Mikey’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant

I love the staff! I ordered delivery while at work and boy do they have awesome bold personalities! I got a pepperoni and cheese pizza and a side salad. This pizza is the real deal. The sauce is amazing! The pizza came HOT and fresh everything was perfect! I will be driving across town to eat here with my family. They missed out since I ordered at work. My co worker had a slice of pizza she was very impressed also! Keep up the good work!

The calzone tasted great and was huge. Had to take some home for later. The service was fast and everyone was friendly.

Delicious food and friendly people. Definitely recommend this place to everyone in Jacksonville Florida.

I honestly don’t know what it is about Mikey’s pizza that makes it so good. They’re not even Italian! Who cares what ethnicity they are when the pizza is this good. I don’t even really like pizza but this, I like.
My family is a bunch of carnivores (oh the irony for a former vegetarian), of course they order the Meat Lovers aka the-​heart-​attack-​waiting-​to-​happen. It must be the crust (not too thick, not too thin) or the quality meat toppings that make it yummy. Maybe it’s the amount of cheese they put on it or the temperature at which they bake their pizza. I don’t know the magical recipe or process Mikey uses to make their food delicious, I only know that I’ll be back for more of it.
It helps that the people there are nice. Good service always makes the food taste better. Happiness is contagious that’s why. We plan on being regulars even if the location is not the most convenient for us. Some things are worth a little inconvenience.

I have eaten here several times in the 18 months I’ve been in Jacksonville and have never had a bad experience from their pizza, pasta, veal, it’s all delicious! Always a good family experience and the staff if personable and friendly!

I was a huge fan on Micky’s and loved it. However they went on vacation for a month and ever since its been different. I think maybe they are using cheaper cheese as its like rubber. Loved this place and the owners so sad…

Best pizza in jax. Picked up 2 large meat lovers and a supreme. Can’t forget my cannoli. Great neighborhood Italian Restaurant.

Really good meatball sub. bread was soft and warm, and the meatballs were excellent. Service was outstanding.

Fast delivery and omg amazing pizza and sandwiches. The bread has this light crisp crust and chewy inside, perfectly toasted… you can tell they have made the way these classic foods personal and touching.

Great Food!!! Pizza was delicious!!! Very Family friendly!!! Mikey actually sat down and had a conversation with me and my wife. It was like we were old friends and was catching up on old times. We will definitely be back…

Very friendly service, delicious food at an affordable price. I’ll be back next time I’m in the neighborhood.

I have been wanting to try the buffet at this place for a long time so I figured why not today when I went there was greeted by the owner and his wife explain to them that I was going to get the buffet but I really just wanted a pizza. I was anxious to try the different types of pasto so that I could recommend to others. The owners /​club they came by explain the quality of how they make their food it was fast and it was quick and it had that smell that reminds you of Italy not just a generic pizza smell everything was prepared very light and texture the alfredo was buttery and flavorful but not heavy and thick and the tortellini was off the chain good. I love the little local spot and this it. They use fresh ingredients and treat u like family. Definitely an a+ from this Unilocaler.

Really really great food. I had the Chicken Picatta. Wife had the Lasagna. Both of us enjoyed it very much. The service was fantastic. Just great food for that side of the River. Can’t wait to try the Pizza!

Terrible service here. The waitress (owner) was too busy talking to her family in the restaurant to bring us our drinks. She forgot our appetizer as well. I came here before and the pizza was great, but the service was not. After my last experience, I won’t be back.

My family and I went here for the first time (not sure how this was my first visit since it has been around forever) and I have to say the pizza was the bomb! The crust is really what made the pizza… Crunchy, fresh, light, and delicious! Hands down better than Pizza Palace or Als. Definitely will be our new pizza go to. I already am craving it!

If you place a delivery order, be sure to have your own utensils on hand because it won’t be included with your order. Before delivery guy left, I asked if utensils were in the bag because I didn’t see any when I peaked in & he made it seem as though it was a dumb question. When I called to bring it to their attention, they denied they made the delivery to my hotel 5 minutes prior even though I have the receipt As far as the food goes, ordered lobster ravioli and it was not good at all! Tough & under cooked, loaded with salt. Unenjoyable meal, poor service.

To be fair, the food was great. But the fact they charge 3 dollars for a drink makes me unlikely to go back here.

Our party of four went to dinner tonight at Mikey’s Pizza per my brother-in-law’s recommendation. I am so glad he did because we all loved it. Between the four of us, we shared a fried mozzarella appey, a 12 by 12 thick crust meat lover pizza, a small NY style combo pizza, and spaghetti with sausage. We had to take half a pizza home because it was so much food.
I LOVED their pizza. My husband is a thick crust fan, and he really enjoyed the meat lover pizza. I was only able to eat one slice of it and was pleasantly surprised that it was not as greasy as other thick crust pizza I tried at other places. The NY style pizza was just so delicious. Part of it is personal preference. I’ve always preferred the thinner crust than thick. But the pizza is so flavorful with fresh ingredients and delicious crust.
Besides delicious pizza, the service was impeccable. It was actually funny because my brother-​in-​law walked in like he knew the owner or something. They were all smiles and chit chatting with us, super friendly. Then after dinner, I asked him how long and how often he’s been to Mikey’s that they were that friendly to us… He told us, once. ONCE?! That’s how friendly they were.
I am sure we’ll be going back to Mikey’s again soon.

I have to say, I’m shocked with myself that we haven’t tried this place before! Ordered baked ziti, cheese pizza & a calzone! Kids said that the flavor is excellent on pizza & it’s not greasy like some other companies, my daughter loves the ziti & sauce is very flavorful! I’m always weary about new places! I have to say y’all out did Pizza Palace. Thanks for good food!

The coolest thing about this place is that they try their best to please their customers. We had ordered something called Lasagna Pizza while in Manhattan. My brother wouldn’t stop talking about it for months. I mean it’s been 8 months and it’s still on his mind.
And since this wasn’t Manhattan, I took necessary precautions. Before I left the City, I took those slices of pizza, sealed them carefully in my luggage and ran to put them in the fridge as soon as I got home. I savored that thing piece by piece until I had indulged in it for a week after I we arrived from our trip.
I expected to bid farewell to that mix of italian beef, ricotta cheese, and perfect crust, but I was pleasantly surprised when I went to Mikey’s and they said they could custom make one for me. Now that, is customer service! The best part is that I think the cooks at Mikey’s used better herbs and cheese, because it seemed to burst with even more flavor than its Big Apple predecessor and the cheese wasn’t as greasy.
Great job, Mikey’s!