Diamonds In the Rough

Came by last year to rid of lots of good clothes and caught the bug of buying! Zach is the star of that store. It’s like a vortex, a dangerous place that draws you and gets you spending unintentionally. Good thing the prices are great (although some items are pricey). Some of my favorites. Catherine malandrino dress, velvet and michael stars tees, paul green boots, faconnable button dowm. Lots of classics and hip stuff, accessories too. Feels like its a lot of high end stores rolled into one and the sustainable concept of vintage and consigned stuff make the best sense for earth friendly Marin folks!
Mich friendlier and better choices among the Millvalley consignment stores.

Very disappointed to drive 30 minutes to visit the store only for it to be closed on a Friday at 5:30, their hours posted said they should be open right now.
* update
I was very pleasantly surprised to get a message from the owner about the special circumstances that led to closing the store early that day, I was more disappointed about missing an opportunity to visit this great store! Thanks for reaching out to me!

I love consignment stores and have been to MANY across the country. This one is one of the best. The service is wonderful. They are very nice and helpful (a problem in many consignment shops I go to). The store is extremely organized. Easy to find things by color and size. Nice quality designer items all in good condition. It’s a dangerous place to visit and have never walked out without a shopping bag. I live in San Francisco and this is worth the drive up to Mill Valley.

Very clean and well organized. Great selection of name brands. Really unique dresses! I scored on a few times. Very satisfied.

I am a frequent shopper and consigner of consignment shops. I found this place just recently. What I really like about this place and why it works well for me is the large selection of small sizes. I almost thought the entire store was dedicated to size small but there are some mediums and larges. What I don’t like are the prices. Many items I looked at were priced too high but labels and or quality were not reflective of that. It’s still fun to look and some items are marked down further.

First time here, and I scored! Got a great pair of shoes, great price, completely NEW, and they were having a 20% off sale to boot. The owner is very pleasant and helpful, and seems to have a passion for his job.
Lots of cute things, good brands, and good prices. Nice place to check out when you are in the neighborhood. Parking is a bit of problem, so plan accordingly. I had to jay walk (run!) across the street to get to the store.
I do have to agree with the other reviewer that most of the clothes are for skinny sistas. I wear a size L/​12, and there was very little in that size.

Great consignment store for either consigning or purchasing. They make consigning items so easy and they also have the cutest things! Definitely a shop to check out on either buying or consigning! Love them! Check it out!

I just came from Diamonds and want to tell the world how wonderful it is. Let’s start with Zach, who is the most welcoming, sweet, positive person I think I have ever met. To me, that is worth its weight in gold as there are plenty of not-​so-​friendly folks out there in «service» positions who interact with the public. Anyway, they have great pieces that are merchandised nicely by color and size. They have a great selection but not so much that it’s overwhelming. Designer labels abound. I was consigning and also picked up an adorable pair of biker boots and sweet little necklace. I may do all my shopping there from now on. Consigning was a breeze, unlike other shops in Mill Valley, and I have no doubt my things will sell. Thank you!

Great store! I came in a few months ago with my friend, not expecting to buy anything. I found a leather jacket here that I loved, but wasn’t sure I wanted to buy because of the price. I had been looking for one already, but hadn’t found «the right one» yet. well, I found the right one here! I spent about 15 minutes trying to decide whether to buy the jacket, (one of those situations where you don’t fall in love with the item til you bring it home and wear it out) and the man behind the counter gave me a discount to make my decision easier. I usually don’t shop at consignment stores, but this one was great! If I lived in Mill Valley I’d shop here more.

I’ve read the other reviews and see there are great comments about the other owner, Sybil, however I Have never had a chance to meet her. Zach has been there everytime I have gone in (usually with my mother) and I have to say that he is one of the nicest store owners I have ever had the pleasure of meeting. They always play great music (Aretha!!) and they organize by size and color, which makes for a visually pleasing shopping experience. Thanks for all the great deals and all of the help, Zach!

The store is great but what makes it even more appealing are the owners. All in all I spent about an hour in this store during my first visit and would have stayed longer if I had not had a previous appointment at the nail salon nearby. The owner made me feel welcomed as soon as I walk in. He spent time explaining where I could find shoes, certain sizes of designers, and explaining the consignment process. Both customer service and satisfaction make up the key to my pocket book! I will definitely be back here as a regular just to check in for new merchandise. I saw everything here from high end designers to some great pieces of Splendid and James Perse that I had to take home with me. Outstanding prices! Great people to buy from.

Love love love this little hide-​away! It’s name is a slight misnomer because they do have plenty of gems in the shop. Sybil is a delight and has created a cozy styley experience for consigners and shoppers alike. Prices range from completely affordable to a bit of a stretch, but SO worth it for high quality, gently pre-​owned clothes, shoes, boots, bags, coats, and more.

I LOVE this store. The owners, Sybil and Zak are very helpful with locating merchandise in the store that fits individual style and providing honest feedback, without being pushy.
I have literally acquired a new wardrobe with their extremely lovely options — tops, sweaters, dresses, jackets, shoes, belts. They keep their merchandise moving; it seems that if it has been there for awhile goes on sale, making room for new arrivals.
The store is Full of high end, in great shape, fashion forward, high end brands! Their prices allow someone like me who as champagne taste, to walk out with gorgeous new outfits.
Highly recommend Diamond’s girls best friend!

Cute stuff, but overpriced. I wouldn’t recommend this place.

Very cute store with a large selection of well-​selected clothing. Was not very impressed by the shoes or handbag selection, though. The owners are very nice and there was a 20% off sale the day we went.
My only real beef with the store is that most of the clothing is size small. The selection of medium and large size clothing was not as plentiful or good.

It’s stores like this that make me adore consignment. Treasures at every turn — strappy Gucci heels that look like they’ve barely been worn, a classic prada sweater, and the crowning glory the sweet and oh-​so-​helpful owner hooked me up with the rick Owens lambskin jacket of my dreams. Great prices, good quality, I’ll be back!

This place is wonderful I have learned the consigners I like and when they typically consign and have yet tobe dissapointed. The brand names are amazing as with the care and quality of the garments. The couple who ownes the store is so friendly and ALWASY gives me a «teachers» discount! I just wish they were open more :)

This is the best consignment shop in town. The merchandise changes constantly, and I never know just what brands I’ll find here — several Johnny Was, Jimmy Choos, AK, Joe’s jeans and more. I’m always presently surprised! The items are priced very well too. Mill Valley is lucky to have such a great place to shop.

I’ve lived in Mill Valley for about four years, and never knew this was here. I have gone to the other consignment store downtown, and wish I had started here! Much better merchandise and prices.
The service is excellent, the clothes are delightful, and there’s lots of deals on top of the deals. The down side of this shop is the location… you feel like you are walking into the thrift store, but do not let this distract you. The interior is terrific, and very well run.
The owner wrapped all my purchases in paper, and carried my bags to the door.

Owners are super sweet!
GREAT prices for jeans, great brands, perfectly worn in & comfy. I can find fabulous jeans there for under $ 20.
I’ve seen all these brands:
7 For All Mankind, AG, Citizens of Humanity, Free People, Hudson, J Brand, Joe’s, Lucky Brand, Rock & Republic, Tag, True Religion, Vigoss & William Rast
My last visit I got a Tory Burch dress and Ralph Lauren button down shirt for $ 10/​each. As well as some thigh high black boots for about $ 10!
They have shoes (Saw a pair of tall black Gucci boots and some Prada heels) purses, jewelry, jackets and more.
Good deals! Thank you Marin women!
To my knowledge, I’ve only seen Women’s clothing (no kids or men)