Nancy’s Pizza

Their smaller deep dish pizza is absolutely delicious! They don’t overdo it with cheese or sauce, and are not stingy about adding whatever you decide to have in it. If you have a taste for something else then they have a pretty big menu of other things to choose from like chicken and great Italian beef sandwiches and more. The people who work there are really great! They treat you very respectfully and get the pizza done well, as well as having it ready for you on time! I highly recommend them for carry-​out since they do not have a dining area.

I am perplexed by Nancy’s. The pizza will always be my top choice in comparison to other places. It remains delicious on all counts, and has been consistent over the years I’ve been coming here. The original deep dish w/​sausage is a favorite of mine, but you have to be in the mood for that amount of cheesy goodness. Mainly the thin or super thin sausage & mushroom is my go to pizza. Nancy’s uses fresh mushrooms, and you can obviously tell the difference over canned mushrooms at many other pizza places.
Now onto why I didn’t straight up rate this 5 Stars. The pizza as stated is great, the other menu items I’ve just recently begun trying not so much.
1. Breadsticks, I’ve been getting them on & off over my last couple orders, usually they are very good however sometimes (like last order) they’re dry and bland. **sometimes they completely forget the marinara sauce.
2. Zucchini, just tried it about a week ago and it was terrible. It was very lightly breaded even though the menu states double dipped and it was barely cooked. Now it’s most likely because I’m used to fried zucchini, and this was baked. However, besides that I was still very disappointed because ***they also forgot the marinara sauce.
3. Sandwiches, the only one I’ve tried is the «Godmother». It honestly wasn’t bad. However it wasn’t great and a tad small for the cost. The chicken was flavorful, but there could of been more of it.
TL:DR — Pizza is delicious, ingredients are usually very fresh but other items on the menu are mostly a let down. (Have yet to try pasta) ***Nancy’s if you’re reading this, be more mindful of the # of side sauces an order is supposed to contain.

I’ve had the pizza and it’s fantastic. It will never disappoint, but I felt like a meatball sandwich tonight. Once I got the sandwich home, unwrapping it felt like Christmas morning. I was filled with excitement and once the paper was off, I gazed at its beauty. The first bite assaulted my taste buds in a good way. The flavor was incredible and I scolded myself for not trying the meatball sandwich sooner. It was excellent. I can’t wait to try some other stuff on the menu now besides their delicious pizza. This place has it all.

We ordered for the first time last week and it was sooo good! The crust was perfect and they put just right amount of sauce and lots of toppings and cheese.

Order from Nancy’s last night for the first time. We order a cheese pizza with ½ green peppers. The crust was not crispy the cheese, sauce an green peppers were just fine. The pizza crust was to soft and had no crispness to it. Would have to think twice about ordering again from here.

This place has really good pizza like all nancy pizzerias have but the only problem is its a little on the expensive is side but u pay for what you get so its pretty good, you should try it