The Toggery

I can’t recall the last time I went to a store and bought brand spankin’ new clothes. I have been a consignment shopper now for years. I’m pretty happy with The Toggery. They get some very quality pieces in. It’s hit or miss each time I go but really that’s been true of any consignment shop I have been a regular at. When I do find something, it has been perfect! All of their items are in very good shape, too. I have never pulled a piece with holes, tears or stains. The service is friendly. Two downfalls, I feel like they have a weird mix of pieces that are way out of fashion and quite stylish items. I also think some of their prices are inconsistent and sometimes inappropriate. I have shopped here several times and will certainly continue to do so.

For years I have been bringing my clothes that no longer fit, are no longer my style, or in general are just taking up space in my closet to the Toggery. They go through my pile of misfit outfits and sell some of them. Once a month they give me a check. I spend check on more outfits from my favorite shopping grounds… that will likely end up at the Toggery after a while. It’s a vicious cycle.
Every now and again I buy something at the Toggery with a debit card or with a credit from selling my misfits. A few purchases have become wardrobe staples. Tweed Elie Tahari sheath dress for work? Tags still on it and only cost me $ 14? STAPLE. JCrew A-​line long sleeve wool dress with front pockets? Oh, so 1960’s chic for about $ 26? STAPLE.
This place is really top notch. Great staff too.
TIP: Try it also for Halloween costumes!
TIP: Shop or drop off items on Friday’s for free snacks and wine.

I took some sandals to the Toggery about a month ago. Now keep in mind these are Bandolino, Guess, and some other name brand sandals. I guess they weren’t good enough for their store. So I looked at what was already there regarding the shoes and I was dumbfounded. Those shoes were not in good condition but they wouldn’t accept mine which were in almost brand new condition. Will never go back there to purchase or to sale. I was able to sell them at another consignment store,

A broad ripple staple that always delivers great fashion and designer styles for a great price. They give you a fair percentage for consignment plus the store credit is an even better deal. The constantly updated collection is hard to top in this city.

This place has gone down in quality big time. Used to be my go-​to for quality consignment, but as they’ve gained popularity they have become more concerned with quantity rather than quality. Not sure how someone can think $ 32 for a dress with a rip like this. and let’s not forget it’s consigned so it’s used… is appropriate. Not much to find in there anymore.

Love love love. They have great items and good prices on their resale! You just never know what you are going to find.

I love this store! I moved to Indy a month ago and enjoy exploring unique places that tend to be on the down-​low, which is how I came to find this place. If you are looking for a women’s high fashion consignment store, you’ve hit the jack pot! The majority of their clothes look unworn and are in great shape. The prices are not as cheap as Goodwill of course, but I thought it was worth it for what I went home with. I purchased a black genuine leather Guess jacket that cost $ 32, a White House Black Market jacket/​light coat (resembles a Chanel pattern) for about $ 35, a J Crew cardigan for $ 16, and a silky white tank for $ 8.
The reason I gave this business ⁴⁄₅ stars was for their customer service. There were quite a few people working when I came in and shopped for 2 hours, yet not one person approached me. It would have been great to know more about their business and for them to let me know where to find specific items, clearance, and any other helpful information. Also, there are not any baskets or shopping carts and so in my opinion (coming from a fellow retail employee), they should have asked to free my arms when they saw me struggling with about 30 items. It does take quite a while to search through all of their items and so a bit of assistance goes a very long way.

Let me admit — I remember hearing about The Toggery waaaaaaaay back when and I had always thought it was a place for little old ladies to shop. Man, was I wrong.
Recently I had a friend text me while shopping there to let me know that she had hit the jackpot on one of my favorite brands of exercise clothing. Mental note — go check this place out.
While passing The Toggery this weekend, we stopped in. Unbeknownst to me, the hubs asked the lovely little lady working if they had any of my fav brand in stock. As I caught up to him, Tiffany was arriving with an arm full of workout clothing goodness! Talk about the amazingness of having a personal shopper! WOOT! I was able to find some good stuff in good shape for about ¹⁄₃ of the retail price. Score. An added bonus is that the store is well organized — by item and size. You still get the thrill of the hunt without having to dig as much.
I would be remiss if I did not encourage you to check out the 75% and 50% off racks immediately inside the door. Scored some cute designer jackets and sweaters for like 7 bucks.
Later we learned that Tiffany is the manager there and she absolutely went above and beyond for us – despite the store being busy on a Saturday afternoon. I just wish she would have let me buy the cute hat right off her head. We will be back. Well, maybe I will leave the hubs at home next time.

