Mama Nita’s

Absolutely love this place. I can’t believe my boyfriend has never brought me here before. Apparently, there is a risk of becoming morbidly obese because the food is so good. Everyone who works there is super friendly and greeted us the moment we walked in. They offered to make special pizza for us. All you can eat buffet includes drinks. The salad selection was perfect; much better than Subway next door. Sauces are great. Pizza was delicious. I loved everything. It’s not fancy — styrofoam plates and plastic ware which was just fine with me. We left completely stuffed for less than twenty dollars total.

This place is a standby. Pizza buffet is great, service is cheerfull, and the cost is very reasonable. Dining area is tiny, and that about the only negative I can think of.

I discovered this awesome little pizza shop quite by accident. I was working in New Pal for a couple of days and at lunchtime my coworker started searching for a Subway. (No, not Subway AGAIN please!) Subs happen to be my coworker’s favorite food group and she was driving. Sigh.
HOWEVER, as she pulled into the Subway parking lot I saw a sign for Mama Nita’s pizza buffet. Next door to Subway! I suggested (ok, demanded) that we check out this buffet.
What a cool place! Several varieties of fresh, hot pizza, tasty breadsticks, soup and a fresh salad bar with a nice selection of ingredients. And ice cream for dessert, included with the buffet.
The employees were very welcoming, friendly and helpful. They asked what kind of pizza I wanted and I told them I was vegetarian. They asked if there were any veggies I didn’t like, and when I said I like all vegetables they made me a pizza that was loaded with veggies. Amazing service for a buffet!
The ice cream treats were a nice extra. A freezer full of ice cream sandwiches, single-​serve ice cream cups in different flavors as well as other treats! It was very convenient to grab an ice cream sandwich on my way out the door because we had to get back to work.
I will definitely return to Mama Nita’s the next time I happen to be in or near New Pal.

A great dining option in New Palestine. The pizza buffet is affordable, fresh, and they’ll make any type of pizza you request. The menu has several options besides pizza from wings, nachos, pasta, and subs. Once a year they offer ‘buy one get one ½ off’ on subs and that’s a steal! Definitely worth stopping in or ordering to go.

This is an awesome local, unique pizza place. They have a buffet every day — they will ask you what kind of pizza you would like them to make for you. The buffet has a fresh, but small, salad bar, along with unlimited ice cream treats for dessert. Their pizza is some of my favorite pizza ever. The bread is sweet and soft, and the tomato sauce is also on the mild and sweet side. They have a great Barbeque chicken pizza, as well as a chicken cordon bleu and a cheeseburger pizza, amongst other specialty pizzas. Like Don said in his review, they keep the buffet stocked the entire time, regardless of how busy they are. Only downside is the seating is fairly limited. They have 2 tvs on, one with sports and one with cartoons for the kids. Highly recommended as a place for families.

Thu place has an insane pizza buffet. If you are around I definitely recommend this for pizza, however, Papa Roux is the best food in town

It’s good! Sometimes pizza Buffett’s leave u sitting waiting for more food… It’s always full of pizza and fresh… And staff is in a good mood and friendly! Fast delivery too.