The Wurlitzer Pizza Co

I love the fact that this place has the restaurant and ice cream place it’s great for the summer for the kids one of their favorite restaurant food is good can be pricey at times but it is still good food

Quality is lacking. Pizza was over cooked. Mine was take out but during my wait (they forgot to put my fries in) I looked around the dining room and it wasn’t very clean. Doesn’t take much to keep a place clean but it appears they’ve stopped trying.

We’ve had pizza there twice. It was pretty good. I like it better than Good Guys. Also, weird to order a pulled pork sandwich from a pizza place, but it was sooooo delicious. Definitely gonna go order that again.

This place use to be my favorite when I first moved to the area however the quality of product has gone downhill. The cheese pizzay is always super greasy and hard to eat. This hasn’t always been this way and wish they went back to the old recipe of it has changed.

So when I first moved out to the area I tried a bunch of pizza places to find that one I liked. This was the spot. Wings were great, pizza was good, and the blue cheese was out of this world. I kept ordering there for the next year. Never a issue. Then last year came and we ordered a few subs. Omg. They were horrible. I called them because they knew I was a weekly sometimes a twice a week customer. They have me 25 percent off my next order. I was on with that. Next time I called, no record of my discount. Whatever. I was hungry. We got our food and I was shocked at the mess they sent. Time to move on. So 6 months went by. Tried it again. Two subs. Both were horrible. Sub oil tasted like 10w30. Rolls were soggy. Lettuce and tomatoes were old. That’s it for me. No quality no order. This is WNY and I have plenty of wing sub and pizza choices. Two thumbs down.

Really disappointed with the regular pizza as of late. This used to be my pizza place but haven’t been there in months because of another stores online ordering capabilities.
Went back and got s chicken finger pizza. It was great. No complaints.
Went back again for a cheese and pepperoni. It was so cheesy and lacked sauce. The sauce it did have was somewhat tasteless.
Not sure if I’ll be going back for anything besides specialty pizza.

My order of a medium/​large pizza of pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms, and 20 wings was delivered to the house. The pizza dough was well underdone and raw! The wings were also under cooked. We finished cooking everything in the oven/​broiler so we could eat it. My family and I thought this was maybe an isolated event, as we have gotten deliveries in the past. Our next order, just the following week was also undercooked wings and pizza! Really? I would of loved to call and complain that night, but it was late, and they didn’t answer the phone. I visited them the next day and spoke to the manager. She said next te order the items under the cheese, that way it can get cooked better. Really? Next time, order the chicken wings crispy, that way I (myself) will know they get cooked well. Really? The manager was putting the blame on me!!! I said all the other pizza establishments can cook it right with those toppings! I can’t believe this woman! Blaming the customer. She said they are all timed to cook perfectly. She goes on to explain how they can never be undercooked. Everything that came out of this person was to defend herself and the company. She offered 10% off the next pizza. I said don’t worry, keep it! I’ll never go there again! Ever!!! She was insulting and so unprofessional!

Some friends turned us on to this place. Delicious there or delivered. The quality is all there. We order Thin crust well done well done. It’s a tasty pie!