Nancy’s Pizza

This is my family’s favorite place for stuffed pizza. We’ve been going to Nancy’s for years, we are loyal followers! We make the trip to Niles all the way from Wheeling to pickup up the best stuffed pizza in the northwest suburbs! We occasionally eat in at the restaurant, and the service is always great & the employees are friendly as can be. The all you can eat salad bar is a great addition while you wait for your pizza. Definitely worth the trip! With so many pizza choices out there today, Nancy’s in Niles is at the top of my list!

The best stuffed pizza! Period! Thin crust is phenomenal too. Those other touristy places are ok but for a born and raised Chicago girl, this Nancy’s has me. We are serious about pizza here too!!!

Food is pretty delicious, the sandwich was a large piece of breaded chicken, oozing cheese, and sauce was a good marriage of flavors. The beer battered onion rings was surprisingly good with that garlic marinara sauce, only thing that would have granted them another star would be if they had better service. Went there to pick my food and I flagged down two of the workers in the back who just looked at me and walked away. It took this nice lil old lady who was watching tv to ask if I needed help then went to the back and told some guy that I was there.

Great pizza and very nice service! They even gave us free Pepsi pack :)

Nancy’s pizza is the best!!!
Great food great, great people, and a great environment. Always a friendly face when come in. Frank is the best!!!

I feel responsible to pull down the overall grade of this place because.
I called on a Monday as a new customer expecting half pizza day, not only was it not half day, if was screw up your order day.
I asked for extra sauce, which was on the ticket and wasn’t done. I asked for little cheese, wasn’t done and wasn’t on the ticket.
Second, whoever wrote the ticket didn’t add anything or use any prices. He just decided it was 50 bucks for 3 items and charged me 50.
Third, the gnocchi was terrible. So I got over charged and the food was not only wrong it was bad.

I’m pretty addicted to their pizza here. I probably order Nancy’s at least once a week or so. It’s become my go to place to order pizza and italian.
Everything from the thin crust to the deep dish is really good.
All of their pasta dishes are great and they have enough options that if I want to try something different I can.
They also have a really great antipasta salad, actually ordered that last night!

I fancy Nancy’s. So far, theirs may be the best pizza within a ten-​minute drive of my home. They make really good thin and stuffed pies: all ingredients are in balance, which is the first key to a great pizza. They taste like quality too.
The guy who takes the orders and mans the counter is a character. He will take good care of you.
Nancy’s pizza can be a good bargain if you take the time to sniff out a deal: lunch specials, half-​price Mondays, various email or snail-​mail coupons. Buy any pizza, get the second for five bucks is pretty sweet when you have houseguests. $ 3 off a large stuffed is pretty sweet any damn time. If you want to dine in, there are occasionally email coupons for 50% off a single pizza.

We love Nancy’s pizza! We love going there on Mondays to get half off. The only problem is that they charge extra if you want a side of ranch. That’s annoying.

The staff is kind! The food is delicious and nice little environment for a family dinner/​a get together with friends!

The Chicago Style stuffed deep dish pizza here is to die for… and I thought my favorite was another place. They are consistently perfectly cooked, with tons of cheese and the toppings of your choosing.
On their half price pizza night, you can actually get the deal for carry out, which is rare.
The staff is friendly all the time, talking to customers and making them feel at home. The owner is there every time as go. He is a nice guy, spending time talking to regulars and making sure all tables are happy.
Salad bar is always fresh and delicious with many choices of items. There is a bread bar too, (just what we need with bready pizza, but still delicious) which has both savory and sweet varieties.
People I was with said the thin crust pizza was delicious too.