I just love this place.

It’s a great consignment store that has a ton of brands, designer and non but yet popular such as Ann Taylor, J Crew, BCBG, etc. etc. There is a ton of variety here, but I have two issues. One, I feel like there is tooooo much to look at and that it’s like a small overpriced Goodwill for Broad Ripple people-​not hatin’. Two, I think that for the prices of items that are on the cusp of becoming out of style, it’s not always worth it.
That being said though, you can sift through if you have the time to find good items. However, you could probably find something similar or better at your local Goodwill or Value World. And of course at a better price.
I think there are some fun pieces that you wouldn’t find at a Goodwill, especially the hats and gloves and some of those gorgeous coats they carry. The rest is just meh.

Great Staff. The merchandise is well priced. I find the best deals there and I know I have a one of the kind. Quality designer brands too. I always check the Toggery when looking for designer jeans and cashmere. I’ve bought many items with the tags still on them for a fraction of department store prices.

I was in desperate need of new jeans. I didn’t want another cheap pair from Target, but I just can’t spend the money on the nice, expensive jeans. A coworker suggested I give The Toggery a shot, and I had success on my first trip! Two pairs a great, designer jeans for a total of $ 41 (you get a discount by checking in on Unilocal,too!). The store is well organized (as many second-​hand stores can be cluttered), and sections are clearly labeled. I’ll be going back!

I find awesome deals on designer and mall brand clothing, accessories, and shoes every time I shop here! They always have several clearance items. I usually only shop clearance and always find lots of items. On my last trip I came home with 1 sweater, 3 shirts, 1 dress, 1 bra, and 1 make up bag all for $ 20.33 with tax! I love The Toggery!

Be prepared to be there awhile. Such a large inventory of nice items!

The greatest place to shop for women’s clothes on a discount!!! I love this place! I have been coming for a few years now!

I recently moved from dallas, TX. I was sad to leave one of the largest shopping networks in the country; however, I was overjoyed when I found this place. The staff is great, and I visit there so often they now know me. I had a recent clothing emergency and the mgr went out of her way to help me in a pinch. This is my favorite shopping spot in Indy! I can’t wait to share with my visiting friends and family!

This place is great. That is about all there is to say about it except for the stuff I have already said, which I continue to stand by. However I said I would recap about my experience selling things on consignment which I have done now twice with pretty great success. I am a fan and will continue to be a loyal customer.

I need to lead in by saying, I think I got my expectations up too high before going here. I knew I wanted to visit after seeing the Unilocal reviews and then I liked them on Facebook. Their Facebook site makes it seem like they only carry high end items but that is not the case. Don’t get me wrong, they have a great selection and everything is in good condition, but for the most part it is your run of the mill consignment brands, J. Crew, Gap etc. There were a few pairs of high end jeans, a small rack with the really high end designer items (10 or so items), and the items behind the glass case but that was about it.
Prices are right and there is a pretty good selection, especially the dresses– I really found a lot of cute dresses that I liked. I was just expecting a lot more high end stuff based on what they post on their FB page. It’s certainly a notch above Plato’s Closet though so I would recommend if you are in the area!

I am quite thrifty. I brought clothes in to sell. I felt weird for being there because I guess I had to have an appointment. They only took two items, which was kind of disappointing.
I looked around at items in the store and found that it was pretty pricey for used clothing.
I think I could find the same quality for cheaper at Goodwill.

Out of all the consignment stores I’ve been to, the Toggery is my favorite. I brought an armful of practially unused clothes, few purses, wallets, and they were sold in less than a month. More money in my pocket to buy things I won’t wear… doh.
And of course, I never leave without buying something, like the Burberry cardigan I purchased for under $ 20. If I didn’t have Dillon trying to herd me out the door, I could probably spend a few hours looking through all the clothes and shoes. Oh, that brings up another thing that’s so great about this place; the smell. Is it me, or does this place NOT smell like a consignment store? With all the hundreds of clothes and shoes from multiple people you’d think it would have that Goodwill-​ish, musty smell. Or maybe my eyes are overloading all of my other senses that I don’t smell anything.
I will definitely be making another trip; I found 3 space saver bags of clothes I brought from California. You’d think I would be all unpacked by now.