Mustang Harry’s

Must try their peace sangria! It’s very tasty and awesome. Their happy hour menu is super limited and I wouldn’t come here for It, but MUST try their peach sangria… I also had 1 of their burgers, and It was delicious. I’ll definitely be back.

Last time I visited I sat at the bar for some beers over a Ravens game. I decided to grab a bite and went with the quesadilla. Let me tell you, that thing was about 3 bites for $ 10 (a single small tortilla folded over). Not happy.

Just awful!!! Ordered the coconut shrimp. Got FOUR small shrimps for $ 14! They weren’t even tasty. Received a huge amount of mango sauce for those tiny shrimps. The place is loud with 100 tv screens. The chairs look and feel old from an old diner. The entire place felt stuffy and fishy (and not because I ordered shrimp). If fish is fresh the entire restaurant shouldn’t smell bad. The host was tired at 7pm and she just seemed like she could care less.

Food below average. Wait staff horrible. Go some place else. Would not come back or recommend. Tried not to give us happy hour prices. Said that’s the summer specials we posted on our web site. Told them that not my problem and had them deduct $ 17 from our check. DO NOT EAT HERE

Very very disappointed Food not as good as thought and Waite staff slow and chatty with each other in a corner

I came here for a specific reason. Not sure how it happened, but my bf is one of the few Ravens fans that I’ve ever met in NYC. This can be tough during football season, since it’s not exactly always shown on the local networks. While doing a search to see if there would be anyplace that he could watch the game amongst like minded fans (instead of this Giants fan) I came across Mustang Harry’s. He was so happy to proudly sport his Ravens jacket when walking in. lol .
So, we came on a Sunday and what I really like is that even though the game is on, they still adhere to the brunch menu. I was happy– Steak and eggs please with a mimosa! The food wasn’t great but it was decent and the service was right along with it. Some of the televisions were a little dated and made the Ravens look like their uniform is brown– may be time to upgrade. Was also surprised that there weren’t more fans out, thought admittedly it was towards the end of a not so good season. Not sure how it would be here if it were really crowded, but they definitely have a-​lot of space here.
We’ll definitely be back next season.

Very cool place to grab drinks and food before a concert at Madison Square Garden… Me and my friends have kinda made this a place we meet as a tradition before every Phish concert at this spot! The beers are cold and the staff is friendly, the food could have been better, but I didn’t go there for the food, I went for the drinks and ambience.

3.5 stars
I was waiting for a train to leave Penn Station. I had a Dubliner burger and a Kale and Qinoa salad. The burger was actually pretty tasty. Cooked med rare and nicely seasoned. Now I have to say that I really don’t like kale salad as much as I think I do. I know it’s healthy and its full of antioxidants but when you get right to it it’s like eating weeds.
We sat at the bar and service was good for a Sunday at 12:15 pm. The place was almost empty.
The bill was 33.99 and it fed two people. I would say that if you ate the burger alone you would be in a food coma until the next day. Splitting the meal was great. Neither of us were hungry and neither was too full. I’m not sure I would go out of my way to eat here but if I was heading to the MSG or Penn Station I would for sure come and grab something to eat.

A little tight getting from the entrance through the bar area to the back, but you can hardly blame a pub a block from MSG from getting crowded prior to an event.
Good selection of beer and spirits.
Decent selection of salads, pub food, burgers, etc.
Attentive, courteous, professional wait staff.
Quick enough bartending staff, given the large crowds.
You may want to make a reservation before an event if you have a large party or want a table for dining.
It’s pretty much your standard sports-​style bar. They’ll have the popular games on. They’ll have on the music of whomever is performing at MSG that night.
Is it a destination location? No. They’re not trying to be. It’s a good place for a quick bite or drink before an MSG event, or if you happen to live local.

Pretty good place, quite packed, and decent food. You can never go wrong with the disco fries (I wish the gravy wasn’t on the side. Disco fries should be covered in gravy and then you melt the cheese in my opinion). I got the lamb pops and that sauce was sooooo good! Service was pretty good as well. Nothing to complain about, but nothing to really rave about.

