Maggie Moo’s

Love this place and the unlimited mix-​ins! The staff is always friendly and I really enjoy the earning reward points and coupons towards my birthday ice cream.

I absolutely love this place! I love, love ice cream but seldom eat it… I only eat it when it will be extremely satisfying to last me a while. Maggie Moos fits the bill everytime!
They have great flavors, standards and rotating flavors, and then you can have them mix in your favorites. Personally, I love chocolate with caramel & raspberry. They put it on the slab and chop it all together. Then you can have it in a cone, cup, waffle cup.
They also make great cakes and cupcakes. My family orders these from time to time for birthdays and celebrations.
If you want an ice cream, skip the boring places or grocery store and hit Maggie Moo’s!

This is ‘THE BEST’ ice cream shop ever!!! We used to have one in Fleming Island and for some reason it no longer is here. Now when I travel back home or crave this spot, I will travel to Orange Park Mall and order a quart for $ 7.99 of ‘peanut butter galaxy’. This mixer is just amazing. They may not have it listed on the board but as they have other flavors. My family also enjoys cotton candy ski jump and cheesecake break.
They went up 2 $ in their prices but it’s worth it. It may be because they partnered with Marble Slab. Not a fan of that place as I’ve had it once and their ice cream seemed a bit oily. I really hope they do not change Maggie Moo’s ingredients for their delicious ice cream.
They have an awards program that you use your cell number and every Monday if you go, you receive double points. You also receive coupons on yummy items through the app as well. It’s a pretty neat.

After strolling around the mall, a friend and I decided to go in here on a whim. We both did not realize that Maggie Moo’s was also owned by the same company as Marble Slab Creamery. No matter. I’ve never had ice cream prepared on a slab before so I was a bit excited. I decided to blend Dark Chocolate and Banana together in a regular waffle cone, no toppings. Boy that was way more than I thought I would get and it was totally worth it. It was also pretty cool that they had cupcakes of the same flavors as the ice cream. I was almost tempted to get one of those as well but I looked back at my waffle cone and decided maybe another day. The staff were super friendly and while the place was pretty busy they managed it well. I’d be back if was in the area.

This is a great ice cream shop… I absolutely love this place.
There are a lot of flavors to choose from… But I always stick with my norm of a strawberry milkshake with chocolate chips mixed in…
The employees are very friendly… They don’t mind letting you try different flavors…
The shop is kept very clean and the prices are very reasonable…
I prefer Maggie Moo’s over the other ice cream joints.

First of all, I have to echo Carlos C.: I absolutely love this place! When we’re at Orange Park Mall (which is often), we generally always get an ice cream fix. Sometimes it’s from Baskin Robbins or Yogurt Mountain, but most of the time it’s from here.
Even though they have their main flavours all the time such as vanilla, sweet cream, chocolate, and vanilla, they change up their other flavours and they also have seasonal flavours. For instance, during the Christmas holidays they have an egg nog flavour.
The employees here are mostly young, but they are always top-​notch. Always smiling and friendly. They don’t mind you trying as many flavours as you like.
The prices here are quite reasonable. Most places charge you extra for toppings, but not here. All the toppings you want are free. They even offer a waffle cone for free.
Hubby is a weird one and prefers to drink his ice cream, so he never strays. He always gets a large strawberry milkshake with chocolate chips mixed in. It’s his favourite milkshake above all others.
I prefer to actually eat my ice cream. I always go with 2 scoops in a waffle bowl. My favourite ice cream is their pistachio. Heck, pistachio is just my favourite ice cream period. I always shed a little tear when they don’t have it. But, that’s ok, because I love their sweet cream and strawberry very much as well and will get a scoop of each when they don’t have pistachio.
The flavours of all the ice cream I have tried are so rich and smooth. The flavour really comes through and «pops.» It’s like little spoons of heaven in my mouth!
If you like, they will mix your flavours together and mix in the toppings. I personally prefer to not have my flavours mixed, and when I do get toppings, I like to have them added to the top rather than mixed in. I must say again, I think it’s really cool I can get as many toppings as I like at no charge.
They have a lot of seating inside and the store is always super clean.
Although I haven’t tried them, they also have ice cream cakes and they have ice cream cupcakes. One of these days I’m going to have to try one of the ice cream cupcakes… they always look so good in the case!
If you visit the Orange Park Mall and haven’t been to Maggie Moo’s, you’re really missing out. It’s located on the outside of the mall next to AMC and TGIFridays. So, do yourself and your taste buds a favour and stop in next time you’re at this mall!

I absolutely love this place! The Ice cream here is always super creamy and rich. The flavors are spot on and very delicious. There is usually a nice selection of flavors to choose from as well. They will mix in any of the large variety of toppings they offer into your ice cream for free, although I usually only mix in toppings when I get vanilla. My favorite flavor here is the blue cotton candy, the flavor is so accurate and just makes me smile every time I take a bite. The banana is a very close second. Once in a while they will add in some new flavors but they are very nice about you trying out any of the flavors before you make your choice. It’s always hard to restrain my self from coming here every time I am in the area which is a lot! I treat my self every once in a while though.

Love the coffee ice cream. Server allowed me to try different flavors until I found what I liked and I didn’t feel rushed. :) made up for a bad lunch

Yummy! Some of the best peanut butter ice cream I’ve had — will happily return for more.