Sweet Carolina Cupcakes

Sweet Caroline Cupcakes is a great cupcakery! There are enough choices to satisfy every palette. My family bought 3 different cupcakes– the Sweet Carolina, Very Strawberry and the Velvet Elvis. I am an icing girl and they delivered on the icing for sure! The cupcakes were very delicious, I wish that the cake part was just a tad more moist though. But other then that, they are great! The location is great too next to Piggly Wiggly at the south end of Hilton Head. It would be nice to have some indoor seating though for people to enjoy their cupcakes inside the cool A/​C, especially in the excruciatingly hot summer!

Not impressed:(
The cake part was dry and almost cornbread like:(
The icing on the sweet Carolina was good tho!
Not worth the $ 5 each!

Killer cupcakes but the tops fell off in transit which I thought was odd. I would guess some of the best cupcakes on the island.
Would definitely go again, especially if I were to eat near or on site.

This bakery is very small but cute inside. Smells very yummy as soon as you walk in the door. We ordered the pink Caroline, salty caramel, Boston éclair and choc w/​vanilla icing .my husband really enjoyed the pink Caroline and said it was very moist. My son and I tasted the others and thought they were just ok. If you have a sweet tooth, any of their cupcakes will do the trick. But they weren’t that great for a bakery that specializes in cupcakes, icing was very sweet with after taste and texture wasn’t moist, a step up from grocery store cupcakes. But the lady running the register was sweet and seemed happy to be there. We may give them another try …

I stopped by yesterday. Got 1 red velvet and 1 chocolate on chocolate cupcake. I started off slow because I didn’t want to buy a bunch and then be disappointed. They both were excellent cupcakes. They came up to $ 7 and some change. I read the reviews before going and people were complaining about the prices. I’m from Atlanta and that’s what we pay for great cupcakes. I do wish they put the cupcakes in a box. Didn’t like the bag because the icing got messed up but I didn’t let that stop me from enjoying it. Going to ride my bike back up there today to get more !
Maybe because it’s off season but They open at 11:00 not 10:00.

The cupcakes are decent but nothing better than I could make myself at home for a fraction of the cost. I’m from Indianapolis and love The Flying Cupcake and their inventive flavored make the price worth it, their presentation is also far better than Sweet Carolina. I bought 3 cupcakes paid just under $ 12 and they were wrapped in wax paper and placed in a paper shopping bag. One cupcake that had caramel on top of the icing stuck to the paper and therefor most of the caramel was left on the paper and not on the cupcake. Boxes come in all sizes so you’d like to think they cared enough about their customers to give them boxes so the cupcakes would still look delicious when they got them home. Also didn’t like that the cashier picked the cupcakes up with bare hands, even with the cupcake wrapper I’m sure some hand to cupcake or icing touching happens. Tongs or gloves would be a much better option.

After a few hiccups with communication, Holly has reached out to me and will be baking the cupcakes for our wedding! I have personally had the cupcakes a few times and they are absolutely delish! Im glad that we were able to move forward and I’m looking forward to working with SCC and devouring some cupcakes in a month! I know our guests will be very pleased :)

Delicious cupcakes, unique flavors, and generous portions. A little pricey, but you’re on vacation, so splurge a little!

This cupcake shop is the first place my family goes when visiting Hilton Head. It helps that it is right next to Piggly Wiggly. The cupcakes are phenomenal. If you love real buttercream and a well made cake, this is the place for you. They are not skimpy on any part of this treat. The cupcakes are not cheap, but I believe they are fairly priced for the ingredients and presentation. Even the boxes they come in are beautiful.
I have two children, teenagers now, who even rave about this place to their friends. Our favorite cupcakes are the chocoholic, after dinner mint and black & white. I also like the lemon when they have it. The menu is different each time we go. However, we also like the standard vanilla and chocolate, so we always find something good.
Before we go, we look on their website and see what the menu is. We have not been disappointed yet.

Although I cannot speak from personal experience about the actual cupcakes, I CAN say that Sweet Carolina’s Cupcakes has SUPERIOR customer service. I am traveling to Hilton Head for a family vacation and was looking around for someone to make a birthday cake for me to pick up when I arrive. I emailed Sweet Carolina’s asking if they offer this service. They replied very quickly saying that they do not offer cakes, only cupcakes, but they were willing to help me find a place that could help me out. Holly emailed me a list of places to check out, which was super helpful being that I am not from the area. I definitely plan to stop by for a cupcake or two while in town next week! Thanks for being willing to help out, Sweet Carolina’s!

As good if not better than Abby’s in Cincinnati. Lots of options and flavors to choose from — you can’t go wrong. Go for the pink house cupcake but be sure and get there before 5!

Awesome Cupcakes! Loved the Sweet Carolina!

Treats were great. The 6 year old wanted vanilla cake for desert one night and this was just he place. The staff was very helpful.

So, I love cupcakes. Just the right amount of cake, and I can scrap off the icing without offending anyone (as I am not an icing fan). So, I have cupcakes all over…
This place is by far my fav! I don’t even scrap off the icing:) I love vaca because that means I am getting a fab cupcake at some point!
PS– coffee cake is AMAZING — like literally better than the cupcakes!!! Get the coffee cake!!!

I tried the vanilla cupcake and it was average. The batter was tough on the outside and tasted only like a sweet bread. My friends had the black bottom and hot fudge Sunday. The black bottom was really good and had smooth icing while the Hot Fudge Sunday’s icing was gritty and the cake was a little tough too

Just brought home 6 cupcakes for the family! The «Sweet Georgia Brown» with brown sugar, pecans and peaches with cream cheese icing was scrumptious! My kiddos devoured their traditional chocolate chocolate and chocolate/​vanilla!

These are my favorite cupcakes! When my husband and I lived in Charleston, we would drive once a month to pick up a few! They are much better than anything we have in Charleston and there have only been two or three times where I have been disappointed in the quality (thats in a three year period) My favorite is the Sweet Carolina and Neapolitan. I can’t complain on the price if the taste is there and it says a lot that someone is willing to drive 100 miles just to grab a few for the day. Its definitely one of my favorite places!

My cupcake (vanilla cake with vanilla frosting) was fresh and sweet and perfect. I wish I’d gotten a chance to try more than just one flavor. All the cupcakes in this store looked amazing. Perfect amount of frosting to cupcake ratio (which in my opinion, means that there’s just a bit more frosting than cake.) So. thoroughly. enjoyable. If you’re in Hilton Head, this is a must-​try.

Visiting from DC, the cupcake capital of the world, I was shocked by 2 things: 1. How delicious the Sweet Caroline cupcake was 2. How expensive the cupcakes were — DC prices in SC for anything makes me sad. This being said, the cupcakes are huge and I only tried the one, but it was ONE OF THE BEST CUPCAKES I’VE EVER HAD and the rest looked pretty good too :) Definitely worth it for at least one!

I’m a sucker for an overpriced boutique cupcake, and Sweet Carolina’s has earned it’s way to the top of my list.
We discovered this location the last time we vacationed on HHI and made several cupcake stops during our trip. Trying the unique flavors was fun, but my favorite hands down was the Sweet Carolina cupcake.
Went to HHI for a day over winter break and had to make a special stop for another one of those Sweet Carolina cupcakes. Did not disappoint!