Jerry & Joe’s Pizza

It was 10 o’clock last night and I was craving pizza and every New York style pizza place that I could think of was closed. Then I find Jerry’s and joes online I love that they’re open late and the pizza is fabulous it’s wonderful I’m in love definitely coming back!!!

While in high school this is all I ate and loved it. These days when I want to indulge and have close by pizza joint that never disappoints … I come here.

Very unique pizza taste. Not like Papa Johns or Pizza Hut. It’s much more authentic and less greasy. SO GOOD

First time here, I got two slices to try it out. The slices came out within 10 minutes, hot and not bad at all, If you like New York style that is.
I was looking at the pictures they have on Unilocal, showing bars in front of the registered they’re gone. Looks like they may have a new owner, but don’t know for sure. They have a few tables to eat in, but it’s more like a take out delivery place.
I’ll be back for a second try, as for delivery and delivery time I can’t say. The take out seemed to be about average for a pizza place. I’m giving them 3 stars, because it’s my first time here, but if it’s like this next time I would go up to 4 stars.

Just ordered my first pie there… it is simply terrible — undercooked, gummy and no flavor or not good flavor. They also cut the large pie up in to 2″ wide slices «Why»? How in the world do they stay in business? Overall the place is a dump, a couple of small tables to sit and wait facing the counter and parking lot. No personality at the counter or over the phone and the pie is just really bad… I will not go back there again. I’ll stick with Steve’s Pizza until I find someplace better. Jeff

One of the worst pizzas I have ever ordered hands down. If you want a pie made with no love what so ever order from jerry and joes. Stale, tasteless food & expensive. To describe it, you can imagine eating cardboard.

How is a pizza place 10 minutes away and on a Sunday night at 830 it takes over an hour to get a pizza! The pizza itself isn’t bad (not hot) but very disappointed In the time it took!

Jerry and Joe’s Pizza only offers take-​out. The pizza is ok. I am rating this place three stars because I am being nice. The cheese made up most of the flavor. The pizza had too much dough and not enough flavor. Wouldn’t return.

I tried Jerry and Joe’s for the first time a few weeks ago and was very happy with my order. Tonight I decided to try them again, I ordered th Veal Parmesan and spaghetti. The dish was exceptional. I highly recommend anyone try Jerry & Joes!

Been ordering pizza here for years. Large portions. Great service. Pizza quality Not always consistent.

We ordered 4 XL pies from Jerry & Joe’s. My family unanimously agreed that the quality of the pizza was excellent. Everything from the pizza dough, cheese, & toppings tasted fresh & delicious. I’m going to have to a agree with my fellow Unilocalers review and agree with the fact that Jerry & Joe’s pizza makes the best pizza in Cutler Bay. Sorry Steve’s Pizza I’ve jumped ship for good. Nothing personal against Steve’s, Jerry & Joe just flat out make a better pie!

There are many people talking about Jerry & Joe’s Pizza that I had to check out this place. Wow, the pizzas are large. One slice was actually bigger than both my hands combined. Unfortunately, the serving size is the only thing commendable with their pizza. Yes, the pizza was good but it wasn’t that great as well. I had something better than this before.
This place might have large servings but food is pretty much average. So if you feel like treating yourself with gourmet pizza, try some place else. But if you just want to enjoy devouring large pizza servings, then you’d like it.

Ok — let’s get one thing out of the way. It can take a long time to get a pizza. They’re seriously understaffed — they’re hiring though, so hopefully this doesn’t last much longer!
That being said…
This is hands down, the BEST pizza in the Cutler Bay area. My husband is a pizza junkie, and we always do a first judgment on whether or not a place can make a good cheese pizza. If they can’t even do cheese, they can’t do anything right! If the cheese passes, we will try other combos. We have tried Steve’s, Lillo’s, Sal’s, Cazzoli’s and many more in the area and this is the best!
We have had friends try it and the response is always the same — «Wow… Which pizza is this?» And then they are hooked.
It’s worth the wait!

We decided to give this place a try based on reviews below. The young lady taking the order via phone was pleasant. Getting the pizza was a nightmare! The driver probably wouldn’t know his elbow from his @ss if it wasn’t labeled. We spent over 15 minutes on the phone guiding him to our place. We told him to travel south and explain to me how he ended up 1 – 2 miles north on US1. By the time the pizza arrived it literally had slid to the side of the box from the u-​turns he made finding us. Needless to say we returned it. They made good on trying to fix the issue and 20 mins later the replacement pizza arrived. Again cheese sliding off the crust from pizza rolling around in the car. The pizza itself is one step above Little Caesars. The garlic knots were good though, not good enough to convince me to order from here again though. I’m sticking to Steve’s or Mario’s, heck even Pizza Hut.

You know, I just really enjoy their pizza. I love how thin it is, I love the flavors, it isn’t as greasy as pizza hut and their garlic knots are delicious! I will admit that the garlic knots have lately been rather lackluster, needing just a bit more flavor but they are cheap and quick and good.

Good pizza! Nothing fancy but they were fast the food was hot and we got a lot for a great price!!! I say if u have a chance give them a call!

I must start this review with a warning if you look at their website don’t expect the pizza to look remotely similar to the pictures on the website. That being said the pizza wasn’t half bad. I had the mountain pizza which I suppose is the equivalent to a supreme. Crust was thin not crispy but not doughy either. And the toppings were good as well. I do highly recommend the garlic rolls– some of the best I’ve had.

Ordered delivery for my kids and babysitter for when my husband and I were going out. They were out of 2 liter lemonade and WENT OUT TO GET IT FOR US before the delivery! Hats off to Jerry and Joe’s!!!

Not a bad Pizza joint. They claim to be NY style, but lacks that NY Pizza taste. Their Pastas are not bad, but a little watery. Over all if you are really hungry and are in the area, it won’t hurt eating from there.