Pizza was ok, nothing special. Typical NY large slice greasy thin crust like every other place.
B K.
Classificação do local: 3 Marietta, GA
Good pizza with a typical 2 Alice and a Coke deal. Not the best pizza ever but still good enough to visit.
Mary K.
Classificação do local: 5 Alameda, CA
Awesome pizza and great salad too! I brought in ten hungry travelers — everyone found something that he liked. Even my friend who is gluten free liked this place — great salad with real chicken! Thanks Gotham!
Powell M.
Classificação do local: 3 New York, NY
Nothing wrong with this pizza place! Good place to get a bite if you are in a hurray.
Chris S.
Classificação do local: 1 Flatiron, Manhattan, NY
Waited 20 mins for a pizza that never showed up. After waiting patiently and no sign I asked how much longer to which his reply was«have you ordered?». He then pulled a pizza that had been waiting 10 mins and that I’d seen them top with cold pepperoni after baking it and forgetting the topping. When I pointed out that I’d seen them do that, he refused to serve me. 20 minutes wasted. Very frustrating.
Alex H.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
Pretty darn good pizza for take-out for roughly 30 bucks! The only problem is sometimes I don’t think the pizza is cooked long enough — I suggest telling the guys to cook the pizza a bit longer(i.e. asked for is browned a bit) it’s much better this way! Topped with Mike’s Hot Honey and you are good to go!
R K.
Classificação do local: 5 Bronx, NY
Wonderful pizza; they use high quality ingredients and the food is always fresh. Sadly, I am now on a gluten-free diet and no longer frequent this place, but have eaten here probably a dozen times since moving to NYC in 2014. Give the plain slice, grandma, or pepperoni(my favorite) a try.
Shea C F.
Classificação do local: 5 Butler, NJ
This pizza is awesome! Idk how they made their crust but it’s fantastic def will be back!
Sheri S.
Classificação do local: 3 Minneapolis, MN
This neighborhood Pizza spot will never replace my favorite«Hot Spot» Pizza that is now closed but it comes in close as an option if I am not able to head over to Artichoke Pizza(love them, but they are a little pricey). I typically go here for a slice of the grandma’s pizza and a white slice. The staff is always friendly –and whenever I am there usually after work there are seats. I know during the day it is usually crazy busy so I am glad I get to avoid that.
Melissa R.
Classificação do local: 1 New York, NY
Ordered delivery on seamless. Delivery estimate was 35 – 45 mins. It’s now been 80 mins and it’s STILL not here
Erica K.
Classificação do local: 5 Houston, TX
My friends and I found this place after discovering Artichoke’s had closed for a private event. We decided to get a classic Margherita pizza and eat it while roaming the high line. It’s a delicious pizza, what can I say. And for the price, I’m not complaining at all. The thin crust is nice and crispy, but what I really enjoyed is how they kept the integrity of all the ingredients and made those shine. The nice chunks of mozzarella with a good serving of tomato sauce and basil. Nothing was out of balance and it wasn’t a heavy pizza. Cheap and very satisfying bite to eat.
Suzanne W.
Classificação do local: 4 West University, Houston, TX
Wow my first slice of NY pizza and it did not disappoint! The pizza itself was gooey with cheese and absolutely delicious to stuff down your face in a very un-ladylike manner. My only complaint was that the restaurant itself was HOT. Ugh we definitely could not have stayed there to eat. Instead we took our meal onto the High Line which was nice as well. Also, it was $ 16 for a medium Margarita which was a tad expensive for the actually servings we got. I would have expected a pizza that size to be more like $ 12ish.
Spencer A.
Classificação do local: 4 Miami, FL
Surpisingly delicious, high quality no nonsense NY pizza. Sauce, cheese and crust were close to perfect. Service friendly. Price was right.
Kyle D.
Classificação do local: 4 Shelton, CT
My father and I stopped in here for a pie after the concert. The staff couldn’t be nicer. They were quick and efficient and made a beautiful pie. The ingredients all taste extremely fresh and full of flavor. This is definitely going to be our go to pizza place while in the Chelsea area of NYC. Don’t pass this place up!
Jo B.
Classificação do local: 5 Manhattan, NY
Great fresh pizza for an unbeatable price(for a REAL pizza — not the $ 1 dollar stuff). Always our go-to place in Chelsea.
Claudia A.
Classificação do local: 2 Miami, FL
Pizza sauce is not homemade. Pizza has been waiting since baked in the meowing to be sold so it tastes stale. Not recommend
Shachar M.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
First time we ordered pizza from Gotham and it was great! We ordered couple of slices each and they were all awesome! Just as crispy as you want warm and not cold. Toppings were generous and it arrived fast! Just what you need ok a rainy nyc day! Highly recommended
Krizia C.
Classificação do local: 5 New York, NY
Best pizza in Chelsea area!!! I have tried many of the pizza spots, but this place is by far the best. Ordered in on a rainy Saturday night and decided to order different slices. We got a cheese, mushroom, margharita, and grandmas slice. Each were superb. The dough is so crisp and delicious. The delivery was quick and pizzas were hot. Usually I have to stick them back in the oven, but not here. When you want pizza go Gotham! Love it.
Peter M.
Classificação do local: 4 Brooklyn, NY
very good pizza, although a touch too thin. lunch special is a solid deal. $ 5 for two slices and a fountain soda. Grandma slice has a nice and flavorful sauce.
Tara P.
Classificação do local: 3 Manhattan, NY
Tastes like the version of Domino’s pizza they show on tv, crispy, salty and generic. The issue is the price, for better than Dominoes, you expect better. Maybe it’s Chelsea prices for stuff. Ordered delivery. The crust was crisp. Lots of good air and olive oil crispness. Even had cornmeal on the crust. But, it was too salty, the sauce was forgettable and overall the pizza generic tasting. I mean it was very well cooked just tasted generic; which would have been tolerable for $ 17 or $ 21 but $ 26 for dominoes?! I should have reconsidered my order. But, it wasn’t horrible.