The pizza is not bad; I like it. But I have to give a shoutout to their chicken fingers with honey mustard. I swear, it may be the best chicken fingers I have ever had(btw, it may appear burnt, but it’s not). Don’t forget the honey mustard! My one problem is the lack of brains either the person on the phone has who takes the order or the kitchen. Multiple times I’ve ordered a pizza pie to have half of it with pepperoni and the other half sausage(sounds simple, I think)– once the pie came with it all mixed with pepperoni and sausage, another time it had one half mixed with sausage and pepperoni and the other half plain. How many different ways can you screw that up? Still tastes good.
Michelle C.
Classificação do local: 3 Morristown, NJ
They need to up their game with delivery service. Too many times it has taken close to two hours to get a pizza delivered. That’s too long a wait.
Orlaith B.
Classificação do local: 2 Morristown, NJ
Pizza is really tasty. However, I waited 2 hours for it to arrive after being told on the phone it would be 45 minutes? 45 minutes is ridiculous in itself never mind 2 hours. The girl on the phone didn’t care whatsoever and said she would get the manager to call me. Still waiting on that call. When the delivery man arrived he explained they let the other driver away early? Terrible.
Michelle E.
Classificação do local: 5 Morristown, NJ
Anthonys pizza is delicious and very family oriented. The food is all fresh and homemade. The pizza slices are huge so your getting a lot of bang for your buck! The chefs are super sweet and the owner Rudy is so welcoming and personable!
Mike M.
Classificação do local: 4 Whitehouse Station, NJ
My son and I stopped here for a quick dinner. We both had the chicken parm dinner. I have to say it was better than expected. The portion size was not huge like some pizzerias may give you but better tasting and just enough. Also included a small house salad with bread. The people working there we very accommodating. You cannot beat the price in Morristown New Jersey. You walk up and order and they bring it to the table. I did see the slices of pizza which looked quite large. I did not have a chance to try them though. All in all a pretty good find.
Paula R.
Classificação do local: 5 Morristown, NJ
I always ask for extra thin crust, well done. I get the same perfect pizza every time. Kudos, you guys. I’ll never go anywhere else.
Meghan H.
Classificação do local: 5 Morristown, NJ
Anthonys food is delicious and their staff even better. After a little mix up tonight they were super understanding and I would definitely recommend them simply on that only.
George C.
Classificação do local: 1 Morristown, NJ
disappointed with the burgers… not a good experience.
Alicia P.
Classificação do local: 1 Cranford, NJ
Pizza was okay… nothing to rave about but edible. My biggest problem was the person working. The young cashier was really nice but there was an older lady behind the counter that literally just stared my friend and I down as we were ordering. The dirty looks and eyeing up and down was so uncomfortable that I wanted to just walk out. I wish I would have! Either walk out or ask what her problem with us was. I’ve never experienced anything like it before in my life. The only thing worse than bad food is bad service. I will not be returning.
Abi B.
Classificação do local: 1 Chatham Township, NJ
We have been loyal customers of Anthony’s for years. We first moved here about six years ago and have always gotten our pizza from them. Parking is abysmal so we usually get our pizza delivered. Over the years we’ve seen delivery service become slower and slower, and at this point it’s atrocious. We ordered a pie last week and it took one hour and thirty-seven minutes for ONE pizza to arrive at our house. I just checked on google, we live exactly nine minutes away. I could have walked there, made my own pizza in their kitchen, walked home, and still beat the delivery person. Sorry to say we will now be trying out Godfather’s.
Lana S.
Classificação do local: 2 Cedar Knolls, NJ
The pizza was cold. The wrap wasn’t toasted and they forgot to include the marinara sauce I asked for on the side. Also, the woman delivery driver was beyond rude. First, she called me to find out where I live since the address wasn’t coming up in her GPS. ok, that’s fine but she was anything but pleasant. Then, she called back to ask me how to get there because she didn’t like the way her GPS was showing. Last time I checked, I wasn’t the delivery person or a map.
James C.
Classificação do local: 4 Summit, NJ
I had a bad experience with delivery one time(cheese and toppings slipped all the way off the pizza) but I’ve got some great pies when picked up. Haven’t had much else on the menu but friends say everything is pretty good.
Amber C.
