Three Guys Pizza Pies

After reading the Unilocal reviews, I was really looking forward to trying this place and having a good experience. Sadly, that didn’t happen.
I went on a week night, and the place was about 75% full. I was seated promptly, and a young woman greeted me, brought me something to drink, and after about 5 minutes returned to take my order.
10 minutes passed, and then a young man appeared and said there had been some mix up, and said that he was my server and not the young woman who’d taken my order. He then left.
Another 10 minutes passed, and still no food. I went to the counter to be sure my order was still in place, and was assured it was. 5 minutes later (about 25 minutes after I placed my order), the food arrived. The food tasted ok, but it was nothing special.
During the time I waited for my food, and while eating, the place had gradually emptied out. I noticed that multiple tables were left uncleared and uncleaned, which surprised me because it made the place look uninviting.
Bottom line: I’ll try a different pizza place next time.

Awesome pizza tonight. Ordered a couple pies for the family — take out. Both were great and was the first quiet dinner in a while. Everyone was too busy eating to talk :)

Love their pizza, the staff is always friendly and everything on the menu is very very tasty! Our first time there the waiter even have us complimentary garlic knots so that we knew how great their appetizers are! Love supporting this local business!

I went back to give them a second try because the management was amazing! They assured me things would be right when I came back and they were! The wing sauce was different but very good and the thin pizza was pretty good too.

Yum. Unilocal says I need more words for this to be a review, but I disagree. Yum sums it up perfectly.
Actually, affordable yum works too. They should change the name to Great Food at Great Prices.
As a matter of fact, the service is also fantastic! I guess a better name would be Great Food at Great Prices in a Fun Atmosphere Where You Are Treated Well.
Hmm while descriptive, that name would take a huge marquee or a tiny font… Maybe the name is like the food, prices and service. Meaning they shouldn’t change a thing!

Great pizza. Had the cheesy guy pizza and I could not get enough of it. The amount of cheese on it just makes it so amazing!

If you’re looking for the real deal, this is it.
Whether it’s freshly made pizza by the slice, a calzone or an order of garlic knots, you won’t be disappointed. The service is great, and they have a great selection of beer.
Also, they have wifi. I’ve spent many days working from a booth with pizza and my laptop.
Bring in your church bulletin on Sunday’s for a free order of knots!

The food is great…5 stars. The Angry Hawaiian is my favorite. However, the service is horrible. I have never had an attentive server. I think if they had someone come in and actually train their servers on how to wait tables, it would do a world of good. It’s a given-​we know when we go, we will get great food but sorry service.

Very decent, edible pizza. I know this might sound like a weird way to describe a pizza, but it’s actually high praise.
This is a high quality pizza, artfully made. Lotsa cheese and high quality toppings. For the South, this pizza is really outstanding. (I’d give it three stars if it were in the Chicago area.)
BTW, it’s not «expensive», as some have claimed. An extra large pizza with two or three toppings *should* cost about $ 28 to $ 30. This ain’t McDonalds, people. That pricing is correct. This is real food, made by real people. Too many folks expect fast food prices because the market is saturated with dreck like Papa Johns. Forget that stuff. Eat real pizza.

This is my favorite new pizza stop! The pizza has an interesting crust flavoring that really makes it pop and is delicious. The large selection of toppings allows you to create your own pizza and you can even order personal pizza by the slice!
They have lunch and daily specials and you can get a great deal on a slice, salad and drink. And if you return within 7 days, you can get 10% off your next visit!
The employees are all very pleasant and helpful. Anyone will stop by to check on you even if it is not your server.
Three Guys is a great new addition to Cordova and a welcome change from all the other big chains. I hope that you will check them out soon!