Another excellent pizza night! Had yummy baked clams and an awesome stuffed sausage pizza… always preach this but I’m a a believer of keep it simple — one ingredient for the stuffed pizza!!! Now, if you leave your email address, you can get a coupon for either 50% off of a pizza or buy one, get one free entrée. I’m told there will be a new coupon every Friday morning. Most excellent! I’m being told that a Friday/​Saturday night family special is coming — full meal at special pricing…

Mrs B wanted to have a deep dish pizza; so we scrounged around in our vault of two-​fers and deals, and found a half-​price coupon for Nancy’s.
This was not the first time we ate at Nancy’s, we have gone there for deep dish pizza from the days that Niles was a primordial swamp. We had not been there for at least a year — because I am not permitted to eat a lot of fatty foods.
Nancy’s has been there since dinosaurs immigrated to Niles in the 1950s and 1960s. It has been a favorite place for Niles families and couples who like Chicago style pizza, and don’t want to travel out of the way to Chicago.
Over the 30+ years I have come to Nancy’s, I don’t think that they have redecorated or changed the place substantially. It is a bit dark, but not in a «romantic» way. There are no notable adornments nor pictures posted on the wall.
One can quibble over what place makes the best pizza; but I really don’t get too excited about that: I find all of the local establishments pretty much acceptable. Their menu does offer other items, and they have a modest salad bar to either supplement your meal, or order the salad bar alone. During the course of the week, they offer specials and half-​price deals.
Their pizzas are made fresh, and you will wait 30 – 40 minutes to have them prepare the food; but it is worth the wait. Their crust is excellent, and the sauce is great. When it is brought out, it is extremely hot, and you will really need five minutes until the temperature has dropped from scalding to merely real hot.
Service was good, and I am always satisfied with Nancy’s and I happen to be a dinosaur, too! I just don’t live in Niles.

Great food all around. I’ve tried a variety of items off their menu and nothing has come short of excellent. Pizzas thin and stuffed are great, especially Mondays when they’re half off. Salad bar is always stocked and fresh if you’re ever dining in. Service is great as you definitely get the family restaurant vibes. Overall, great place!

There is nothing really spectacular about this pizza. It almost tasted like straight from the freezer pizza.
I hate writing bad reviews, but it is what it is.

So close to home and our favorite «go to» for pizza had closed!!! So we tried this place.
Did dine in once n carry out twice.
First time was carry out. Was good. Just thin crust sausage n thin veggie.
Wanted to dine in to try their stuffed cuz it looked so good sitting at the others’ tables when we were picking up our thin crust order. Stuffed was good but I found the crust’s edges a bit too crunchy n hard. Kids ordered spaghetti n meatballs. Meatballs were good! But the spaghetti was not. Sauce tasted a bit too «chef boy ar dee» to me. How does an Italian restaurant not make good spaghetti? Maybe they’re just known for their pizza. Salad bar for $ 4 can be added to your meal. It was small with some sad looking veggies. Maybe it was just a off day for the salad bar.
The third was Stuffed carry out. Doesn’t travel well.
Might just have to bite the bullet n drive a bit farther to grab Lou Malnati’s.

Nancy’s was pretty standard as far as pizza went. Onion rings were okay. Kinda soggy, pizza wasn’t bad but the cheese was kind of rubbery and the wings were dry. Not really an awesome place.
We are from out of town and will be coming to Chicago quite a bit this year and sadly Nancys won’t be getting anymore of our business.

The pizza is good! Well worth it on Mondays when it’s half off. The service is super slow though, we came in on Monday night and it was dead. The waiters were just mingling among themselves the entire time and did not care for our table. It was my first time in a restaurant where I was brought a Pizza to my table and after that the next time the waiter came without me getting up was to give me my check.
The pan pizza is like a deep dish pizza, it’s actually pretty good. I wouldn’t say it’s better then Pequods or Giordano’s though. I would come here again on Mondays because it’s so cheap, but I wouldn’t bring your friend from out-​of-​state whose never tried deep dish pizza here. I didn’t want to try the stuffed pizza, it looked like it was WAAAYYY too much cheese in the pictures. I can’t handle that.
Overall, food was 4/​5, service was ¹⁄₅. You can have group dinners here. Free wifi, easy parking.

I’m a Chicago native of 30 years who has worked in pizza places. Nancy’s has become my favorite Chicago pizza. I love their pies and their restaurants have a cool feel to them and good pricing.
The staff at Golf Rd. has been friendly to me and took time to make sure what I was ordering would be best for my family.
But honestly, even if everyone was a jerk I would eat here and you should too.

Speaking to anyone on the phone is like torture for them. Every time I call to place an order they are so curt and can’t wait to get off the phone. Forget about asking for recommendations.
As far as the pizza it’s pretty bland compared to giordanos but I’ve only tried limited items there