Forty Carrots

A good place to rest your tired feet after walking around nearby and shopping.
The staff is not the best or friendliest. I ordered a hot chocolate, which was decent, but not as hot as it should’ve been. The tables were all dirty with scraps left on them. Being in Bloomingdale’s, I expected better service, quality and cleanliness.

Boasting 24 more carrots than its EVill competitor does Handles, I was subconsciously drawn here after a meal at Back *Forty* West. Waded through the 2^nd floor of Bloomingdale’s to find it way at the back (past some tables near the stairs) and handed over $ 5.44 for regular cake batter. Cashier insisted I not use the chip reader and that I only swipe my CC instead, defeating the purpose). Product was kinda icy but the larger portion than most for the price and the overall flavor saved the experience. (Much smaller flavor roster compared to the UES location)

Their plain frozen yogurt is what dreams are made of! Got one with walnuts and it was heavenly! Huge portions even on a regular size, you could easily share between two people.
Pop in here for a break from the crazy weekend crowds in bloomies.

Frozen yogurt is fine but $ 2 for ONE topping? Come on. I would never have gotten a topping if I had known.

Frozen yogurt here is NOT good. Not only did it not taste like anything remotely close to yogurt, but it tasted more like blended ice, milk and sugar. I don’t understand why the reviews for this place is so high but I deeply regret purchasing the yogurt which is now sitting in my trashcan :(
First of all, I bought a cream cheese frozen yogurt and asked for the carrot topping. The guy gave me chocolate chips instead –_​– … I hate sending things back and wasting food so I just took it and paid. Then I started eating it and I couldn’t even tell what flavor it was because it had no flavor!
On top of that, the chocolate chips weren’t even good! How do you screw up chocolate chips? I’ll tell you how… by buying cheap ones! Half of my yogurt consisted of chocolate chips so I had to try to eat the bland yogurt and ended up tossing all the other half with the chocolate chips away.
At least this place did one good thing for me — I won’t be craving frozen yogurt in the near future anymore.

The workers here are complete idiots. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, workers told me it would take 20 mins. Went back in 20, they gave my order to someone else. Did not apologize, rather just acted like they didn’t know what I was talking about. Had to wait another 20 mins. A complete waste of time.

The yogurt was good. But the staff is inexperienced and slowed to a crawl when only 2 people were in line. Also easy to see why this place got a health code grade of B. If Bloomingdales is running this place they should pay the staff more and train them better.
And I only saw the grade of B after I finished eating. Come on I expect more from Bloomingdales which gives an upscale image.
Overall the yogurt is very good but they should do better in service and cleanliness.
I won’t return to this location unless improvements are made.

As a self-​proclaimed frozen yogurt snob, I had doubts about Forty Carrots. I mean, how good could this stuff really be compared to the fro-​yo heavy hitters, with their endless rows of toppings and constantly rotating flavors? However, Forty Carrots really holds its own!
Stopped by here on a random Tuesday in May– you know, the kind that is hot and humid and cloudy and sweaty and threatening to rain at any second? Gross, I know. Anyways, the Forty Carrots is on the 2^nd floor of Bloomingdales. To get there, you must pass the sparkling marble floors and the sections with tons of shoes, bags and cosmetics all screaming «BUY ME!!!». It’s a rough road but you’ll get there.
I ordered a small froyo with plain and sampled some coffee, which was delicious as well! They serve you HUGE portions, which kind of mitigates the sticker shock a little bit. Plus, the seating is tucked away from the shopping and is fairly quiet and secluded, so it’s a great space to curl up with a book or just enjoy the bliss of frozen yogurt on a hot day.
Five stars in my book! Although I do wish the SoHo location had a couple more flavor options on rotation.

The person who introduced me to froyo told me to make a pilgrimage to «the froyo store in Bloomingdales» since it was the best. Two years later, I did, and she was SO right! I have tried a lot of froyo and can say I prefer this place for their tart yogurt. If you just want a mound of plain froyo, this is THE place. The portion is bigger than other places and the tart flavor is just the right blend of creamy, tart, and sweet. It was thick and not icy. This is NOT the place to go if you want self-​serve, lots of toppings, or a big flavor selection though, so be warned (and there’s definitely a time and place for that).

