Manny’s Sicilia Pizza

Just walked in here on a whim, I will absolutely be back for more of this garlic dipping sauce! It’s seriously mouth watering amazingly addicting. The plain pizza is very cheesy, but very good! Great tomato sauce too!

Returned to Manny’s on Friday night this week.
More people in there than the last time I was there. Problem was a bunch of teenagers who thought this was the school cafeteria. Also the tables weren’t bussed so I had to look for a table.
The waitress was friendly but a bit inattentive. Took a while to take my order and also took a while to bring the soup and main dish.
The soup, a seafood bisque, was good. Once again the spaghetti was a bit over cooked and the sauce lacked seasoning. The garlic bread was nothing but an six inch roll with garlic butter. Very soggy. The bread wasn’t toasted.
I may go back again and try something other than spaghetti.
It seems most of these places make a basic marinara sauce which they use for all dishes. Put it on the spaghetti, add some oregano and then put it on the pizza. No one makes a basic Ragú. Still looking for that place. Only one I ever found is at home. Hmmmmmmmmmm?

I own a small business in town and the office is constantly picking up or getting delivery’s from Manny’s. They all say the pizza and sandwiches are excellent. Unfortunate with my food allergies my favorites are their salads which are huge. I’ve asked for special orders and never had a problem. Service is friendly. If your in palmyra and looking for a quality casual Italian restaurant, or just want to grab pizza with the kids I would suggest you stop here.

Manny is the King of Broad Street. He has great food and he cares about everyone that walks into the restaurant. He is also very involve in the community. Friday nights is always a favorite night to dine there. Great seafood bisque soup and love his famous pizza dip.

I’ve gotten takeout from here many many times. Never actually eaten in here. Pizza and sandwiches are OK. Nothing to write home about. Kind of like the atmosphere in here. The wings are probably the best thing they have here

This place is awesome, I personally did not order pizza here so I cannot account for what that tastes like. However I did order a steak and cheese Stromboli and goddamn it was the best Stromboli I have ever had. Not just the filling the actual crust itself was really tasty perfectly cooked not burnt or raw really awesome place to come eat at. I also ordered the wings and got their 801 sauce I believe it is called it was the awesome-​st sauce I have ever tasted because they basically mixed all the sauces they had together and put them on the wings so you got like 8 different flavors in your mouth at once. tangy sweet spicy salty. So awesome, I know what you’re thinking why would anyone do that and if you are you should just shut up and try them just saying. I will be back here sooner then later and I recommend everyone come here because you will never experience wings like this anywhere else.

Best restaurant in the area! This is also not a kid hang out for pizza. This is a family pizza restaurant. Love going to Manny’s from the staff to the food it is a great time out. The staff is wonderful. The food is amazing. The pizza is fresh and tastes great with the dipping sauce. The sandwiches are filling and there is a nice variety to select from on the menu. Wings are large, and flavorful (hot garlic are my favorite). Soup! Oh my! The soups are outstanding. Always end up taking home a container of the Italian Wedding Soup.

In my opinion, Manny’s has some of the best pizza around, with the exception of their Sicilian ironically, which is the reason for 4 stars instead of 5. Their regular cheese pizza is great. You can tell he uses traditional methods in making his sauce, so you can tell their is almost no sugar added (if any) and you can taste the basil and garlic without it being over powering. Their white pizza is my personal favorite, plus the dipping sauce you get when you order delivery is amazing.
I haven’t had much else on their menu, but their wings are pretty darn good for a pizza place.
Their staff is personable, their prices are reasonable and their delivery has always been exceptional. Add in the coupon stamps and it definitely is worth it.

I’ve been going to Manny’s for years. The hot sandwiches in particular are very, very good. I also enjoy their pizza, however, it could be a bit more well done or crispier at times. The people there are also very nice and friendly.