Gelato Ti Amo

I’ll be back for that hazelnut flavor again! Yumm

First, I got Gelato Ti Amo at Urban Space at the Garment District so I don’t know how the store location is like.
As far as taste goes, it was good. I have never been to Italy, so I have no idea how gelato is really suppose to taste like besides it being ice cream. I got the tiramisu flavor cause I’m a big fan of tiramisu. It obviously tasted more like coffee than anything. Not sure how tiramisu would differentiate from a coffee flavor (if they have that flavor). It was smooth and creamy. A little pricey, but I didn’t mind.
Not quite sure if I would have it again.

Had a small cup with two flavours that cost me $ 5.00. I chose mascarpone/​fig and lemon. Was hoping for strawberry but they were out. The flavours were rich and creamy and had a good mouth feel to it. Lemon was pretty tart but it helped to cut the richness of the mascarpone. A good gelato when you’re in the area.

With all the gelato places in the city, you really need to make yourself stand out. Gelato Ti Amo does not do that at all. The flavors are boring and the employee there seemed miserable. I got the Nocciola. It was just okay. No intense flavors.
I do like the outdoor seating.

Stopped in again last night, nothing has changed, still the best Gelato in town, love this place.
Love you Luca, great job !!!

High quality ingredients! You taste the flavor of your gelato. Not the powdery substance like FroYo places.
Example: the dark chocolate with cherries has actual cherries in it, such a wonderful surprise.
Gelato ti amo, hits the sweet spot, but if you crave tart– their yogurt choices are just as good!

small spot with few chairs but perfect for a quick purchase of something yummy. the variety is limited but some times too many choices is confusing. simple is good and tasty is better!
Unilocal doesnt provide discounts but as soon as I used 4squares I received a buyone get one. so Unilocal???come on!!! step on the discount/​promos.

Yum!!! Yummy yum yum!!! This is truly a little hidden gem in this area and I find it strange that they don’t have this place all blingy blinged out to let you know they are there! If you’re not looking for them, you’ll miss them!
The staff was super helpful, the girl behind the counter let me and my husband try like 10 different flavors all with a smile… bonus star! The reason we even tried all the flavors is because they sounded so different and each and every one of them was delicious and bursting with flavor. My favorites were the black cherry yogurt, bacio, hazelnut, fig and pistachio. I look forward to going back and trying out some more flavors!
The small is a bit pricey, but they give you a lot of gelato. You can also get two flavors in one cup, always a bonus! So if you’re in the area and craving some gelato you gotta come try this place. It is one of the best gelato places in the city!

The best gelato place for some post-​dinner dessert! My favorite flavors are the yogurt apricot and the mascarpone with caramelized fig.
The yogurt apricot is a splendid mix of creamy and tart, with delicious swirls of apricot! The mascarpone with caramelized fig deserves a place on the list of best things St Marks has to offer! So creamy and unique is this flavor, I could eat scoop after scoop of it. I love that all the flavors are reliably good; the cheesecake is also done surprisingly well! Not thick, yet still a perfect consistency – one of the best cheesecake gelato I’ve ever tasted.
Workers are always friendly as well, and let you try any flavors until you find the right one! Sample away, because it will be difficult to choose just one here.

Yuuummmmmm gelato!
Came here after seeing a BOGO offer from ScoutMob. The staff was super friendly and super helpful (they had to show me how to redeem the offer).
Even though I was getting one order free, the friendly face behind the counter obliged in my gluttony and allowed me to sample various flavors. She didn’t even bat a lash when I continued to ask for samples after I ordered and paid.
I ended up getting the coconut in a small cup. After topping it with a mini sugar cone (and my last sample), my friend and I grabbed a table right outside and enjoyed the weather and our yummy gelato!

Any place with a ‘Giant’ size cup knows what they’re doing. I was in the area with my girlfriend when I saw the word «Gelato» and naturally, I had to have it. Seating isn’t too expansive but they have a nice, little outdoor area you can sit with your friends if it’s not too hot or too cold. There’s a foursquare deal and apparently a scoutmob deal but I saw that they had a ‘Giant’ size and until I was done eating, words such as ‘deal’ or ‘taster’ or ‘scoutmob’ seemed so insignificant in comparison.
I got the pistachio, hazelnut, chocolate, and vanilla. Overall, I would say the gelato is above average. I always assume that places with ‘deals’ need them because their actual product is not very good but Gelato Ti Amo surprised me. I thought the Pistachio and Hazelnut were especially good. The Hazelnut actually had lots of nuts inside which I assumed was to give it a more authentic taste; they actually erred on the side of too many nuts which kind of gave me the impression that they were trying too hard but whatever, it was still really good.
Lady at the front was nice. She let me sample six different flavors and didn’t so much as sigh or roll her eyes. Impressive. Definitely worth a try.

