Greek’s Pizzeria

Oh Greek’s, I wish we hadn’t been introduced this way…
I ordered delivery online on a weeknight, which is how people do things these days, right? I followed all of the steps correctly, and upon receiving my order confirmation, my computer screen told me to expect my pizza in 45 – 60 minutes, which is pretty typical for delivery in Broad Ripple. So I waited 45 minutes… then 60 minutes… then 75 minutes…
Something wasn’t right here.
I picked up the phone, thinking that the voice on the other line would tell me my pizza was on its way, things were backed up, etc. Sadly, it turned out that my pizza didn’t exist, and they were going to have to call me back. I was left confused and also feeling guilty, because these kinds of things don’t happen when you prepare yourself a rabbit-​approved salad.
Just as I grabbed for a carrot, Greek’s called me back. SURPRISE! My pizza order existed, but it hadn’t been prepared. The voice on the other line told me to just give them another hour and quickly hung up. I know I should have called them back and cancelled my order so I wasn’t chowing down on carbs at 9 PM, but at the same time, it’s pizza. Never in my life have I turned down a pie, and I wasn’t planning to do so just yet.
When my pizza did arrive, it was actually quite good. Sauce was just sweet enough for my liking, crust was soft and chewy, cheese was gooey, and the sausage was seasoned and plentiful. Had I not waited longer than two hours, I would have nicer things to say about Greek’s. This review was saved by the most important part: my food.
What we can learn from this: Greek’s needs to work out the kinks in their online ordering, and Allison needs to get off her ass and order carry out.

Pizzzzzzza!!! Who doesn’t love pizza?! Not I! This place has one of the best pizzas in broad ripple. Come for a slice or come for a whole pie! Nice place to stop in for a slice after you’ve had a few drinks from around the corner. Pizza is delicious!

I was in the mood for a little bit of a splurge on this Memorial Day weekend and decided to break the diet and have some pizza. I was already in Broad Ripple and had never tried Greek’s Pizzeria, an Indiana franchise with 16 locations, so decided to give them a try.
The Broad Ripple Greek’s Pizzeria is located in what used to be Ben & Jerry’s right on the corner of 64^th & Guilford Ave. There’s a curb cut right in front of the building. The door is an older wooden door, though it’s on a slight incline and is a bit of a pain in a wheelchair.
As you enter, you arrive directly in the dining area with an ordering counter straight ahead for take-​out. I arrived at a time when no one else was dining in and took a place at a four-​top table. Greek’s decorated like a pizzeria with a colorful red/​white theme throughout the restaurant. They offer pizzas, of course, along with your standard sandwiches and calzones along with standard appetizer options found in most pizza shops. They have daily specials and lunch specials (M-​F only). They serve alcohol and do have a Kid’s Menu.
As I was already splurging, I kept it fairly simple with a small pizza with one topping (Italian Sausage). It was just shy of $ 7.00. The drink adds another couple bucks and the entire bill came in at $ 9.70 — while that’s certainly higher than you’ll pay for a standard issue Pizza Hut value meal, this pizza is fresher and their specials during the week will also knock a bit off that.
Now then, if this review sounds a little bit more bland than you’re used to from me there’s a pretty good reason fir it.
Greek’s Pizzeria really never got much of a reaction from me. The food? Slightly above average. The service? Slightly above average. The atmosphere? Slightly above average. There was nothing about Greek’s Pizzeria that I loved, but there was also nothing that I absolutely hated. I left sort of saying to myself «Okay, now I’ve been to Greek’s Pizzeria.»
The sausage was appropriately fresh and nicely spread throughout the six slice pie. The crust was light and tasty. I had no problem finishing off the small pie myself. I also ordered my usual unsweetened tea, though I was a tad disappointed to have the rather light amount of ice melt away before I’d even taken a drink. I did, however, get my always desired refill and got it in a «to go» cup. So, that was nice.
My server seemed to be largely working the front herself, though a delivery person did pop in a couple times and there was obviously someone working the kitchen. She was friendly, but not particularly outgoing. She did check in, but it just felt very methodical rather than an actual desire to serve. She stayed behind the counter a lot, which I found to be a bit of a surprise given that the floor was obviously dirty and it just seemed like there’d be some things to do.
Overall, in a market where gourmet pizza has become a fairly common thing this is a decidedly average option mostly limited to those already in the neighborhood. They deliver within the Broad Ripple area, but I can’t imagine anyone making Greek’s a destination spot. But hey, at least now when someone asks me if I’ve been to Greek’s Pizzeria I can respond «Yeah, I’ve been to Greek’s Pizzeria.»

