DiMarias Pizza & Italian Kitchen

My wife and I thought we’d try out a new pizza place in town tonight and we placed an order online through their website and even got a confirmation email that the order was placed. We waited an hour before calling to check on where our food was and we were told they don’t do online orders, even though their website has an entire area dedicated to it (click «Online Orders» in the top right hand corner of their website). They offered to take our oder anyway, but required a minimum $ 35 order to deliver about two miles across town. Clearly they’re going to be bothered with servicing their customers. Really just kind of annoyed they claimed they don’t offer online orders when they do, guessing they just lost our order, or maybe don’t have it set up correctly on their website, but if that’s the case, take it offline, don’t lie and say it’s not there.

I’m from New York City and recently moved down to Mount Joy. My wife and I were looking for a pizza joint and stumbled upon this store. We walked in, had a waitress address us, and noticed a young male who seemingly worked there on his cell phone. The young man raised his head and began awkwardly staring at both my wife and I. This lasted the entire duration of our stay — which, consequently, was short. I’d recommend the managers taking note of this individual as it made the environment seemingly hostile. It’s also important to note the possible time theft taking place as he obviously wasn’t working and wasting the store’s time.
While trying to ignore the inbred staring at us, we looked at the limited selection of pizza and decided to take our business elsewhere. Their slices looked as if they were made the day prior and nothing stood out to us.
We live down the street, but we’ll venture elsewhere. Today’s pizza is right next door — and though their selection is even worse than yours — at least it was cooked today and not yesterday.

Used to be our favorite in the area. Vince & family did an amazing job. Homemade lasagna. Jersey tomato pie, all well prepared and delicious. Hadn’t been in for a while but stopped last week. Not sure what happened but it’s not the same quality or taste. Vince is gone. Pizza was just OK, sandwiches nothing special. We lost a great place to eat, won’t return anytime soon.

Had a Buffalo Chicken Personal pizza and it was basically greasy flavorless pizza with undercooked crust and a few slices of chicken. I’m not sure how our why it was so greasy, it may have been the cheese but it definitely wasn’t from the blue cheese that was supposed to be on it (according to the menu) because it was non existent. I’ll give 2 stars just because the waitress was ok and the place is nice and clean but the pizza deserves no better than 1. An FYI for DiMarias, BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA IS SUPPOSE TO HAVE BUFFALO SAUCE ON IT.

We loved DiMaria’s until it changed ownership about a year and a half ago. It is now owned by the owners of Today’s Pizza (along with all other Pizza places in Mount Joy). Every time we go, there is an issue and we vow to not go back we give it a few months and then we give it another shot only to be disappointed again. Some issues are small but still should not happen. Last week we gave it another shot and the pizza was not cut and they forgot the ranch dressing that we paid extra for. We called to let them know and they told us to come back but we were not interested in going back, we just want them to be good again. This place is literately across the street from our house and we go to DiMaria’s in Lititz as they are still owned by ownership that cares about their product and customers.

Stopped in to DiMaria’s in MJ yesterday. Mr. Vince sold his store. My family ordered a cheese steak sandwich and cheese pizza. Everything was supposed to be the same under the new ownership. Sadly it was not. Flavorless sauce & barely any cheese on the pizza that was now smaller in size. The cheesesteak had less meat and cheese on it. Not piping hot. Quality standards did start going down after Vince opened the new store in Lititz due to Vince being at the new store & neglecting his MJ shop. This used to be our main stop and sadly hasn’t been for a while. Now we probably won’t step in to the MJ shop at all again.

This is the ONLY place in the area for a real, authentic Jersey Pie. Sauce is made in the classic Philly/​Jersey style with excellent flavor and acidity that gives brightness and depth to the cheese and dough. If you are a transplant looking for a pie like you get in Jersey or Philly then this is the place for you. If you love pizza (and think domino’s actually makes an edible product) then this place will open your eyes to what pizza is suppose to taste like.

Great food. Expensive, but you will get your money’s worth. Would you rather pay less for junk or get top of line food? I recommend the buffalo chicken cheesesteak.

As a New York native, I’d say this is the closest you are going to get to decent pizza.

Just moved to Mt. Joy and already had their pizza 3 times. Love it. Great pizza. We will be eating here very often.
The cheese, the sauce, and the dough. Perfection. Freaking awesome.

Just stopped by to pick up an upside down personal pizza – it tastes like I’m back in Little Italy! Friendly staff too. I’ll be back pronto!

I will def come back. Pizza was great and French fries are flaky and crunchy. Cheesesteak and sub were great too!

Words can not express how much I love this place! There are some weeks I’ll go there at least twice, it is that good. Vince and company really know how to cook, which is a rarity in Mount Joy, which has a slew of pizza places. Dimaria’s sits atop the pizza food chain. The pizza’s are great, (make sure to try the tomato pie too!), I think the real standouts are the homemade pasta dishes. Nothing tastes like it came out of a jar or a box. The vodka rigatoni may just change your life. No I’m serious, try it and then get back to me. Spaghetti with garlic and oil, huge pieces of lasagna… no matter what it is, every single dish is superb. The staff, led by Vince, go out of their way to make you feel welcome and a part of the family. It always cracks me up when I call, and Vince answers by asking if I want my usual. It’s that attention to their customers that makes them extremely loyal patrons This little place in a strip mall is a culinary gem! I can’t wait to go back!

Nothing special about this place. If you want better pizza in the area go to Papa’s or Two Cousins.

Although it appears to be a typical pizza place, the food really is amazing, always very fresh, and a little more unique than comparable restaurants. The staff is always very friendly and outgoing too.
Definitely check it out!

Best pizza in the area! We love going there, they import the ingredients in from Philly. It’s delicious!