Just okay pizza, the marinara sauce kinda tasted funky. Also tried a vodka slice and the sauce was very spicy. Dough is too fluffy not how I expect my New York pizza. The delivery was running late and they were nice enough to call.
Cody C.
Classificação do local: 5 New York, NY
Really, great authentic pizza and delicious pasta. Hidden gem and super friendly staff. Fast in the delivery category and one of the better go tools in the lower east side!!!
Frank F.
Classificação do local: 5 Princes Bay, Staten Island, NY
this place is selling great pizza and food on that street for 30 years. he also rips the entire kitchen apart and cleans every inch with bleach EVERYNIGHT !!!
Rhea D.
Classificação do local: 5 Financial District, NY
best pizza and pasta by far in the lower east side. excellent service and super fast delivery. this is and will forever be my go to pizza shop in the lower east side. thank you don alphonso!
Frank F.
Classificação do local: 5 Piscataway Township, NJ
Always a favorite spot for me. Pizza is delicious and the service is great. Delivery guy is very considerate and kind. I highly recommend pizza shack for good old fashioned pizza/Italian cuisine.
Gladys M.
Classificação do local: 5 New York, NY
If you love Pizza, Chicken Rolls, Pepperoni Pin rolls or my favorite White Cheese Pizza made to your liking you have to go and meet Tito, one of many cooks at Pizza Shack. The workers are all courteous and polite and let’s not forget the owner Ally a great person, always giving back to the community. . Tito you’re awesome..
A Luis S.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
Pizza shack continues to provide great food and great service. Thank you guys for making every plate of food with a special touch. Good customer service
Angie M.
Classificação do local: 2 New York, NY
2 stars because delivery was early and the guy was nice. The food was terrible! The gnocchi was sitting in a pool of water and oil. The gnocchi on the bottom was mushy. It was that horrible gnocchi that you get at the grocery store in air tight plastic. Nothing good or homemade. The lobster ravioli was boring. Typical. The lasagna was bad too! Store bought crap. Undercooked. I just kept getting that feeling like they bought all the ingredients at C-Town then just assembled at the shop. I bought 3 dishes hoping to spread them out over a few days, but ended up spending way too much money on one crappy meal because I could only tolerate a couple bites of each.
Chris N.
Classificação do local: 3 Sayville, NY
The pizza is delicious and usually fresh. Always making different special slices and pies. Today was the first day I noticed a little attitude when asking about the special slices. I was told he makes different slices every day when I asked are you going to make the spicy pepperoni slice again with the fresh mozzarella on top. That did not answer my question so I will be trying it again soon see if it was just a bad day
Chrissy C.
Classificação do local: 5 Park Slope, Brooklyn, NY
Pizza Shack is my favorite pizza spot in the city! I live in Brooklyn and I know good pizza when I eat it! I’ve had several of the pasta dishes as well and they’ve always been delicious and full of flavor! Its a cozy little spot, clean inside with some art on the walls. Definitely a must try!
Mia C.
Classificação do local: 3 Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan, NY
What a disappointment i placed my order through the Unilocal site and when i got there they thought i was speaking in tongues. They only accept grub and seamless orders. They didn’t honor the 10% checkin discount and I had to reorder. Thankfully the penne alla vodka was tasteful.
Scott K.
Classificação do local: 1 New York, NY
Dear Ally & Joe D, I wrote that review almost four months ago Did it take you that long to figure out that your delivery guy got hurt? You just got back with excuses and lip service about«Great» food Great food speaks for itself and Pizza Shack ain’t it I have not gotten anything from Pizza Shack since your guy got«hurt» and I don’t miss it at all As a matter of fact, I must thank you for giving me a reason to search out better food in the neighborhood Not very hard Sincerely, Scott
Lindà W.
Classificação do local: 1 New York, NY
Tried your pizza and a while ago… thought I’d give it another try… horrible, tasteless crap plus there’s no a. c in the shop… you need to try another business… food is not your thing !
Eric T.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
Solid Pizza. I often order delivery and their meals are all very good. Chicken Parm among my favorites. Delivery time is usually very good. Solid local pizza place.
Elton W.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
Pretty solid pizza and the best pizza in the LoHo area. Good proportion of dough/crust to sauce to cheese; and I absolutely love that they use«Old World Pepperoni» for their pepperoni slices. Old world pepperoni are smaller in diameter than the basic(Hormel) pepperoni, and curl up into a little bowl when cooked. Old world is higher quality and less greasy, so you’re not repeating(or tasting) that pepperoni all day, like you are with the cheaper stuff. I think most of the bad reviews are because of delivery issues, so get some exercise and eat it there. Highly recommend it. Of course there are better places in the city — Joe’s, John’s, Artichoke, etc., but for the area, this place is the best.
Jorge O.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
«Yay I’m a fan» because 1) Real NY-style-friendly owner/staff in my experience. They’re definitely trying. 2) It’s good oven baked Sicilian pizza, the kind you can’t find for blocks and blocks around. The spot apparently has been around for a while. 3) The bad reviews here seem a bit exaggerated. 4) I got a HUGE margherita slice which was good! Also, I never tried a potato+ricotta slice before, interesting… Not sure about their price point. Could also use some re-branding(maybe even remodeling), the grandma logo is confusing — do they do «grandma» pizza?
Kobe F.
Classificação do local: 5 South Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
I’ve had many different dishes from Pizza Shack and I’ve never been disappointed… A wide variety of food and all very good.
Harry H.
Classificação do local: 3 New York, NY
They are no longer accepting LevelUp but still serving up a decent $ 2.25 slice way out on Grand, albeit from pretty rude and distant staffers.
J C.
Classificação do local: 1 Long Beach, NY
Used to be our go to local Italian restaurant, not any more. Did they change owners? Food is poor, service(delivery) is worse.
Anna K.
Classificação do local: 1 New York, NY
Strike 1: Placed this Seamless order at 5pm for delivery at 6:30pm. Arrived at 6:55pm. Strike 2: Ordered the mozzarella tomato basil panini with prosciutto. It came with no prosciutto. Strike 3: Bit into what I thought was PUBIC hair in their salad. Turns out they were thin wires from those scrub sponges. at least I hope so. It was all over my salad. Completely inedible. I just had to throw it away. The first and last time I’ll be ordering from here.