Cookie Cards

***BAKERY HAS CLOSED***AS OF 12.22.14***
The only way to begin the review process is to give a STAR RATING. That being written, I am writing to say I am SAD THAT I NEVER had the chance to order from them. My husband tried the cookies and said they were fabulous. And then, as a merchant, I had a need for a customer (mother of the bride) who was looking for a recommendation for sweets for a bridal shower. I gave them 5* based on my husband’s taste test and the fact that they COULD HAVE made Gluten Free cookies for me! THE OWNER is looking for a buyer according to their voice mail. If you know of anyone that might be interested in purchasing the bakery, PLEASE CALL 847 496 7929 and leave a message.

I ordered a gluten-​free chocolate cake for my daughter’s engagement party. Not only was the cake beautiful, it was also light, moist and flavorful. If you’ve ever had gluten free cake, you know it’s not easy to find one with all those qualities. Totally yummy!
Thanks Cookie Cards!

«The only things you’ll regret in life are the risks you didn’t take»
With that being said, I regret not getting a bundle of the coconut macaroons from here. When I think about what I had to lose (between $ 5 – 6), it seems so senseless to have deprived myself from potentially limitless happiness (I have high expectations when it comes to baked goods) those toasted little suckers could have brought me.
Conversely, I’m oh so happy with the baked bundles of joy I did happen to purchase and partake in. The strawberry caramel blondies and the strawberry lemonade cookies.
The blondies were the perfect brunch-​time treat to pair with our afternoon coffee. Soft, decadent, and cut into bite-​sized pieces making them perfectly pop-​able as we sat on a nearby patio table.
The strawberry lemonade cookies weren’t exactly my top choice, but I saw my partner eying them so I went for it. The cookies were bright pink (my least favorite color) with little beige chocolate chips in them. I wasn’t quite sure what to expect upon first bite, but they tasted exactly like Country Time pink lemonade. Tart and sweet, ultra soft and easy to break off into more manageable bites. It wasn’t the kind of cookie you could eat in bunches, as it was so tart and sweet, but that was good for portion control.
The cookies did seem a bit pricey (6 for $ 5, in most cases), but having a storefront and all the fun stuff in it adds up so I can see how they got to that price. I also noticed (after I’d already bought my stuff and left) that they have a Unilocal check-​in offer for a free decorated cookie AND you can also purchase a $ 5 for $ 10 Unilocal Deal… which I will totally utilize next time.

LOVE Cookie Cards! We have eaten just about every cookie flavor offered and have enjoyed each one. I have had cookie cards delivered to me that were adorable and tasted awesome. I have also shipped a cookie card to my husband (it’s one way to their heart… right? Ha!). He loved getting it and eating it! When I get my car worked on over on Colfax I try to swing by for a few bags of cookies for the guys too, they love them! Swing by if you haven’t tried them yet, you won’t be disappointed :)

Order my daughters birthday cake from this place. It was a cake of Elmo and absolutely perfect. She loved it. It was so creative and well worth it.

Cute little store in a great location. I picked up some of the s’mores cookies, awesome! The folks at the store are really great.

Cookie Cards is great! They are always coming up with a new selection of fabulous treats. They have always been generous in supporting the community too.

I tried Cookie Cards because they’re in my area and I saw from their website they make gluten free cookies. The cookies are available on Saturdays but they will gladly bake them for you any day of the week if you request them. I tried both the sugar and chocolate chip and for a gluten free cookie I have to say they were awesome! Really moist and delicious. I was so pleased and really thank them for making these products. My family also tried their normal cookies and couldn’t have been happier. We will return often.

Amazing cookies and the best custom cakes :). I ordered a custom snowflake cake for my daughters birthday. AMAZING and delish

I like this place. Bought an assortment of cookies for a party a few months ago and they were a hit. Tonight went in and loved the macaroon sample, but walked out with the lemon shortbread cookies.
They are a bit expensive — but I enjoy them.

I recently had the pleasure of getting a custom order of cookies for my sister’s baby shower. The cookies (which were different colored baby onesies with white polka dots) turned out cuter than I could have even imagined! The quality of the product (both in appearance and taste) as well as the beautiful packaging was beyond outstanding. Furthermore, the order process was easy. The owner is creative and flexible, and prompt in answering questions via email. Though I am glad to have baby shower insanity over with, I look forward to using Cookie Cards Inc. again for custom cookie favors.
I have also had the opportunity to sample a variety of the «regular» cookies. From pumpkin chocolate chip to thumbprint to shortbread — everything is delicious! I have rated Cookie Cards Inc. as «pricey» because Yes… you are going to pay more for cookies than you would at a large bakery. That said, I believe the prices are more than fair, and definitely worth it if you are looking to treat yourself or someone you love!

I recently ordered some cookies from their St. Patty’s Day specials for my spousal equivalent’s birthday. The mint chocolate chip was tasty tasty and I absolutely LOVED the lime dreamsicle cookies. I’ve had the orange dreamsicle ones as well and they are fabulous!
I didn’t get them this time around but the coconut macaroons are also fantastic. I had everything shipped to me and not a one was broken. Will order some again for my son’s birthday in July.

I was at the salon across the street when I noticed Cookie Cards on the way to my car. Sounds amazing, no? I went in to see what kind of cute desserts I could bring home, but the selection was pretty small and it had the appearance of a special order place more than a typical bakery.
I tried the Mexican Chocolate cookies, which were a bit on the dry and crumbly side (I prefer my cookies soft and chewy), and the flavor was a bit too sweet. It did have a bit of a spicy aftertaste, but it wasn’t something I would go back for.
I also picked up some cupcakes: peanut butter banana and cinnamon graham cracker. Both were okay in terms of texture, but flavor was average.
Cookie Cards seems like a good option if you’re looking for a unique gift, but it’s not a good options for your everyday desserts.

Love this place! Great cookies. Cool custom options, specialty flavors, as well as your old time favorites! YUMMY!