Had a coupon for a $ 10 medium pizza, how did my bill come out to be almost $ 14? Oh well anyway the pizza was a little bit better than average, the toppings tasted pretty commercial. The crust tasted good and the sauce tasted pretty good as well. But the Greeks I remember which I have had a put their fishers location was 10 times better than this one. So they must not be doing something correct here because it’s the same place, it shouldn’t taste this much different. So in closing if I go back here again it will be to the one up in fishers. 2.5 stars. I wish Unilocal let you half stars too, my experience was in between two and three stars.

We had not been to Greeks in a long time. If I cant find a parking place close by I give up and go further south on College. Still great pizza and bread sticks. Service tonight was just ok. Great windows for people watching while eating. On a warmer day eating outside would be nice.

Great pizza shop. Best in Rip!

I love their spinach deluxe pizza but can’t seem to get one. We called for delivery last night and waited for an hour. Called in to learn the driver had a flat. Totally understandable and ok. We were then told that another driver would be picking up the pizza and getting it to us. Nope. Finally at 930 (2 hours later) they called and said the pizza had made it back to the restaurant and would we we still want it. For us, the moment had passed and we didn’t want to terrorize any other driver with our undeliverable pizza and told them not to bother. They mentioned they had a gift card in the mail for our trouble. Jury is still out on if that comes through.
Tonight, we attempted to give them another go. 1 hour 15 mins and 2 follow up calls later, spinach deluxe arrived — cold. Greeks, if you do get our business again, it’s dine-​in only.

I love Greeks, their pizza and appetizers are always amazingly good!
Tip: try the feta bread!

Crispy crust and sweet sauce. Good price for good pizza. Would definitely eat here again.

Excellent cheese and crust. Breadsticks are deliciously bad for you. A go-​to pizza spot for us.

I have ordered delivery from this establishment about once a week for around a year. Tonight I called and was told by the delivery girl that I was outside of their delivery zone. I politely told her they deliver here all the time. She then said they are getting too busy and will not deliver that far when they are busy. I live 3.5 miles from the store. No problem. I will save my usual $ 30 a week and spend it somewhere else that wants my business.

I’ve been a big fan of Greek’s pizza ever since my youth, eating at the Greek’s in Muncie whenever I had a piano or choir competition at Ball State. Was always a treat, and it still is now!
It pains me to not give five stars, and I’d love to change my review if next time I go, I don’t have to walk into the kitchen to find someone to take my credit card so I could pay and leave.
Besides that though, everything was so good. I don’t understand why there are never any people in the restaurant! Maybe they do a better carry-​out/​delivery business than in-​house? Who knows.
We ordered the breadsticks and a Roma pizza. If you get the breadsticks, be ready to die and go to a butter soaked heaven. These babies are so decadent… and so bad for me… but oh well! The crust on the pizza was also perfect, and the toppings were delish as well.
While there are other good ‘za places in the Brip, I really think Greek’s is the best. I know. a bold claim. but I’ll stand my ground.