Yep. Sometimes you stumble upon a place that gets everything right. I was VERY tempted to write a 5-​star review after my first visit. However, I resisted the urge to praise. I wanted to be sure that I hadn’t just caught them on a good note. But no, this place is REALLY GOOD.
Typically, when you order pizza by the slice, you get a warmed over piece of pizza that has been getting all waxy for 2 hours or better. Typically, you’re at the mercy of the prep table, so the combo may be pineapples and anchovies. Not here.
At Three Guys, you actually select your toppings for pizza by the slice. And then, they bake it fresh right away. THIS is the way Pizza by the slice should be.
The toppings are varied and amazing. From artichoke to andouille… they have some of EVERYTHING. What’s more, the preparation of the toppings is fantastic. I had a slice with bacon, bell pepper, and Italian sausage. The bell pepper was sliced into thin rings that crunched perfectly with each bite. The bacon was coarse cut so that they didn’t turn into burnt bacon bits on your pie. Nice job on this guys (REALLY nice).
To boot, they staff members are POLITE. They’ve got a lot of specials, so check them out.

Excellent pizza. Real ingredients. Never opt for a cardboard crust from the chains when you have pizza this good as an alternative. Ordered with their super-​simple online tool, picked up at store, which looks like a fun place to hang with friends and family if you are lucky enough to have them.

I’m usually super frugal about rating a business in general, but in regards to pizza served south of the Mason Dixon, it was purty fantastic.
Being that it’s freshly prepared (i.e their dough which is made daily); with (real vegetables) ingredients sourced locally, meats sourced from suppliers they know and have chosen personally, these are all great reasons to check out this pizza purveyor. In my experience with Tennessee folk, if it’s cheap and in large quantity it’s the best deal. The quantity is huge but in comparison to grossly cheap-​ass fast food pizza like Papa John’s, it’s not the same cost, but it’s value is BETTER!
First, lets assume you haven’t a clue who the «foodbabe» is, it’s a
so you can check out her articles if you like. She has one on pizza, so search for it. She talks about their ingredients lists. Many of these companies like to be super hush about what goes into it. That should be a sign to you. I mean, what the heck else is going into a pizza other than sauce, cheese and the desired toppings right? So, many of the pizza chains y’all might be familiar with use MSG and fake toppings on their pies. Read the article; in some cases the meat toppings are half meat and half dehydrated vegetables. Not a 100% meat. Strange right? Cheap asses.
Now, look at Three Guys pizza pies. They’re willing to share their ingredient list with you and information about its whereabouts. Crazy right?
What’s great is they offer a bunch of different ingredients for their pies as well as a few specialty types. Now everything can’t be that great right? In my experience, I found it funny that the meat was plentiful and the veggies miniscule. Also, (not sure if they deliver) make sure to place pizza orders on the way to their location. Their pizza and appetizers are best when HOT.
They also offer specials, like BoGo on certain days, so you’ll like to check out their website.

Love it! The Carnivore is amazing. We stop here every 6 weeks or so. This is our treat for driving thru West Memphis, AR and Memphis TN.

My favorite pizza, another local owned place. Great Italian food and pizza, Lots of toppings and sizes run large. Bring your own wine, Beer sold here.

Just moved here from Chicago and it took us a while but finally found a great pizza place. Love the specialty pizzas the muffalata is our favorite choice. And it always smells delicious when you walk in the doors

I have been here a few times and the pizza is really good. I have gotten their version of the meat lovers pizza.
Looked as if they had great beer specials as well.

Great pizza, yummy salad, attentive service, free video games for the munchkins, yea for three guys pizza pies!!!

Three Guys Pizza is FANTASTIC! I loved this place, deep admiration for their pizza ethic.
Great service at the start. The garlic knots were truly legendary — light, fluffy, delicious. And the pizza — oh, my, this is my favorite kind. Not thick or thin, somewhere in middle. They layer meats in middle, cheese on top — haven’t seen this style outside of Boston. They also char the crust so its crispy — delicious.
My only complaint was baked spaghetti, which tasted great, but portion size was pretty small for $$ price. The pizzas are somewhat $$ pricey but they seem to have enough specials to offset.
This is my kind of pizza joint. Big thumbs up!

Was my ultimate favorite independent pizza shop in Memphis. The first two years I would have given it 5 stars but the quality has gone down since the management has changed some. Now I’d only give it 3.5 stars.
Still a nice place to eat with a great family environment. Service is more slow now, but if you have a good hour an a half to eat, I’d still stop by…
Things to eat: 1) garlic knots, 2) meatball sub 3) pizza with pepperoni, mushroom, meatballs.
My mouth is watering just thinking about it