The fro-​yo options for that day were plain (tart) and chocolate. There were two people working there, but service did seem a little on the show side. The topping selection was smaller than I would’ve liked — I don’t think fruit was an option, and I usually go for the tart and fruit combo. I ended up getting tart with oreos as my topping — the oreos got mixed in to the swirl which was a nice change from just plopping the toppings on top of the fro-​yo.
As a tart fro-​yo connoisseur, if I do say so myself, this is why I give Forty Carrots 4 stars instead of 3 (3 would be due to the small topping selection and limited flavor choice). The tart was very smooth, thick, and creamy — not watery like some other tarts that I’ve tried. I also tried the chocolate — it was very rich! Overall the frozen yogurt itself is very good — leans more towards the ice cream side because of its thick texture. Oh, and portions are pretty large! If you’re in the area, Forty Carrots is the perfect shopping break!

Cute little place with banging fro-​yo. I loved that is wasn’t overpowering, but satisfied my sweet tooth.

This is located inside Bloomingdale’s on the 2^nd floor
Sampled the vanilla and mango and decided on the mango, and thought the quality is above par
Large portions, but a bit on the pricey side
$ 5 for small (although you get a lot of yogurt) and $ 1 for each topping
I normally get a lot of toppings too

Hands down the BEST frozen yogurt I’ve had. The plain tastes great, I don’t even need any toppings. They also give you A LOT, maybe 6 times more than what you get for a small pinberry. It’s super smooth and not too sour — have just hint of tanginess.

They put crack in their froyo, right? The portions are more than generous and the flavors, while basic, are phenomenal. Worth going into Bloomingdale’s even if you aren’t doing any shopping.
The sandwiches and salads are delicious as well, so if you’re taking a break from shopping you can lunch at a fair price. Just be sure to get the froyo for dessert!

Only the BEST froyo EVER!!! Plain (tart) and coffee are the best. It’s definitely not your fat free, taste free, froyo that you can get at some other places that I’m not going to name…

Incredibly huge portion, light with a faint tart taste = amazing froyo :)
Only two flavors at this location but give it a try!

Finally got to try forty carrots since I am a froyo junkie. I ordered a small but it was huge! I don’t even want to know how big a large is. You get to mix 2 flavors together for a small. I got banana and peanut butter. It has more of an ice cream texture to it. I wouldn’t really buy as a frozen yogurt, it doesn’t have that tart taste and it seems too sweet. I think I’m going to stick to Pinkberry and 16 handles for my frozen yogurt fix. It’s too worth trying though folks!

Located in Bloomingdales… what a treat!
My friend brought me here, and I thought it was a pretty cool idea… nice to take a load off, when wandering around.
We had the strawberry banana yogurt with sprinkles — I’m glad we decided to share b/​c it was just massive!
They are also now stocking treats for the holidays… chocolate covered cookie dough… ya that’s right… yummie…

If you’re (A) a quick shopper and (B) love frozen yogurt like myself and have to wait hours for the slow shoppers, head to Forty Carrots on the 2^nd floor of Bloomingdales and take a seat. FYI: Perfect resting spot.
They have frozen yogurt, fresh juice & smoothies, soups, salads, sandwiches, and other baked goods. It was 30 minutes till closing and they didn’t run out of yogurt or rush anyone out.
A small frozen yogurt cost $ 4.90 including tax. But it’s no small it’s more like a large. They had plain & coffee and I requested for both flavors. The coffee was amazing and the plain was okay but the two flavors blend well together. The texture is great and after half an hour I wasn’t left with a liquidity cup.

great value for great frozen yogurt. $ 4.50 for a huge cup that feeds two– must be 20 oz size. seriously, just try to eat the whole thing yourself.
tasty toppings, as well as an assortment of other sweets, snacks, juices and teas to nourish yourself while getting your shop on.