Mannino’s 4 Pizza & Restaurant

The dinners are so much better than the normal pizza place. The sauce is homemade and not canned. We love their pasta dishes, salads and the pizza. The inside is dated but comfortable and it works well. It’s a «normal» pizza place/​restaurant that serves food above the norm.

Five stars??? Yes! Traveling to NYC with family. A great lunch stop. Great choices of pizza, quick service, the price is right. Friendly faces behind the counter. If we were locals we’d be regulars.

This is our go-​to Pizza place in the area. When we get delivery, it always gets to us really quick. The dinners are ginormous and feed us for days.

I’m originally from Bayonne where we had a pizzeria on every block so I’m used to eating delicious pizza. Bayonne had mastered the art of pizza-​making. Mannino’s 4 reminds me of good olé home sweet home. Best pizza in this area by far if you like good fluffy but light pies. If you want think crust, this is not the place for you. We ordered the originale (essentially a Margherita pie) and the Primavera (a white pie) to share. I am currently stuffed as I write this review but I couldn’t resist having an extra slice of deliciousness. Their wings have alot of breading which isn’t my favorite but this is definitely my go-​to spot when I crave a slice or 3 of pizza :)

Chicken parm in vodka sauce over penne vodka… Just amazing. Like the godfather pizza, straight ridiculous how good it is. We order from here several times per month and they have great service and very kind people, thank you Mannino’s 4!

Well I don’t like doing this but I have to change my review of a once great pizza place.
Lately the pizza has not been good. It is usually cold when it comes (they charge for delivery so they should work on keeping it hot).
We ask for the crust to be crispy, it never is.
And finally the biggest change is how unbelievably salty the pizza is. It is seriously like licking a salt stick. Last time I only had two slices and afterwards I had to drink three bottles of water I was so dehydrated from the salt.
I don’t know if there are new cooks there but something changed and not for the better.

Great pizza and service! Ordered a pepperoni with extra cheese, crust had the perfect crunch, pepperoni added the right spicy and thankfully no heat touch. Will stop by again on my next visit to East Windsor. Next will try the cheese steaks…

Pretty good family joint pizza shop in this cute little town. I especially enjoyed the fresh ingredients on the pizza. I do agree that their pizza is the go to, we did order a cheese steak sandwhich too and it is just well, food. But the pizza was good and crust was nice and crunchy but chewy. They had a good selection of single slices too when we went late afternoon on a Sunday although we ordered our own medium rusitca. There were eight huge slices to it.

Don’t pass it up. Great people! Great food! Wild pizza flavors. I suggest the buffalo chicken or the chicken bacon ranch. Sandwiches and dinners are also excellent.

Some of the best pizza, hands down, I have ever had, anywhere! Great toppings and a perfectly done crust. I just can’t say enough. You will probably think they paid me to write this review, but it’s really that good. I’ve had pizza throughout the country and this is simply outstanding.
Chicken Parm was also amazing. The cheese they use is top-​notch. Their sauce was very flavorful and the pasta cooked perfectly. My family also loved their Calimari, bread, and sausage.
Quaint and clean little setup. Very friendly and outstanding service. You can definitely tell that the people there take pride in what they do. Everything fresh, great portions and for the money, outstanding value. Definitely something for everyone.
Well-​done, Manninos 4. You have my vote!

If you are in the area, get your pizza from Mannino’s 4. If you want sandwiches or wraps, you may want to go some place else.
The Good– the prices and the pizza options. we loved the Originale with fresh basil and mozzarella and some great sauce. The plain pizza was also great.
The Not So Good– The Eggplant Parm had no cheese whatsoever, and my father in law said the chicken caesar wrap was like chewing rubber. I can’t speak to it directly.
When we talked to friends in the area, they confirmed. Manninos is for pizza only. so enjoy your pizza!

Pizza was very tasty! And the crust was perfect! I didn’t give 5 stars because it’s a little to salty. While I love seasoning, not a big fan of salt. Also, we ordered what they called ‘Buffalo Wings’. That would get a fat 0! It’s really fried wingers that you can purchase at the grocery store! Don’t bother.

Great great great!!! Passing through and stopped in. Service excellent and vodka sauce out of this world! Come in and taste for yourself

My go-​to place for pizza in the area. The pies are always delicious and cooked perfectly. Also, every encounter I have had with staff has been very friendly. I’ve had a few of their other offerings (antipasto salad, buffalo wings) and they are decent. I haven’t had any of their entrees, but I tend to stick with the excellent pizza here.

