Mafia Mike’s Pizza

I received a call from them after submitting my online order around 3:30 to resolve two issues: a driver wouldn’t be on the clock until 5 so delivery would be 20 minutes later and they had not yet removed the cheesecake bites from their menu and offered an alternative. I’m easy going and totally understand. After all, this is a local business who may not always have enough staff. Everything was fine with my chicken Alfredo, breadsticks, and cheesecake but not the spinach artichoke dip. The oil and cheese had separated in transit. I really tried to re-​emulsify it but it was not salvageable. I’ll try them again but I would suggest they remove that item at least from the delivery options. The driver was very nice and arrived within the time expected.

That’s a spicccccy pizza sauce!!! Decent pizza, very crust based, lower toppings. Good flavor, delivery guy was very friendly. Worth a try.

This pizza was the bomb. I literally could not stop eating it. They have multiple varieties of toppings so you can get whatever type of pizza you can fathom. The customer service was also top notch. I can really tell that the owner has a passion for what he does!

Just ordered from GrubHub. The pizzas were cold, no ranch for the wings, and no potato salad at all. It took 1.5 hours to get delivered and the driver said it was a really long drive. Maybe they should reevaluate their delivery zones, but I will definitely not order from them again. The pizzas were mediocre and the wings looks like they needed to be cooked a little longer. We didn’t eat them.

First visit here was for the lunch buffet. Pizza was decent, good service. They made a pizza at my request. Since then I’ve ordered delivery maybe 4 – 5 times. First order was for a sandwich. Wasn’t too thrilled with it honestly, and it was missing half the toppings I requested. My subsequent orders have been for medium pizzas (which are decent sized btw) alfredo with ham. Their alfredo sauce is great, rich and flavorful. On my last order I got my alfredo with ham but the pizza came with what seemed to be ricotta cheese instead of the alfredo. Was odd, and bland. I’ll continue giving them my business, they just need to be a little more attentive in fulfilling orders correctly and it’d be a solid 4 star experience.

Pretty good. Picked up a pizza an hour before closing and it was still hot and fresh. I did a little research on Unilocal before I tried their pizza for the first time. Decided on The Boss. I agree with the other Unilocalers regarding the spiciness of the sauce but, it’s not overpowering. The amount of sauce was just right. I hate a dry pizza! The crust seemed a little tough though. If I get more coupons, I’ll hold on to them. A large pizza was $ 20. Ouch! The price would be reasonable if the pizza had more toppings. It seemed a little skimpy for the price point.

This is the first time my family and I ordered Mafia Mikes. I would like to say that I was very pleased with the delivery. I didn’t have to give them instructions how to get to my house. They were on time the food was still warm and very delicious. Which I can’t say that about other restaurants around the area. No bad review here. My husband enjoyed their hot wings and the Rat Pizza. You get what you pay for. Would we order from them again? You bet.
Side note: I noticed that the sauce for the pizza was a bit spicy. And if your not into that thing, I’m just giving you a heads up.

We really like this place! Fresh, hand-​tossed crust and a zesty sauce with a bit of a kick. We usually get the Boss (supreme) and the Rat (cheese). The Rat isn’t your average greasy, rubbery cheese pizza for the kids; it’s loaded with different kinds of cheese and that spicy sauce… Mmmm.
We almost always order carry out. The dining room is small and very basic. We’ve never used their delivery.
Give them a try!

This is my go to place on Grub Hub! Free Delivery minimum $ 15 My favorite is The Boss. I always use to get the all meat pizza, and I still like it but I tried the Boss on the lunch buffet and it has been my favorite ever since that first bite hot out of the oven. The staff is always working and I’m becoming friends with the delivery driver. I would like to try more items I did try the wings and they were ok the chicken bites are better than ok. Salad is salad just a filler if you ask me. The brownnies are great also.

The manager explained they had changed owners. The new owners must suck. Free delivery… not so much (even though it’s stated on their website). Good food… not so much. 2 of the 4 items we ordered they didn’t have and called to ask if we’d sub out. Fine whatever, but the food was cold and undercooked upon delivery. We live less than a mile but it took about 1hr 15 mins to get here. They delivered an extra olive pizza instead of our dessert. When I called the manager they explained they would PICK up the olive pizza and drop off the dessert. So we explained they wouldn’t get the olive pizza since I didn’t want it sent out to the actual person who ordered it since it was now old and cold. Never again will they get our business. The pizza even looked small and from a freezer.

We’ve carried out from this location a couple times now and the pizza is ready fast and staff on the phone and running the register were pleasant. Pizza is as good as anywhere.

