Brooklyn Pizza Restaurant

Great service, excellent food! Everyone was so friendly. They just made a long term customer!

I suggest staying rather than doing take out. Really nice set up, great food & good prices. Very nice owners and employees. The décor is really done well. If you’ve ever been, you should have a seat and enjoy. I like this place a lot.

I am very disappointed! Ordered a pasta fagioli soup and it was so awful I had to throw it out! It was chunky sauce with a few pieces of cut up ziti and 10 white beans! The buffalo slice was stale and hard as a rock! I will NOT return there! Manager is rude too…

Walked into this place randomly while waiting for my girl at her holiday party. I know, I’m a loser. The people in there were the nicest people I have ever had the honor of dealing with. Food was amazing too. Had a chicken bacon ranch Sicilian slice and a pepperoni pinwheel with gooey cheese. Good choice all around. I fucks with this place

Needed to order 2 pies. Called and they said 20 min. I asked if they could make it fast because I needed it quick so they told me they could do it quicker for me in 15 min. Only took them 13 min to make me. Good service and good pizza if made fresh.

Good stuff! This rule applies anywhere: Don’t get a slice (a TRIANGLE piece of pizza, Ohio people!!) during off hours, as it’ll be a reheated leftover from lunch, but other than that faux pas, this place is top notch! Get it freshly made, or don’t get it at all!!!
We used to come here a MILLION years ago as kids (back when it was Vinny’s Pizzeria) and now that I’m in the vast «wastelands» (jusssssst kidding!!) of middle-​America, my return visits home to NY serve as my «quick fix» for all that’s right in good, old, «down home» eating! You can order anything off the menu in this, along with thousands of other «mom-​pop» pizza joints all over the NY metro area, and unless there’s some sort of serious aberration, you just KNOW you’re getting the best of the best. We goofed and ordered a couple of slices of pizza for a late lunch/​early dinner, so the pizza wasn’t that thin, perfectly cooked, melty mix of cheesy heaven, but our arugula salad (small, plenty to share) and pasta e fagioli soup more than made up for the technical foul! Grab a menu, or better yet, just walk in, inhale the mingling smells of heaven on a plate, and order one of everything! Buon appetito!

My go to pizza and pasta place! Service is fast, friendly and the food is amazing. I’ve tried the lasagna and pizza, both were great.

They were courteous, the food was very good and the prices fair. I’d go again and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend you try them out too.

Service is fantastic. Nicole is friendly and knows her customers. Calzones, pizza, and lunch buffet are great. Also had their pasta from the menu a couple of times and it was great too. Best in the area.

This review is based on one visit, so judge accordingly.
Last Saturday I dropped my car off for service at Huntington Honda and was told it would take at least one hour to diagnose the problem. Now, if your ever stuck on route 25 in Huntington Station, sans vehicle and with no comrades, the only thing you can do to entertain yourself (without breaking any laws) is eat.
The dining area is small and adorned with old photos of Brooklyn’s glory days and various subway station signs. As a native Brooklynite, I felt very at home. The waitress took my order of Chicken Parm w/​Penne and a diet coke and seemed to return with my meal as quickly as she’s left to put it in.
The entrée was a huge 3 piece portion with a bowl of slightly overcooked Penne on the side. The cheese was a bit thick and hadn’t had the opportunity to develop a brown, but was tasty all the same. The grease from the chicken mixed with the sauce to flesh out the flavor. The same sauce served on the pasta was somewhat flavorless. Once the pasta was moved to the entrée plate and allowed to mingle with the sauce it was quite good.
The service here was wonderful and attentive and as stated the portion was enormous. I was disappointed in the pasta/​sauce and the cheese on the chicken overwhelmed the dish a bit, but the chicken had great flavor.
I’d like to give this a 3.5, but cannot up the review to 4 stars.

After passing by this place all the time, I decided to stop in. Unfortunately, they were out of a lot of the options I was looking for… went for a regular pie to go bc of the lack of choices
I will warn that customer service here is very inconsistent. There is one girl behind the counter who is VERY professional, attentive, upbeat, etc. Then there are others who are just plain rude and unfriendly. Not very accommodating for special requests. Instead, the staff was a bit dismissive. All with the owner observing them in action.
I don’t think I need to spend a penny at a business where the owner allows their staff to be disrespectful to customers right before the owner’s eyes! I’ll take my business elsewhere! Pizza is not that hard to find!

Have to say for a place that has the name the food just wasn’t there. My wife and I ordered take out dinners. I had the chicken Marsala and the chicken parm hero. To start. When I opened the tin I was very disappointed in lack of the portion. There was two small pieces of chicken. And very little sauce. It looked lost in the tray. I wasn’t sure if we accidentally got a kids meal. Then the dinner comes with a side of pasta. They ask you what type of pasta you wanted witch was a plus but it came wit a bland tomato sauce on it. I would think it would come with the same sauce as the dinner. I think they need to up the portion size for the price of the meal. If I was eating there I would have sent it back. For my wife her hero was a good size. The amount of chicken was well but the sauce was bland and there was very little cheese. One thing we both like on our parm hero is cheese melting on and around the meal. It just wasn’t there. Maybe we went on a off day. There are many Italian resturants in and around huntington. Might have to keep trying to find that true Brooklyn type

I haven’t tried any other pizza besides the park slope snob because its amazing. If you like white pizza and garlic this is the one to get!

DISAPPOINTED… Went in at 12:15pm to see their lunch bufet. The sterno set ups were there, but there was no food in it, so we ordered off the lunch specials menu. I ordered a grilled chicken with broccoli rabe hero and my valentine ordered 2 slices. We waited, and waited, and waited. Now it’s 12:43 and the gal behind the counter told us «2 more minutes» after we had gotten up to ask where the food was. This is a Thursday lunch, we were the only 2 customers in the restaurant, and the phones weren’t ringing, so where was our food!!! 3 more minutes went by before our food arrived. Taste was fine but what was the hold up? We will NOT be returning.

The pizza here was ok. The service was EXCELLENT. The décor was really nice too. I had a reg slice, a chicken bacon slice with some sauce, and some garlic knots. The reg slice was ok. The Chicken slice I had wasn’t something I’d order again, just wasn’t for me, the garlic knots with marinara sauce were ok. The woman who ran the place was great. The service was really good. They seem to have a full menu. The other guests there seem to be enjoying their meals. Perhaps if I’m in the area again I’ll have to try something else.

BEST PIZZA I’VE EVER HAD IN NY. PERIOD. I’m from Vegas, melting pot of food, all top notch, and I loved Brooklyn Pizza as much as I love my local foods. Go there, for sure. Everything was good that my boyfriend and I had ordered. And so were the people that worked there.

Love the Buffalo Chicken Pizza.

Great food, great atmosphere. Brooklyn without the schlep to Brooklyn. And try the pizza with chicken and bacon!

Awesome delivery service! New Owners are very accommodating. Pizza is fresh & really good. Had the mussels appetizer & it rocked!