Stopped in to meet up with some friends. The bar is in midtown Manhattan, not too far from MSG.
The bar is quite large. Plenty of tables, booths and lots of seats at the bar. The section itself is quite long and has plenty of flatscreen TVs for you to watch. Mostly serves macro style beers with a small selection of ‘micro’ or ‘craft’ beers. This is a full service bar with plenty of your favorite liquor stocked.
They have plenty of staff working the bar and restaurant area. The staff is friendly, fast and efficient.
If you are looking for a laid back, casual bar setting, this is not a bad place to stop. I was surprised that it was not overly crowded for a Saturday night, but I did not mind that at all.

«I could probably run a sports bar,» you say. Every guy thinks it — just grab some beer, make sure you have your TVs working, serve up some specials, and you’re good to go. But what was that part about working TVs? Surely, a Ravens bar will have all of their TVs working during a Ravens game, right?
See pictures for what actually happened. Two broken TVs, half of the bar couldn’t watch the game. What the hell guys?!

A+++ Was seated in the back and waited on by a young dark haired Irish girl. I asked for a dark beer and she picked out a local brew that was great. Food she suggested was even better. Service couldn’t be better and people couldn’t be friendlier. Best spot in the city by far.

Stopped in here this afternoon only because I had my bike and needed outdoor seating. We were just trying to pass time, but were extremely surprised with the food and service!
We started with Lettuce Wraps which were delish. I got the Salmon Salad … It was awesome!

I think most food in New York is pretty decent, but I was not impressed with this place. It’s conveniently located by Penn Station, but otherwise, that’s the only thing it’s got going. I ordered the Reuben and it was less than mediocre.
Not a bad place though to grab a beer, there’s TVs everywhere to just chill out.

We had a group of 11 that went to Mustang Harry’s before a show. It’s conveniently located close to the Garden and Penn Station, so it’s an easy meeting spot. Because we were a large group, they seated us upstairs, which was wonderful because we were away from the Ranger fans and had no problem hearing each other during conversation.
Our waitress was great. She remembered what all of us were drinking and kept stopping by to make sure no one needed refills.
The food is your basic bar food, nothing special, but still good. My only complaint was that when our food came out, it was total confusion. Most of us had ordered burgers, and we all had them cooked different ways. The staff who delivered them to the table had no idea what was cooked well done or what was medium rare. I do understand that we were a large party and that the place was busy, but they could have been a little more organized.
All considered, it was still a nice evening, and I would return.

This place was great. The price is right and service was on point. Very comfortable booths right by the bar. Pretty big inside for a place in the city. Was not crowded at the time as it was early but i can see this place hoping at dinner time.
Highly recommend this spot.
The bar area is big and long. Great selection of liquor with many TVs.
I will be back to this spot.

Came here for dinner later on a Sunday evening, and it was pretty much dead. The service was a bit… odd. We had two different waitresses. The one who took our orders answered everything with an abrupt «Yeah». Like:
Me: I’ll start with the soup of the day…
Waitress: Yeah
M: And then I’ll have the chicken quesadilla
W: Yeah
etc.
The food took a bit longer to come out than I’d have expected, but it wasn’t over the top. The food itself was pretty good: my soup and quesadilla were tasty, and I stole a French fry or two from one of my dining companions.
There are a lot of similar places in this area (see near mirror image, Mustang Sally’s down the street, for example) and this is a decent place to grab a drink or bite if you’re around here. Nothing more, nothing less.

I went for lunch on a Tuesday and it was fairly full of customers.
Mustang Harry’s is A-​OK. The location, size, and interior give it the potential to be much more than it currently is. The menu is fine. The food is doable. The service is acceptable. I wish the ingredients were more fresh and more effort went into making the dishes taste better but, meh, it’s fine.
There are so many better restaurants nearby that I would encourage folks not to bother with Mustang Harry’s.

I went there with my hubby who is huge fan of broncos. I found out this place is denver broncos fan bar. Long bar with spacey seating areas. Nice place to watch the game and hang around with people.
Foods were okay, just average bar foods. Spicy shrimp was very small and tiny portion with $ 13 price. Wings were crispy and nice, pizza was just okay. Sangria was just so so… Among what we ordered, my favorite was jersey disco fries. Melted cheese on top of fries and it comes with gravy. Loaded nacho was okay, hard to mess up.
Service was fast, efficient and very attentive. General staffs were friendly. Food came out really fast, my glass was never empty. I was happy with their service but food was just okay.