Chicago Brothers Pizza & Pub

Don’t get your hopes up people. Pizza set up there for 29 minutes until bartender decided to bring it. Couldn’t get a beer at bar. Bartender is clueless. Finally said loudly. What do have to do yell to get waited on! Got pizza it’s wrong. First time trying. Get your act together. And start by recognizing you have customers!

First time in the area and was looking for pizza and beer. Beer prices were great but the pizza was just ok. There was seriously an entire onion on the pizza. Too much. All and all it was ok.

Super nice staff! They were attentive. There were alot of choices in this area, but we chose to go back because we were treated so nicely. Very, very wonderful people that create an easy and nice atmosphere. Food was good, service was spectacular! Highly recommend this place.

On a pool day at Tan Tar A Estates we decided we needed some lunch. If we didn’t want to go the chain route of Pizza Hut, it looked like Chicago Brothers Pizza was our next best option. Less than a mile away, we called and ordered 4 pizzas for pickup in about an hour.
Having lived in Chicago I can say this isn’t really Chicago pizza. It’s like Pizza Hut deep dish. However, it did the job and was better than Pizza Hut. We ordered the buffalo wing pizza which was awesome. Word of caution: we don’t remember seeing jalapeños described on the menu but they came on the pizza. Personally I love jalapeños so I’m not complaining but just an FYI.
The pizza was cheesy and delicious, and even better when we came back from drinking all night.
Only complaint besides not being real Chicago pizza is that it wasn’t ready for about 20 minutes after we were supposed to pick it up, which is annoying.

Loved the food, loved the service. Cold beer. Ashley was our waitress, and she was awesome! !!

Really awesome pizza, and they do have the best balls at the lake, meatballs that is. The service was great, nice people who are happy to talk, and provided great service. Totally coming back again

Was on vacation with my family of 18 and needed a GOOD family-​style pizza place. Well, this place will not disappoint! Firstly, the pizza is delicious. We ordered cheese, meat lovers, veggie, and chicken florentine.
Our server was super accommodating and friendly. They typically only sell pitchers of beer, but if you ask they will do soda! This restaurant is also non-​smoking!
Karaōke starts at 7pm and we were seated directly in front of it, but he kept the volume down not to disturb our party. We even had some people in our party participate (this was not planned) and it was hilarious! All in all it was a great time and I would highly recommend this place for pizza with a family!

Such a disappointment! I was so excited to get some deep dish pizza, but what I got was a sloppy, soggy nightmare. In no way is this deep dish pizza. It was more of a poorly done New York style. The bottom crust was so soggy and greasy, we almost had to use spoons to eat it. I will never order here again and if anyone asks, I will absolutely recommend that they save their money and eat elsewhere! I’ve had better pizza from pizza hut!

So I was in town for a wedding and was looking for a place to eat. I picked up my trusty Unilocal app and started looking for what was nearby. This place popped up and it was rated 4 stars and it was a pizza place. «Four stars and pizza», I thought, figuring you can’t go wrong there.
Well It finally happened folks, I was wrong. On the outside you wouldn’t even know the place is there if it weren’t for the big sign out front. It’s pretty unassuming. There was a banner advertising a pizza buffet all the time for a great price. «Winning», I thought.
Upon entering it was anything but a pub feel. Run down dive bar would be more like it. In the back of the room I spied the pizza buffet which consisted of ones choice of two different pizzas and a salad bar. Two pizzas, seriously?
There was one waitress in the place and she was doubling as the bar tender. Over the course of the meal she was very difficult to get a hold of. I actually ordered our appetizer of cheese bread (which was absolutely delicious BTW) as well as a drink refill from her, by walking across the room to the bar.
The food took forever to come and in the end it was honestly mediocre at best (aside from the above mentioned cheese bread).
Now if you want a great dive to go watch your choice of sporting event on the weekend, this would be the place. There are tvs everywhere and plenty of seating. But to call it a pizza pub is just entirely misleading. I will not be venturing here again sadly.

Service was fast, friendly, and cute! Thanks Tessa! Had the Hot Wing pizza and I strongly recommend it. The only knock is their draft selection. They need more craft selection, especially with Boulevard Brewing Co. being distributed in the area.

Wasn’t expecting much, old strip mall average lookin place. In the mood for pizza, ordered Chicago Stuffed deep dish. A little different to the good. Stuff should be illegal, my tongue bout lapped my brains out, BE CAREFUL! 5 star rating was for the food. The facility and atmosphere are appropriate for the price.

Awesome place to just walk in and sit down! It’s very… home-y…I guess is the word.
The food is amazing, especially the pizza. I had some kind of «stuffed» pizza, though I don’t remember the name. I would say this is the sports coverage capital of the area. There were at least 10 TV’s in the area that I sat in, all on sports coverage. Baseball, football, hockey, soccer, the whole 9 yards! Anything, any time, they’ve got it!
The reason I gave it 4 stars it because of cleanliness. I’ve been there multiple times and almost every time, the table it either sticky or it has crumbs on it. There is also trash under the tables. Other than that, great place!

A great place to just come and relax. The food is great and the atmosphere is laid back.

Great service. Fun pizza atmosphere. The lunch buffet is good and fairly priced. They make you feel like they want your business and that seems to be hard to find anymore. Thanks for a great lunch… David O.

Had 9 couples (18 people) stop buy after our Sunday Nigfht Couples League @ Sycamore Creek tonight. (several reluctantly I must admit) Bottom line was you had 18 very happy customers. The food was excelent, the pizza special was a big hit and everyone was very impressed with the new no smoking rule and that the Kareoke didn t start until 8:30! Kareoke warm up started at 8:25 and most of the 18 were out the door by 8:27 but happy with full stomachs! Thank You Stacy & Jeff !!!
PS: Our league moves the start time back to 4:30 in two weeks and hopefully we can convience more of the 27 couples that we had tonight to join us at Chicago Brothers instead of driving all the way to Millers Landing & Mexicalli s to sit outside to avoid the smoking where the bugs get nasty after dark. NO SMOKING NOW so show some support & the food is great!
Denny Hanner
Sycamore Creek Sunday Night Couples

Great local hangout. Stopped in on a Sunday and had a great pizza. Super nice Bartender who knew the menu. Prices seemed cheap, bit not complaining. They have the NFL ticket so I was set.

This place was an ok place to eat. I had wings which were the smallest wings I have ever seen about half the size of my pinky finger, if you like wings don’t get these you will be disappointed. How ever I had a calzone which was good and you could make your own and choose from a multitude of toppings but ease up on the garlic butter. My waitress did a fine job no problems there. Over all it was ok.

Quality food and enjoyed the atmosphere. Can get loud but I founder to be a nice experience with good service with several family members working the tables and bar. Been back a couple of times now and give it a thumbs up.

This your best bet for pizza the the lake!
Sports style bar & pizza joint, great for college game days!
A bit on the smokey side, wish they would pass the no smoking law here!