Two Cousins Pizza

Pizzas here are always wonderful! Perfect crust. Chicken bacon ranch is a great choice. Homemade fresh bread. Salads are always very fresh. Strombolis are to die for! Absolutely love everything here and super friendly staff.

Was I supposed to ask for sauce on my pizza? Bet my last money that the broccoli on my veggie pizza came from a frozen block. Won’t do this again

Very nice people and the food was very ordinary. I would guess that ingredients are all from Sysco. We will not come back.

Great pizza, best buffalo chicken pizza I ever had. Avoid Today’s pizza they are the worst pizza I’ve ever had! Stick to Two Cousins Pizza they are awesome

Jason Loraw
The only thing not to love about this place is that they’re closed on Tuesdays, besides that GO THERE NOW AND ENLIGHTEN YOUR TASTE BUDS! The food there is amazing and made with love like grandma use to. Been to other two cousins and although they all share a name a lot of the recipes have a bit of a twist. Mt. Joys two cousins prepare the food a bit different with attention to detail and the bread they use for the subs is to die for. The chicken cacciatore sub is highly recommended. Pizza is delicious, the pasta is cooked to perfection. Bottom line, go and if you’re short on time, call your order in they’ll have it ready for you to pick it up. It will still be hot by the time you get home. Trust me, we live in Mannheim township. So worth the drive!

This is top notch pizza for this part of PA. The owner is from Italy and the food is made much like you would find with NY Style pizza taste. The restaurant is on the small side but the staff has always been friendly anytime I have been here.

Growing up in New Jersey I was always surrounded by amazing Pizzeria’s. However, moving to central PA 5 years ago I quickly learned that for the most part pizza in this area is just garbage.
Two Cousins is one of the few exceptions, amazing pizza!

By far the best pizza shop in the area! Their bread is made fresh and put’s their subs over the top. I highly recommend either the Italian off the cold menu, or the Cheese steak of the hot.
As far as the pizza goes, outstanding! I have never had a bad experience. The cheese, sauce, and toppings are always in just the right amounts.
Another plus for Two Cousins is that it is the only pizza place in Mount Joy that you can actually enjoy an ice cold beer with your pizza or sub!

love their subs since its fresh bread… but omg the pizza was horrible. we ordered a regular cheese pizza… one problem… NO SAUCE. how do you not put sauce on a pizza??? i was so disappointed… we won’t be going there for pizza again.

Puts most pizza shops to shame. Their bread is made fresh daily so the subs and pizza are outstanding. Because of Two Cousins Pizza, I can only enjoy a sub made with fresh bread. My personal favorite is a cheese steak calzone and a cold picture of Stella Artois (yes, they serve beer). There are three TVs for your viewing enjoyment. In summary, you will have a hard time finding a better pizza shop.

The food is quite good. I’d probably say, the best italian in Mount Joy — but I’ve had horrible service on more than one occasion.
Food — the hoagies are great because they make their own fresh bread. My personal choice is the eggplant parmesan sub. If they could learn to put the cheese on it without sticking it all to the foil — that would be an amazing thing, but… so far, no luck.
Service — Adequate to lousy. They usually will take your order nd then forget about you. If you want something else, you’d better make it known loudly. On one occasion, I came in after a 20 mile bike ride and was a bit unkept. I sat for over 15 minutes and while the waitress walked by over ten times, she never even acknowledged me. I got up and left.
They have an odd drive through window — yes a good pizza shop with a drive through. This is how I usually get my food. Otherwise you could get completely ignored. Why do I come back? Its a damn good eggplant parm sub.
They recently, and stupidly added a «bar» (two stools) where the food pickup window used to be. So now there is no good place to hand you food over the counter if someone is sitting there enjoying a beer.
Stick to the take out…

This place makes a legit toasted tuna sub (S&P, oregano, oil). Other toasted subs are good too. Homemade (daily) sub rolls are AWESOME.
Remainder of menu seems solid too. Décor is nice enough, clean. I believe they may serve ice cream too (it’s been a while since I’ve been there). For some reason I prefer this location though E. Pete is also nice (E. Pete is owned by the founder who sold off the other independently owned Two Cousins after getting them up and running). These tend to be owned by first/​second generation Sicilians/​Italians. The picture should be helpful when finding TC at night. Ciao.