Mannino’s has delicious, fresh made pizza — my favorites are plain and sausage. Ya can’t go wrong with the pizza and wings deal. My husband and I get that on occasion, and it never disappoints. Now, the wings. They’re not traditional buffalo wings, but don’t let that dissuade you. They are friend to crunchy perfection. Then, the buffalo sauce is served on the side. What?! I ORDERED the wings, I DROVE to get them. Now I have to put the sauce on myself? Yes. Do it. Together with the crispy crunch of the wings, the sauce adds a powerful punch of flavor and texture that will send your buds reeling.
NOW. The pizza and wings aren’t the only goodies at Manninos. There’s also the cheesesteaks (chicken and steak are both faboo), the calzones, the strombolis… All freshly made, all delicious.
When it comes to that nagging craving for Italian cuisine, I recommend Mannino’s wholeheartedly.

Good fried food, the western burger and everything else was good, I’ll order food from here again definitely

OK Pizza lovers
throw away all previous expectations on what «good» pizza is
and go try manninos
small shop typical 1970s looking pizza parlor …
big selection of toppings from the usual to the pineapple
we ordered black olive and plain
now these are 10″ pies good for one really hungry person or 2 hungry but not starving people.
I am at a loss of words to describe… but its not really thick and its not really thin crust
what it is perfect crispy crust
look at fellow Unilocalers pics for an idea how this yummy pizza looks
its good its tasty and its not expensive
plus the guys working there are super friendly
we ordered wings and pizza
and took soda
we sat waiting, no rush to pay which always makes me feel better about a place
I really enjoyed my experience here and my son really enjoyed his wings

Phenomenal! My fiancé and I have been going here for 4 years and I can’t say anything bad about the place. Amazing pizza. The originale is our FAVE! And the pasta fagioli soup tastes pretty close to my noni’s! So thumbs up on that! They have great pasta dishes as well. And their bread. We love great italian bread and theirs never fails! The only thing I wish they had are garlic knots, but it’s not something that serious. Honestly, I recommend this place over any other pizza joint in the area.

I love Mannino’s. When we moved here 11 years ago, we were trying different spots. We went into Mannino’s one night and ordered some slices. They have a big display of specialty pizzas and I was saying to my wife I wanted to try the buffalo chicken some day. Joe Maninno came over and gave me a slice to try for free. That tells you everything about the folks who run the place.
Ok, now the review. The pizza is great. Plain, sausage, white with broccoli, Scicilian are standards for us and always good. The buffalo chicken is good (I get the one with a creamy sauce… not the fried chicken one… yes, they have two types). Then, there is the Godfather. Ham, vodka sauce, fried chicken, fresh mozzarella. This thing is out of this world.
Pizza is not all they do. The chicken parm sub is insanely good and I crave it when I’ve been out of town for a while and away from good Italian food. The sauce is amazing, bright and a hint of sweetness… try it, trust me. Their dinners (Chicken parm and francese are our favorites) are HUGE. Seriously a great value. Obbiously there is a lot of stuff we haven’t tried, but the things we have are great.
Finally, the people working here are great. They take care of you and they put their heart into it. I know there are probably 6 – 7 other pizzerias in a 5 minute drive, but for me, Manninos is the tops.

The tables in this place are all themed with football logos, so you can support your favorite team through your choice of seat. We met a friend and played a few games of Scrabble here on a random weeknight, and they were totally friendly and didn’t mind us taking up the table for awhile. The place seems to do a brisk take-​out business, and less sit-​down customers, so hopefully we weren’t in the way.
Started with bruschetta, which was on thicker bread than I’m used to, but the flavors were good. The originale pizza was great — high-​quality olive oil drizzled atop a generously-​sized medium pie with fresh mozzarella and a flavorful red sauce. The cheesesteak pizza was a bad decision on my part — it’s topped with fake cheese rather than mozzarella, just like you’d expect on a classic cheesesteak, and I don’t particularly like fake cheese.
The owner is clearly invested in the place — he came over and chatted with us and we talked ingredients (and Scrabble) for a bit. It’s a bit out of the way for me, but I’m glad we tried this place!