Hum… something has changed at this place. In the past I would have rated this place a 3 – 4 star — always good /​nothing great and a good value. HOWEVER, this is no longer true. I first noticed changes in the parking lot, it was empty! I chocked that up to just being a fluke… but when I walked in there was only one other person (there was always people in there before). OK. still no big deal. I need a quick decent lunch. So I decide to get the buffet & drink… first stop the salad bar. It was not NEARLY as good as before. much more limited selection and nothing really look fresh. The ranch dressing — weird /​bad /​odd… couldn’t eat my salad. Off to the pizza bar… only 3 sad choices… one mushroom, one pepperoni, one Italian sausage and cheese bread/​sticks. I grabbed a cheese bread hoping something else FRESH would come out… I lingered and read The Pitch. In the 20 – 30 minutes I was there NOTHING came out of the kitchen. The pizza I did eat was cold and bland — not that anything was superb before but nothing this bad. It appears this changed hands, before there was a manager/​owner that happily greeted you and always concerned about your experience. Bring back the old. this place sucks now…

Let’s be honest, we came here because it was convenient, and we had a coupon. The pies were decent. The crust was a little dense and didn’t have any profound flavor one way or the other. We got one specialty pie and one pepperoni. The specialty (Mediterranean maybe?) pie was pretty good. Lots of feta and veggies, but the olives (both green and black) were just regular canned olives… not Mediterranean olives. The pepperoni was pretty damn greasy. The pepperonis themselves were giant.
The dining area left much to be desired. It’s a pretty small place with minimal noise/​music, so conversations felt pretty public. We arrived at nearly 9 pm or so, yet there were still remnants from the lunch buffet, such as a front and center mop bucket and the old pizza slices still sitting on the lunch buffet just whetting your appetite for dried up old food items.
Overall, this place is just fine. They often have coupons which makes them very affordable, and it’s nice to choose a local place lest they start disappearing.

These guys are clueless regarding the name of their place. While there is a «mafia» connection with Italian food, I’m not sure that «Mafia Mike’s» is the smartest play in our day and age.
That being said, if you want the bottom dollar cheapest pizza in town, the kind where the grease seeps through the bottom of the box before you get back to your house, then this place is perfect. Such pizza does have a time and place. Not often, but when you do, you know who to call.

Mafia Mikes has some great pizza. My favorite is the Jesse James.

A buddy of mine and I stopped here on the fly and in a time crunch. Their buffet was great!!! My salad was delicious and the pizza was hot and tasty as well. Prices were very reasonable!

We’ve been there twice for the lunch buffet.
They usually have 3 or 4 pies out at a time on the buffet – a few standard pizzas and a few «specialty» options. They rotate quickly as people munch.
The salad bar accompanying the pizza is a little on the sad side. If you want a small, relatively generic salad, I guess it would do the job. Not a lot of options, though.
The pizza itself is (a) surprisingly good and (b) extremely filling. This isn’t junk buffet pizza – it’s good quality stuff. I like the pepperoni they use (it has a little kick) and can’t think of anything negative to say about any of the other pies I’ve sampled there.
Even with the sub-​par salad, the food probably justifies a four-​star rating in the world of pizza buffets.
Unfortunately, the shop itself drags Mafia Mike’s down a star. Peeling paint, lots of visible duct tape, cramped seating, an old CRT television that sits at a crooked angle, etc., etc.
The food is good. The prices for the lunch buffet are good. But someone needs to go in there with a tool kit, a mop, some rags and a few cans of paint. It looks a little too well-​worn at the moment.

A little pricey ($ 20 for the XL) but worth it. Four of us split a L «The Boss» and a L pepperoni and had about half a pie left over for the next day.
The pizzas were done in about 10 minutes and were delicious!
The service was good but we were there in the evening and were the only ones in the place — although several carry-​out orders came and went. Seems like maybe it’s more of a sit-​down place at lunch.

Nice lunch buffet — small but adequate and always fresh. $ 6.50 for lunch with at least 3 – 4 different pizza choices. The pizzas are a bit greasy but the thin crusts are a bit Neopolitan. The pizza here is way better then chain restaurants, but I’d suggest take-​away for anything but lunch. It’s pretty small inside and the dining room lacks a bit of ambiance — but they make up for it in tasty pizza.

Mafia Mike’s is a good little local pizza joint. We have been here a few times and like the New York style pizza. The service is good and the place is clean and I do love the newspapers on the wall with mobsters in them.
The pizzas are unique and taste great. I always make my own. Tonight I had the black olives, mushrooms and bacon (a ton of bacon) and no cheese.
Hubby had the Big Kahunna, which is Canadian Bacon, Mushrooms and Pineapple.
We had a
coupon so our meal was pretty cheap and fast. We walked in and placed our to go order and they had it done in about 10 mins.
Now back to the Bacon; there was probably ½ a pound of bacon on the pizza. Maybe they felt bad that I can’t eat cheese so they gave me extra bacon. I will upload a picture of the bacon. Yummy.
Just for comparasion. Mafia Mike’s is 1000% better than Pizza Hut, Papa John’s, Domino’s and Little Ceasars, but it is not as good as Minisky’s, Waldo or Spin.