Tomasino’s Pizza

My favorite pizza at this time! We went to the new Lake Mary/​Heathrow location a week ago and it was amazing pizza and great service. The ingredients were fresh, right amount of sauce, & dough was was perfectly cooked with crispy crust. We ordered The Mechanic 14″ and asked them to put all the meat on one side for my husband, and the veggies on the other for me. It was just the two of us and we took half of it home. Really wished they offered a smaller size, but you can get pizza by the slice. They have outdoor seating, too. Right next door to the new «Another Broken Egg» restaurant which is amazing too!

Once again, Lake Mary has scored a big addition in their selections of restaurants. We ordered their mozzarella cheese sticks which were a huge hit. You can tell that they’re made from scratch and not the usual frozen variety. We also got the Margarita pizza which was amazing. It was the right amount of toppings and the dough was perfect NY Style pizza. There are several styles of NY Style pizza, Tomasino’s offers what I refer to is original as many locations in NY use a Brick-​Oven, others are considered NY Style street pizza which is the notable thin crust and lots of sauce. Both are great because, well they’re from New York.
The consistency of the color of the pizza lends me to believe they’re using a standard pizza oven and not brick oven, but overall it was pretty good. We also took a slice of their Cheese Cake which comes directly from Juniors in New York, for those true Cheese Cake lovers its worth the trip there just for that alone, we also took their Chocolate Mousse, it was pretty decadent of a desert even for someone who’s not a big chocolate lover. They’ve got a nice variety of pizzas and dinner items, but remember this is NY Style pizza. They’ve got a daily special of 2 slices and a salad for $ 7.99 which sounds great and I’m looking forward to trying it.

I work across the street so on days I don’t pack my lunch or want to mix it up from my regular salad I come here. It’s cheap, you can order ahead and pick up, typically fast, & the pizzas good!

I ordered a slice of bianca pizza and pesto fries and waited 25 minutes for them to tell me they were out of bianca. They then brought me a stale piece of cheese pizza that had no flavor. And they forgot my fries. Probably would have helped if the waiter paid any attention to me.

Ok so this was our first time here; I have to say I’m not sure we will be back, sorry. Pizza — unremarkable — I was looking forward to NY pizza — um, noooo — not even a facsimile — just nothing about it was NY from the crust on thicker side (which is fine but not NY) to absolutely no sauce anywhere (oh we are training a new cook). I asked for some sauce so I could try it — tastes like your average jar pasta sauce. I also had to keep whirling around in my seat to try to get the waitresses attention, that just drives me crazy. We each ate one piece of dry-​no sauce pizza and asked to swap out for wings. The waitress was gracious and promptly did so. The wings were good. Won’t be back, but maybe it was an off night.

First time going here. Right away, the wait staff impressed me with how nice and friendly they were. It’s always nice to see the employee’s with a smile on their face and it left a very good first impression on this diner here. (PS, I’m talking about yours truly!)
I’m a basic kinda guy, so I went with the lunch special with the two slices (Pepperoni only for me) and either a side salad or drink. I chose the side salad and had it to go. The wait wasn’t very long, maybe 7 to 8 minutes to get my order out. It came out hot, fresh, and boy oh boy was it delicious. I’m eating the Caesar Salad right now and I think that’s honest to god real Caesar dressing there.
The Pizza Slices were huge! I mean, these were BIG slices. And the Salad was a good size too, so I felt like I got my money’s worth ($ 7.49 for the lunch special.) The Lunch special by the way, is served until 4:00 PM.
I left with a smile and a feeling like I had just discovered my new favorite lunch spot. Keep up the good work Tomasino’s and I’ll be visiting much more often.

Awesome pizza. Definitely NY style. We been here a few times now and 5 star all the way. Try them out you won’t be disappointed. Try the philly cheese steak too:)

Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. They have great lunch specials for $ 7.99. You may find a bit of a wait at lunchtime. I’m waiting for them to enable online ordering like the other two locations have. I had two of my friends from New York try the pizza and they said it’s good!

Good home made pizza. I’ve had as good in lake Mary but this place is right on my door step.

Good pizza, prices a little high even the specials. Quick enough take out service.

The best pizza in the Heathrow area. Everything is fresh and made from scratch. You can taste the sauce is homemade. The cheese and garlic knots are great.