Jeremy’s Pizzeria & Deli

We are big fans of Jeremy’s. Try the stromboli with hot capricola — one of our favorites. Friendly people and great food.

This is the best pizza in Newmarket, in my opinion. The only place that has sundried tomatoes and a very tasteful sauce. I get there garden salads with chicken as well which are also delicious. Most definitely my favorite pizza place in Newmarket!

Food is always good, and Jeremy is a great guy who contributes a lot to the community. Happy to support this business.

the bianco pizza they make here is hands down the most delicious pizza i have ever tasted. like, life-​changing. if you stop in, you have to try it. have tried a few other kinds as well, and all are fresh and delicious. you can tell they use quality ingredients. we order from here every week or so, its so hard to stay away! everyone is always friendly. overall a great place with lots to choose from (TRY THE BIANCO!!!)

I love Jeremy’s. Their food is great, their prices are good and the owner is an amazing part of our town. The atmosphere is relaxed and friendly. You always see somebody you know here. Watch for their specials and their community fundraisers.

We stopped in recently on the recommendation from a friend. My wife and I both got slices of their BBQ chicken pizza. Boy, were we pleasantly surprised! The pizza was very delicious. The crust was nice and thin and crispy. It stood up will to the chicken, BBQ sauce and red onion toppings. no droopy first bites here! We can’t wait to go back and try their other fare.

Great pizza… Lots of different choices. Lots of non-​pizza choices also. My kids love it. Very friendly staff. Never had a bad meal. Very much part of the fabric of Newmarket.

Without a doubt the best place to get some awesome pizza and subs in Newmarket. As a resident of Newmarket I face the challenge of choosing between Jeremy’s, Gepettos, and Panzanellas. The bottom line is Panzanellas service isn’t super great and Gepettos food isn’t super great. Jeremy’s is the obvious choice.

Always a good meal… Very friendly

I Like the pizza overall but their customer service and delivery is bar none the worst in the area. Always, always have to wait for an hour + for a local pizza delivery. I’ve stopped even trying as the pizza would come barely warm and by the 2^nd slice it was cold. I’ve gone elsewhere

Pretty good pizza. Holds up well, nice crust. The only thing I didn’t like is the veggie calzone, it was very soggy. They put marina sauce inside with veggies and mozzarella cheese on top. Could have just left it with ricotta cheese, mozzarella and veggies. Sauce could have been put on the side for dipping.

Great quick food. Pizza is varied and one of the better pizzas in town. Nice selection of popular food, sweet potato fries, fried pickles, subs. Staff is also nice.

Pizza is actually pretty good. They’ve got a really good sauce and thin crust.
This is a small restaurant with very little parking and only a handful of seats.
The owner is an… OK guy. Not the nicest guy in the restaurant business.

By far my favorite pizza place in town, Hawaiian with extra cherries is golden. Friendly staff, good specials and quick turn around.

Ive had food from Jeremy’s several times and only once out of the 5 did I truly enjoy it. The buffalo chicken pizza with blue cheese is delicious, the plain cheese pizza, Calzones, and Stombolis however are bland. The customer service is great, prices are pretty good, but the delivery time and flavor profiles are definitely lacking… So I give 3 stars for «ok» ness.

They made for us a gluten free pizza with no cheese, loaded up with delicious pepperoni, sausage, caramelized onions (you must try these!) veggies and their very respectable tomato sauce, and it was pretty great! The staff is super friendly, and very knowledgeable about the ingredients, so they have no problem answering questions for people with food allergies. They even use dedicated equipment and counter top space for the GF crusts to avoid cross contamination. :swoon:
It was ready rather quickly, too. We live around the corner, so haven’t asked for delivery (it would just be silly). I’ll absolutely be back. Maybe not too often since it’s a little on the expensive side, but definitely not unreasonable for the quality and the fact that it’s so allergy friendly!

Check out the Buffalo Chicken Pizza! Wicked good

Love this place! The price is a little high but there is always coupons for 3 $ off for a large in the mail and that makes it a no brainier. Best pizza in Newmarket and the guys there are always friendly.

Without a doubt the best pizza in Newmarket, you really can’t go wrong here for just about anything. The owner is almost always hanging around during the day and very interactive with the customers. Come here for a casual atmosphere with friendly staff, and killer specialty pizzas. When you call something in, you can usually count on it being ready when they till you it will be, don’t worry about waiting around too long, and it always helps that they have Coca-​Cola products!
The best thing here is the BBQ Chicken Specialty pizza with fried chicken. It comes with a BBQ sauce base, cheese, sauce-​coated fried chicken tenders, tomato, and onion. Great pizza.

Mama Lena’s in Newmarket was recently renamed Jeremy’s Pizzeria & Deli (after the owner) to distinguish itself from Mama Lena’s in Stratham. The menu is still the same offering a variety Italian thin crust pizza, gluten free pizza, calzones, strombolis, subs, roast beef sandwiches, salads, pasta dinners, fried foods, and chilled desserts. The pizza pies are baked in a belt oven. Beer, wine and Coke products are offered. They also sell deli meats too. The shop is pretty cozy with a few tables in front of the counter.
I stopped in here for a bite to eat recently. I’ve had the pizza when the place was Mama Lena’s, which has been consistently very good. I ordered a slice of white pizza (feta, ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, oil) ($ 2.25??) and Linguini with Chicken Dinner ($ 8.75).
The pizza slice was reheated in the oven and was very good with a soft firm thin crust and good toppings. The pasta dinner was pretty decent had firm linguini with soft thick breaded chicken pieces topped with chunky tomato sauce and melted mozzarella. The side salad had fresh romaine lettuce, tomatoes, carrots, and onions. The baked garlic bread was buttery and crispy.
Overall, the food was enjoyable and the pizza here is two thumbs up! I would’ve given this place 4 stars. However, the employee at the register calculated my total with a calculator (can’t the register do tallies?) and came up with a total of $ 13.68 with tax. That didn’t seem correct and I asked him how much the slice of pizza was and he replied $ 2.25. I had him recalculate the total and came up with $ 12.50, which I knew was still 50 cents over and handed over exact change. The management needs to train their employee (s) on charging customers the correct totals with the 9 percent tax. The service from the kitchen was very prompt and I had my order ready in under 15 minutes.