The Madison Fire Island Pines

It’s about time.
In The Madison, the Pines finally has a really nice place to stay for the short term. It’s elegant, modern, clean, convenient, and efficiently run. The pool and jacuzzi are fantastic. The staff is friendly and helpful, but unobtrusive.
I am only too happy to recommend The Madison, especially if this is your first time to Fire Island. You will have a lovely time.

We thoroughly enjoyed our experience at the Madision. It’s more like staying at a friend’s beach house for a couple of nights than staying in an anonymous hotel room.
The kitchen is open to all guests, you can bbq on the grill, and you can hop in the jacuzzi or pool at any time.
The facilities are nice and open, but also private. It’s a perfect place for couples or even a group of friends. The location is perfect.
The one negative remark I have is that the rooms are not very soundproof… you can hear other guests speak/​walk around/​etc in the hotel.

I have never so quickly moved into vacation mode. The Madison seduces you within minutes of arrival with its romance, beauty, elegance, style and calm. On a practical level this guesthouse is equal to any Manhattan boutique hotel in comfort, cleanliness, style, service and charm. It’s amazing how quickly you can go from Manhattan to this bit of peace and serenity on Fire Island. The location is perfect, literally a minute from food, drink and a scene (if you’re so inclined) or a minute in the other direction to one of the most beautiful, quiet and spacious beaches in the world. The hosts are professional but quickly become friends.

I stayed for the weekend. A great friendly relaxed place and good food. Luke is the perfect host.
They could shoot a movie in this place.

Our stay here was BEYOND GREAT! My partner and I had a wonderful stay. Very clean, very hospitable, and the people that stayed in the Madison were all wonderful upscale people. Breakfast in the morning was another plus. Great style and great vibe. I will return in a few weeks. And Luke managed the house very well. Great guy.

An absolutely perfect spot for a few days escape to Fire Island Pines.
For anyone who knows Fire Island Pines, accommodation primarily revolves around full season rentals and house shares, with hotels either very scarce and normally very sketchy. Well The Madison gives you the best of being in a «house», yet with all the upscale trappings of a boutique hotel.
The property is really beautiful, hidden away with manicured grounds, cabana style pool area, private hot tub, welcoming communal areas for coffee and breakfast.
The rooms are really nice. Stayed in the Dexter A room upstairs, with lovely outlook to the garden, nice large bathroom and completely comfortable bed.
Pretty much everything you could want is available to you … breakfast, all day espresso, WiFi, swimming pool, hot tub, beach towels /​chairs /​umbrellas /​sunscreen /​bug spray to take to the beach, friendliness, within a stones throw from the ferry and night life … what more could a gay boi ask for.
Yes it is clearly a gay spot, but I am confident it would be very straight-​friendly :-) Will definitely return.