Wayne’s World Pizzeria & Frozen Dessert Cafe

We have eaten here since first learning about their establishment at the street fair. They are located off rt 59 in nanuet behind PC Richards and the owners and staff are excellent. Very clean and nice family style restaurant. The family style meals are great, the food is fresh and delicious. The owners are hard workers and I definitely recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants good value family style meals and great tasting food. 5 stars to the owners.

Relatively new — it opened in 2015 — Wayne’s World is named not after the movie, but it’s owner, and it’s readily apparent that he and his wife are caring co-​owners whose staff go out of their way to make you feel welcome. We called in a table reservation for a kid’s birthday party and despite us showing up 40 minutes late and with about five more people than expected, Wayne was a more than gracious host. We didn’t get to partake in the frozen yogurt — Wayne’s World cleverly combines the two American favorites of pizza and froyo — but the pizza came in a good size, with two able to feed a party of 12, and I tried a corner Sicilian slice that was to die for. The usual specialty slices are available as well as traditional Italian dishes, in both entrée and family style. It’s a great location for family get togethers, and the space is big enough to host parties without being too constricting. Ample parking and a nice view down Rt. 59 on a clear day makes this joint ideal. Party on, Wayne!

My boyfriend and I wanted to try somewhere new and after reading the reviews for this place we thought we’d give it a try. We decided to go on a Friday night around 7pm, we walked in and it was dead. There was only 3 other customers. The place was pretty nice. It was big and had a lot of nice decorations. It was comfortable which was nice compared to other pizza places.
We sat down and looked at the menu, pretty generic stuff, nothing too special. Our waitress came and we decided to order some appetizers (at least we tried to). They were out of mozzarella sticks AND potato skins… On a Friday night (later realized that we were probably better off cause I’m guessing this stuff is bought pre made in a bag or box). We decided to forgo appetizers since they seemed to be going through a shortage and just ordered a grandma pie. The pizza took a while to be made, especially since by this time we were the only ones in the restaurant. Finally we got our pizza (and finally saw out waitress again) and it was good. Pretty much the same as any other grandma pizza. There wasn’t anything to distinguish it from others making it amazing.
Overall, not very impressed. On a Friday night a pizza place shouldn’t be out for product. Our waitress wasn’t very attentive, too busy doing other things I assume since I rarely saw her. As for the pizza, it was good, it was well made and I enjoyed it. But it wasn’t anything special. The pizza is the only reason that I gave Wayne’s world 3 stars, because although it was just a generic pie, it was good. But this place seriously has to work on other things too. Better training for staff and making sure things are ordered. Might be back again, but until then, just going to stick with my local pizza place.

We stopped in for frozen yogurt tonight. Amazing selection of flavors and topping choices!!! We have had the pizza here before and it is also very good.

I had my sons 6^th birthday party here after it was recommended by other moms in the area and it was a total hit! For $ 16.99 each child got to make their own pizza, create their own sundae and take a tour of both the kitchen and the frozen yogurt area. We had nearly 30 kids and every single one of them was thoroughly entertained. The hostess and her assistant were enthusiastic, friendly and made each of the children feel important.
The kids LOVED their personal made pizzas and my son absolutely loved his signed Wayne’s World shirt. The staff worked hard to accommodate us as we were well over 50 people with kids and adults and we were very well taken care of.
Pricing is fair and the staff was wonderful. We will absolutely be revisiting Wayne’s World and thank them for allowing us to not have another bounce house birthday party! Great work!

Great new place for pizza in Nanuet! I highly recommend the Big Mac pizza. Don’t ask. Just try it. Save some room for dessert because they’ve got great flavor ready to dispense from their wall. You’re missing out if you haven’t been here.

Stopped in with family for ice cream. Make your own station was great and staff was very helpful. Waffle bowl with ice cream was great! We’d go back :-)

This place is great! I had some Alfredo pasta with chicken. This item was not on the menu but they were more than happy to make it for me. Its very family oriented. The staff was very nice. The portion that I got was big and satisfying. I’ll definitively come back to Wayne’s world!

First time there today with my brother and I loved it! It’s more than just regular pizza, cute place and lots of selection. There’s soups salads and frozen yogurt selections. Really enjoyed it, it’s hard to find but I would definite go back again. A sign out from might be beneficial for others to find easier!:)

I feel really bad writing this because I’ve seen the effort put into the place, the fliers, the signs on 59, but this was the worst pizza I’ve ever had. Frozen supermarket is better. We ordered the Smoking Goodfella pizza and, after waiting a considerable amount of time for it to arrive at our table, we were thoroughly disappointed. The pizza, with all of those ingredients, had absolutely NO flavor. I honestly don’t understand how this is possible, but each of the members in my group looked at each other and said the exact same thing.
I’m just baffled at how this is possible… maybe it was a bad batch of ingredients, who knows, but the dough/​crust was flavorless, the various veggies had no flavor, the smoked cheese came through, but that was it.
I’d be willing to give them another try with another pizza, but I’m not even sure the motivation is there after the first experience.
Sorry!