I thought that I would give these guys a shot so I ordered some delivery: a pizza a bottle of soda and a calzone with tomato and cheese sauce… about an hour later everything arrived except for the drink and cheese dip. now I live maybe two blocks from this restaurant sure I could have walked there but I got delivery because I wanted to eat at home and stay in well they had forgotten a few items i had paid for but really i just wanted my drink so I called and they said that it was in the drivers car and he would bring it by after his deliveries… so I waited and I waited and then I called and I was told that it was on its way and I waited and I waited and about 45 minutes to an hour after they said they would send me the product i had been charged for I called them and for the first time I asked to speak with a manager the manager told me that he would send it right out with the next delivery now this was let’s say 2 hours after I placed my original order at this point all I really wanted was the manager to admit that either someone had lied to me or they had made a mistake he did not do that.
As for the quality and taste of the pizza it was not bad. Typical local pizza delivery. maybe the best thing was that among the many nationally distributed ingredients that they use they chose to use a product called al dente as a marinara sauce that was very good and is one of my favorite nationally distributed tomato sauces other than that it was very typical Pizza and i suggest you save your money and buy digornios frozen pizza and dont support this location.

First time hitting Greeks in Broad Ripple… have been to the one in Fishers many times and the quality here didn’t disappoint. The place was pretty quiet for 630pm on a Friday so my girls and I enjoyed pizza in relative solitude.
Will likely be at the one in Fishers more often but this is a good spot for pizza.

Amazing pizza with great toppings. They have some of the best garlic bread sticks in Indianapolis. They coat their bread sticks in a flavorful garlic butter sauce. I recommend the white pizza which is their standard pizza with the garlic butter sauce instead of the red sauce. Toss in the grilled chicken on the white pizza and you have one amazing meal. I have been happy with the service both dine-​in and carry-​out. Do not go to Greeks in a rush, take your time and enjoy the atmosphere.

I was bar hopping in broad ripple last summer when I saw a lady outside selling pizza. It’s my fave so I stopped for a slice of pepperoni. When I say it was the best slice I’ve had in years! Omg! That is not an understatement! Every time I go to BroadRipple I can’t leave without a slice! YOU MUST TRY THIS!!!

I was driving back to my hotel last night and getting pretty hungry. I can always go for pizza so saw this place on Unilocal and thought I’d give it a try. I had their tossed salad with their «sweet Italian» dressing and a small white pizza. Their dressing was actually quite good, salad and pizza were just so so. My waitress was very pleasant and attentive. I’d eat here again but only if there were no other options.

We only order for take-​away and pick up ourselves so I can’t speak to sit-​down service but…
I love Greeks! They are great on the phone, make ordering easy, and have the pizza ready on time, every time! If I order some strange mash-​up of ingredients, the person on the phone often matches it up with a preexisting special and finds a way to give me the best price by charging me for the special plus/​minus a couple of ingredients. I really appreciate the savings and they do it without screwing up the order. Awesome!
The pizza is great. Good sauce, good crust, and decent depth. I have no complaints! I have enjoyed many a night watching The Walking Dead and pigging out on pizza in my living room with some yummy Greeks take-​away.

WOW! One of the best orders of breadsticks I’ve ever had!!! Pizza was awesome too, but the breadsticks were by far, my favorite part of this dining extravaganza. They come with garlic buttery heaven drizzled on the outside of them. They were cooked perfectly… had a little crispiness on the outside, but the center was soft, warm bread. They’re served with cheese dipping sauce and come in an order of 6 I believe. I will DEFINITELY be going back for some more stix! You should too.

Solid place for dinner. I’ve been to the original in Muncie and this had the same small town, homegrown feel. I went with a large group, always a test for a restaurant. They actually did really well. So kudos to them.
In terms of food, I split an order of feta bread and a spinach pie with chicken added to it. It all came out in decent time and the feta bread was perfectly salty from the cheese. Their marinara is nice and chunky too, which is a total plus. The pizza was fantastic. Loved the perfectly cooked crust, the ooey cheese, and abundant spinach. Really well done.