Broadway Pizza

Not wasting time writing a review. This place is just below poor quality. But hey you do get what you pay for

The pizza has no flavor whatsoever. I didn’t even know pepperoni pizza could taste not much different from the water I was drinking.
Pretty similar to the «cardboard pizza» you had at school as a kid.

Average pizza at an expensive price. .
Unilocal wants me to write more and more and more and still more..

Pizza– gross
Service– horrible
Ambience– disgusting
Still cost us $ 20 for 4 slices of pizza
And… they charge extra ($ 1.75) if you want to use a debit card
We were willing to try this place out because sometimes the «diviest» places are the best when it comes to pizza. Boy, were we wrong.
I do not recommend anyone coming here unless they feel as though they may be dying of hunger, particularly when you are in NYC. I feel like the fact that this is located in NYC alone should help them realize that they REALLY need to step up their game. Badly…

Sometimes you shouldn’t judge a book by its cover, especially with pizza places, but this is just not one of those times.
This place looks like they don’t care about it. The menu and décor don’t look like they’ve ever been updated. There are no bathrooms available. They also serve breakfast which is a bit strange when you think about it. They clearly cater to the by-​the-​slice order, but the slices are way overpriced. Anything with meat on it will cost you more than $ 4.
The guy who gave us our slices was nice enough until we asked for them to go. He repeated it back to us, but then put them on a tray once they came out. When we reminded him we wanted to take them out, he seemed annoyed. He threw four slices of hot pizza all together in a small box, which was really interesting when we opened the box. The cheese was stuck to the undersides of the paper plates, stuck to the other slices, etc.
As if that wasn’t enough, the pizza had absolutely no flavor. I got two slices of chicken pizza, and I had to check that there was even sauce on the pizza because it was so flavorless.
I took a chance on the place, but it is just simply not good. Stay away.

Let’s be honest — I came here at 2am in the morning after a night of drinking but this place hit the spot!!!
They made a solid slice of pizza while being super friendly. It’s almost fun to watch people come into this place late at night.
If you are in the area and just want a slice of pizza — go here!!!

Been coming here for a long time there pizzas are already great. Very nostalgic place for me.

Though nothing special (esp for the price) the pizza isn’t bad but the the personality of the people (or should I say person) running the counter is so off putting ugh! I came for a slice not snarky commentary. I’ve only gone here cause its the closet pizza joint to my work place but today is it. I’ll walk the 10 mins to Bella Napoli from now on if I want pizza, at least I only gotta pay $ 2.25 a slices there…

Pizza was good. Crust was tasty, but the staff was unprofessional, and the place was dirty. NYC is stupid with good pizza joints. So it’s not necessary to visit this one again. One star for the za.

I have been in town since May, and I am leaving tomorrow and I have walked by so many times… I wish that I would have stopped in earlier. I was just lookin for a cold drink and a place to sit and find what I wanted to see next. I had the best sausage roll ever. I am a sucker for melty mozzarella and buttery, crispy, crust. The man behind the counter was very nice and while I was there I watched two groups (families) come in and greet the staff like they were old friends. One woman even took a picture of the rest of her group with the youg woman behind the counter. with that many smiles in one place you know it is going to be good.

Awful, awful.
They’re a ripoff. They charge $ 4.25 for a small slice — a third smaller than at most joints, where they charge at most $ 2.75. They’re clearly preying on tourists walking between the Flatiron Building and Times Square. Shameful, and it makes you think that a chain like Domino’s moving in wouldn’t be such a bad replacement.

The boy liked his pizza. It was a slice. They were fun and friendly. Nuff said.

The pizza here is actually not bad. Good amount of cheese and sauce on their slices. And with the topping slices, they actually put a a very generous amount of meat on them. This place is not cheap though for what you get ($ 2.75 cheese slices, $ 3.50 to $ 4 for topping slices).
Also, this place is very dirty. There are always stains all over the floor and the interior is very beat up and aged. It has looked like this for years, so you know the staff doesn’t care. Speaking of the staff — the guys at the counter are generally very rude. They rarely smile, are disgruntled, and like to make smart alec comments to their customers. Not recommended at all.

It’s a hole in the wall joint for a quick bite, nothing great or stand out about the place.
This is the epitome of the saying, «location, location, location!»
‘Nuff said…

Slice of pizza for ¢.099. The staff here are pretty cool. Good to know you can come here also for candy bars, gum and a newspaper
I tell you those 99 cent pizza taste great for what they are!
Great place for late night drunken eats!

This place is ok, nothing special at all. Staff is friendly. They don’t take cash and only have one tiny sign under the register that you don’t see til you go to pay. I was in a hurry and came in to get a salad (of all things)! The lettuce mix was fresh and the chicken tastes pretty good.
The pizza looked pretty horrible. I wouldn’t get it unless I was so drunk I couldn’t see straight. And it’s not even 1pm yet!

Out of all the pizza places I have tried in New York City, this was probably the worst one. My boyfriend and I just wanted a slice, and we stopped by here because it was close to our hotel. Although the size of the slices was of a typical New York slice, the taste was not. It wasn’t saucy enough, and was just blah. I wouldn’t recommend this place unless you were desperate to have something to eat.

I only got a piece of cheese, but I thought it was delicious.

Taking a class in the Flatiron Hotel down the block I stopped in for pizza. I was served quickly and sat down in the upstairs dining area, which is stuck in the 1970s. Took a bite of the pizza and it was fine but I was joined for lunch by a swam of flies. In November. On a 45 degree day. Shooed them away and quickly finished the pizza. Alerted the guy behind the counter and he said he’d spray.
I ate at Broadway Pizza today. You don’t have to.

It’s an ultra no-​frills slice. I’m sure it’s better at lunch than any other time. It’s a little less than $ 3 for a cheese slice. It’s crisp but there isn’t much cheese or sauce. The interior is dive-​worthy, which is odd because of its location. With it being somewhat close to Herald Square, wouldn’t they get a bit of the tourist crowd?
Maybe I’m wrong, maybe it is too far for tourists to venture. Perhaps this is a spot for working professionals within a two block radius. And if they had to review this place, they’d probably give it 3 stars, because they keep it in their rotation. And this is probably why ownership has decided against upgrading the interior; because they don’t get the tourist crowd.
But for pizza enthusiasts like myself, I can obviously do better. I have done better, and you can do better. Try Luzzo’s on 1^st Ave. Take the NQR to 14^th, transfer to the L (downtown) and get off at 1^st Ave. Luzzo’s is between 12^th and 13^th Street.
Don’t eat here…