First time… had a chicken caesar salad and a froyo. The salad was fresh, crispy and the dressing very good. Last froyo place in Nanuet! Tart is my favorite. Enjoyed it and definitely will go back, clean and pleasant servers.

Went here after dinner with my mentally challenged brother, my wife & daughter. My brother lives in the area, and he’s got emotional & behavioral problems, so i really appreciate the patience displayed by the owner and a young man working there. The young man was particularly helpful, and seemed interested in having us choose a froyo that we’d be happy with. It helped that they weren’t busy.
The owner (Wayne) told me that this was his first experience owning a restaurant, but that fact isn’t so easy to tell on your own. The place is spacious and comfy & clean.
We didn’t try any pizza or real solid food, so my 5 star review is based solely on this joint as a frozen yogurt destination. Will return.

Stopped in with the wife and kids. Had a 14 inch 6 piece pie and a couple of their salads. The pizza was well cooked with the kids splitting half ziti, half meatball. The cheese and sauce were excellent and worthy of a NYC location. The salads are reasonably priced and very large. My furnace of a 19 year old took half of it home.
The service was attentive and friendly without seeming intrusive.
Perhaps the best part of the meal was the dessert. There is a wall of types and flavors of frozen treats that I spent way too long trying to decide on. There is ice cream, frozen yogurt, sorbet, and in many many different choices. Not to mention all of the normal toppings you would get at a froyo place plus some unique ones like graham cracker crust.
Overall it was a great experience and we were very happy we found this gem on the way back home. The prices were reasonable so If you are in or near Nanuet definitely stop in and give it a try. It may become your go to family spot.
Party on Wayne!

Don’t let the hard to see from the road location behind PC Richards deter you from trying Wayne’s World! Nice and new inside. A full pizzeria menu plus pastas and entrees. All made with top notch ingredients. They custom made the best huge spinach Stromboli I ever had. Frozen yogurt by the ounce — very kid friendly. Kinda like what I call a «Jersey place» — big servings of good food at fair prices in a relaxed atmosphere.

Went here yesterday for a late lunch. The food and service were both good. My girlfriend and I had some garlic knots and a few specialty pizza slices. One slice had mushrooms, mozzarella, prosciutto, cooked onions and other items. It was different and very tasty. This is a good pizza place worth visiting.

I went to this establishment tonight for some frozen yogurt. I was happy I came here the flavors here are very unique. As I arrived everyone was very friendly I felt welcomed and wanted. This place is very clean and they serve pizza beer ice cream and salads. Definitely worth coming to show some support to this mom and pop shop. The flavors were great and will come back here to try the pizza and the beer. If you read this review this establishment is located behind the pc Richards parking lot. So definitely stop by and show some support.

I really like this place. Their pizza is fabulous, very flavorful. I also like their frozen yogurt and create your own salads. All my favorite foods under one roof! It has a very fun, laid back and trendy atmosphere and the service was great. I will definitely be coming back!

I stepped in here during their grand opening. I was quite surprised and have been a regular since then. I thought it was simply a pizza place but was quite surprised when I saw all the frozen yogurt. One of the employees walked over and explained who it worked. You serve yourself the goods and serve yourself the various toppings on the side. I Have a chocolate-​vanilla mix with Snickers and strawberry and it surely hit the spot. They also gave a frequent user tag card. For every 9 pizza pies or ice cream you get, you get the 10^th one free. Their gourmet pizza is awesome as well. I had their Big Mac pizza that actually tasted like well, big Mac. Their ranch dressing bacon pizza was also quite awesome. The service is really good and management is quite attentive. I hope they do well.

Appalling.
Our delivery order was placed at Sunday lunch time. We were told to expect the food in half an hour and then waited twice that. This is annoying but understandable.
The food was the driver of the low rating. We ordered 3 items:
The chicken wings were soggy and flavorless.
The Grandma’s pie was a disaster. The dough was raw as you moved from the corner slices. The marinara sauce was sweet. The slices (yes, like a supermarket cheese slice) of cheese were sparse and tasteless.
The bottle of soda was perfect.
Another pizza shop in this location that looks doomed.

My wife and I visited Wayne’s World after reading about it in the Rockland County Times. We shared a create your own salad (chopped and tossed) which was huge and delicious, and then delved into the Sicilian pizza pie which was so good it reminded me of Brooklyn!
The ambiance/​décor is really nice and the staff very courteous. We will definitely be back soon.