Amy’s Grill

Food was good. Everyone we ate with seemed to really enjoy their food. Wasn’t quick service at all, and pretty pricey

Don’t listen to the bad reviews, you’re not going to find better food in Pauls Valley. It’s that simple. Pro Tip: order the sweet potato fries, I’ve had many different sweet potato fries all over the country and I’m not exaggerating when I say these are the best I’ve ever had.

The quality of the food is above average. The Reuben sandwich is exceptional. Burgers are fat and juicy. The sides are acceptable as well. Potato salad is well prepared. If it wasn’t for the slow service and turn around to get my food, I would have given 5 stars.

Typical small-​town family place full of kitsch. I was very impressed with the selection – burgers, sandwiches, salads, other entrees. No matter what you wanted it was there!
Most importantly, the food was good. It’s really difficult to make steamed veggies tasty, but they were perfect. Loved my chicken wrap.
A great place to stop on 35!

Thank you Amy’s Grill for making my 17^th anniversary spectacular. My wife and I could have gone to OKC, but wanted to do something different so we went to your restaurant without knowing what to expect. Wow were we surprised. She had your sirloin with whiskey sauce and I had your ribeye. Both steaks were more tender than we have had in years and the flavors… well lets just say steak sauce was not needed. Your stuffed mushrooms were the best I have had anywhere. The you surprised us with a piece of your Italian wedding cake… that was phenomenal. At the end of the meal we went out on the patio and listened to some live music which was on par with the rest of the evening because they were awesome as well. All in all we could not have gone to any restaurant in the OKC metro that could have been any better.

Staff was very friendly and welcoming. The food was very good and made from quality products. It was a very nice atmosphere to enjoy a diner with the wife.

There’s not many unique options in Pauls Valley. Unilocal help me find three non-​chain choices. The staff at the Hampton Inn helped me to narrow it to Amy’s Grill, tucked away off the highway, down a frontage road, behind a Shell station.
I was immediately intrigued by the grape vines as I pulled up on a rainy night the day after Oklahoma City was ravaged by multiple tornadoes. The staff inside informed me that it was once a working winery and steak house prior, but the vines were no longer attended to. There is a local wine on the menu, although the name eludes me.
The menu reflects general American fare and I ended up going with the 12 oz. ribeye which came with salad, potato, & vegetable side. I skipped the potato option and decided to double up on the fried okra (yum!). The steak was solid, good char, cooked to medium rare, and the right amount of salt. I enjoyed the herb & garlic butter and loved the okra!
The staff was phenomenal, friendly, and courteous. If I’m ever in the area, I will definitely return to Amy’s Grill!

Great food. Very well done. The veggies were perfect, the pot roast and rib eye were delicious. Of course, any loaded baked potato is amazing! Make sure not to miss out on the wonderful, fluffy dinner rolls. Can’t eat just one.
Nicely decorated, clean, great service. Will definitely make a point to stop again on my next trip through.
Only one complaint. The parking lot is a mess. There is room to expand the parking lot, and it desperately needs to be done. When we arrived, we almost went somewhere else based on the condition. When we left, the restaurant was not full, but we were almost completely boxed in the lot. One small thing that would give this establishment 5 stars.

Very nice staff but not very well trained. Took forever to get food out and then the steak and sweet potatoes were undercooked. Sent the steak back to be cooked up a little took forever to get it back. And again, it took way to long to get our check after we finished eating. Nice atmosphere but disappointed.

Excellent place to eat in Pauls Valley. Wish they were in the city, would eat there weekly. Sandwiches and Potato soup were fresh and amazing. They have a full bar. The patio seating is very nice, giant firepit, good service. Clean modern place. Will eat here every time we pass thru!