The Scoutmob deal for this place is crazy, especially if you’re with more than one person: buy one get one free! Staff was not only friendly but very generous with the servings. She suggested the mascarpone caramelized fig gelato, which is what I got, with a scoop of bacio. Between the two, the mascarpone was better — it was lighter but still flavorful. I’m not a big fan of figs, but the fig taste definitely blended well into the rest of the gelato. The bacio, on the other hand, was a little thick and the hazelnut pieces were bigger than expected, but also very delightful.
Overall, I really liked the gelatos here. I tried the pistachio, which tasted as if I had just cracked open a pistachio nut and ate it right then and there. All of the gelatos are imported from Italy, granted I have never been to Italy, but they brought me one step closer to experiencing the beautiful country’s delicious foods.
I’ll definitely be back — next time I’m trying their affogatos!

I came to Gelato Ti Amo after lunch one beautiful Sunday afternoon.
I got the fig mascarpone gelato and while the flavor was nice (I love fig), it was way too sweet for my liking. The gelato was smooth and yummy, but I think it would have been perfect had it not been terribly sweet.
Buy one get one free on Scoutmob made it better though! At $ 4 a pop regularly for a small though, it’s not bad for the price.

Small hole in the wall shop with its gelato imported all the way from its other locations in Italy. In lieu of scoops, the ice cream preparer of ceremonies donned a spatula, instantly bringing me back to my days in Italy when I feasted on gelato at least twice per day.
In my experience with gelato, the best flavor combination is one scoop of chocolate and a scoop of coconut on top in that order. Thank me later for this suggestion.
At the end of the day this is some of the best gelato the city has to offer.

Get to the Chase:
Pros:
1) Friendly and quick service
2) Cute and small shop with a good variety of flavors (at least 10 or so)
3) Not that pricey at $ 3.50 for a small (which was more than enough for me, which fit 1 scoop of pistachio and 1 scoop of bacci)
4) Don’t know why this place has a low rating, because although it is small, if you go to Italy it’s common to just to be served and on your way…
Place has good flavors, ok pricing, and friendly service!
Cons:
1) Not any unique flavors that I have not tried before (pretty standard) with the exception of the custard which didn’t taste quite good
2) A delivery option would be wonderful

Cute place with a very friendly staff… and by «staff», I mean the one girl behind the counter with the red glasses. She let us sample flavors to our collective hearts’ content, and took her time to whip up crepes and cups of gelato for our consumption.
Gelato is okay. I’ve never been a «fan»…it’s just thick, overpriced ice cream to me. Still! I got the custard flavor, and it was delightful. There are many fruity flavors as well as your typical vanilla /​chocolate /​hazelnut combinations. $ 4 for a tiny cup still irks me, but I’ve seen worse. (Grom, I’m looking at you.)
This place, seating-​wise, is clearly better in the warmer months. Lots of seats outside, and, literally, four seats inside. Yan and I took two seats, with poor Lori sipping her cocoa on the floor. Quel dommage!

Great stuff. Master Unilocalers Allison and Lori brought me here after Stage Restaurant. They have great gelato and sorbets at prices you can swallow (compared to places like Grom, anyway). I had the gnutella crêpe with raspberry sorbet gelato. YES.
The girl at the counter was very nice, and they’ll give you a taste. Business seemed fairly slow, so they’re worth a try. There’s no seating, but the counter girl was kind enough to give us the one table, which appeared to be more for staff than customers.
Seats would help, but takeout works fine!

NOT BAD, but more like ice cream than gelato, although they’ve got some good flavors
take advantage of the FREE scoutmob deal while you can!
–coconut not bad
–bacio chocolate hazelnut was good!
–crema toscano like strawberry cheese cake
–fiordilatte custard chocolate a bit odd
i probably just need to find a flavor that suits me!

Lame: they wouldn’t honor the Scoutmob deal for a free sampler cone of Gelato. She gave some story about how the manager told her she couldn’t accept it anymore. Even though it’s STILL showing up in the app.
Very weak. Good thing it was on the way to another dessert so I didn’t waste too much of my time.
I still asked for a sample of the Peanut gelato before leaving though, and it actually was pretty good. Still, I wouldn’t waste myself on a place like this with all of the other amazing options in this neighborhood (Momofuku, Chikalicious, Lula’s, etc.).

New Gelato shop? I’m there!
The employee was friendly and quick. We asked to sample a few flavors and ended up liking every one of them. Seating is available, 4 tables and 10 chairs.
There are 3 cup sizes (small, medium, large). The Small only comes with 1 flavor and the Medium comes with your choice of 2. We decided to try Medium cups of Strawberry & Mango and Black Cherry & Raspberry.
The kind gentleman was extremely generous with the serving. The gelati was smooth, light, creamy, refreshing, and not too sweet. I loved the pieces of fruit in the Black Cherry gelato. If you’re in the area and looking for a cool treat, definitely give this place a try.
Gealto Ti Amo is exactly what we needed on a hot day.