on the menu that isn’t outstanding. Favorite of all time is the Guido. We would schedule our trips to Petoskey to be there on Friday for the Clam Chowder and a Guido. So good!

I’ve eaten at delis in NYC, Philly, Chicago and San Fran and this rates right up there with the best of them. Had the corn beef, pastrami and cheese with russian dressing and it just melts in your mouth. Wife had the Italian and loved it. Bought a homemade pie to take as a gift and friends loved it. Don’t skip this place for lunch when you visit Petoskey.

Can always count on a great lunch at Cormacks. Nothing beats the tomato bisque soup. Sandwiches are large and filling and tasty. Sit outside on the deck for a beautiful view of the little traverse bay.

Delicious sandwich loaded with toppings. We went in with a group of 9 and they had our food out very promptly.
Beautiful view of the bay, helpful staff that had been around a long time. Plentiful seating. We will be back soon!

What a find! Love this place. I only wish they were open on the weekends. I had the tuna melt on raisin bread and my husband had the chicken salad. Both sandwiches were huge and delicious!

I really like cormacks. Great deli sandwiches, and the soups are always good. Not super great, but they’re good.
I wish they were open on weekends and over spring break, but I guess when you have a place as busy as this place is during lunch hours when you are open, you can afford to close up shop when you want.

This is my kind of place, a small hometown deli set across the highway from a beautiful view of Lake Michigan. I guess my one complaint is that the sandwich that I ordered (a Turkey Reuben) was too big – but is that even a complaint? I was very hungry when I came here and I’m a man with a very healthy appetite, and I had to struggle to finish half of my sandwich. My advice to Cormack’s would be to reduce the size on the sandwich with a corresponding price reduction. But maybe that’s just me…
Regardless of sandwich size, if you are in Petoskey for the day, Cormack’s is more than worth a stop!