Classificação do local: 3 Manhattan, NY
Overall, it was just ok. I only ordered a couple slices of pizza but it was nothing special to write home about. I almost forgot to mention the sauce tastes like it comes from a can.
Diana H.
Classificação do local: 2 Morris Plains, NJ
We live nearby, I love pizza, and there was a Groupon deal, so we thought why not? We went on a Monday and ordered a chicken parm pizza to share. Based on the pizza and french fries we received alone(we didn’t try anything else, so I can’t speak for the sandwiches or pasta), I was disappointed. The fries were okay and pretty standard; they didn’t come very salted which we like. As for the pizza, the crust was probably the best part. The chicken pieces were very small, the cheese was thin, and for someone who really enjoys having pizza, I begrudgingly finished two slices just so I wouldn’t leave hungry. The ambiance was clean and nice enough, as was the staff, so 2 stars for the fries and people. We probably won’t return to try anything else.
Jane M.
Classificação do local: 2 Morris County, NJ
I really wanted to like this place and I am only giving it two stars because the folks who work there are really nice. But the restaurant needs a complete makeover, the floor tiles are all cracked and it really needs to be cleaned up. The portion size for a Chicken Parm hero is small. For a quick bite it is fine but nothing to write home about. They have a prime location on the Green and really need to step up their game.
Anthony I.
Classificação do local: 5 Morris Plains, NJ
Quality food and great service in a cozy spot with great music! The owner is a friendly guy who goes out of his way to please a customer. I have been coming to this place for fifteen years and it has grown into a wonderful comfortable establishment that is very humble. They have amazing dinners and an awesome music crowd on tuesdays. If your looking for fancy its not your place but the sandwiches are out of this world and the pizza and pasta is a taste of italy itself. I highly recommend this pizza joint and if you stop in say hello to rudy!
Jessica H.
Classificação do local: 3 East Brunswick, NJ
I went to dinner with a group of 4 on a Saturday night. We used a livingsocial voucher for $ 30 worth of food and it got us more than enough! I ordered the eggplant rollatini and my boyfriend ordered the veal parm. We both thought that our entrees were pretty good and both came with a massive amount of pasta. My friends ordered the baked ziti and a personal pizza, and both seemed to like them. I also liked the cheesey garlic bread. The servers didn’t seem to know what to do when guests came in to dine. We had to walkover to the counter and ask for menus and for glasses for the wine(it’s a BYOB). It was also kind of awkward towards the end– they started putting up chairs and dimming the lights– they could’ve let us know they were closing! With so many other restaurants to try on the green, Anthony’s is probably a better option if you want to order in. You will probably get more atmoshphere and better service elsewhere.
Nima M.
Classificação do local: 4 Hackensack, NJ
I go to Anthony’s at least 2 – 3 times a week for lunch. It is one of the most reasonably priced and quality pizza places in Morristown. The owner, Rudy, is one of the friendliest guys and he will make anything you ask for. The food quality is excellent and prepared to order so you know it’s fresh. The pizza is good(plain or sicilian) and the sandwiches are great. I’d say probably the best cheesesteak sandwich in Morristown. Their grilled chicken breast sandwich is also delicious as well. It’s definitely a great place to go for lunch with coworkers.
Krista B.
Classificação do local: 1 Maplewood, NJ
How have I not complained about Anthony’s yet? The staff is nice, and that is about the only good thing I have to say. This place is as boring as it gets. They are skating by solely on location. Fries are mushy. Their pizza has no flavor. Tasteless sauce and cheese, gross slimy canned mushrooms. I ordered a stromboli and got a calzone with a soggy crust. I had to wait for it to start to congeal to even attempt to eat the sodden mass of flavorlessness. Go down the hill to Pete’s for a real pie.
Bianca C.
Classificação do local: 3 Springfield, NJ
This place is yummy & efficient. I live in Calif. & was able to order food for my BF who works in Morristown without any hassle. The delivery minimum is also more than reasonable, the person who took my order was apt to take a credit card payment over the phone, friendly, & helpful. I called 5 diff places b4 hand, but I basicly needed to buy food for the entire office with their minimum & they still couldn’t take my payment by phone or said they didn’t do such a thing PERIOD! Very nice to know I can surprise my beb from across the country with lunch. Thanx Anthony! I ordered my BF a grilled chicken sandwich with salad, he said it was all nice & fresh. The salad looked so yummy! Here is a pix & it speaks for its self.