Liberty Pizza and Grill

A lot of mediocre reviews on Unilocal but I thought my takeout was great. I got an order of fries and the buffalo chicken garden salad. The salad was big and there was a lot of buffalo sauce throughout it. It’s pretty inexpensive. It’s more of a takeout place, the ambiance inside is lacking. The people working behind the counter were also really nice.

We started ordering from Liberty about 2 years ago for lunch, at my work. The pizza is outstanding. I have eaten a lot of pizza in my time, and they by far are the best. There’s a fancy millionaire banker guy that frequents my work. He had a slice one day, and since then has us order him one every time he’s there.
The staff is super friendly. I know most of them by name, and will admit that my review may be a bit biased since I have formed friendships with the owner, and some of his employees, but the only way you will find out how good it is, is to try it for yourself.

We just moved in a couple months ago, right cross street with Liberty Pizza. The owner is a great person, always friendly, very nice service. The food there is also pretty good, you can find almost everything with a reasonable price.

I grew up in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, so yes, I am a bit of a SEAFOOD SNOB (AN «S.S.»). Liberty says «Pizza» on the sign, but it should say «crab legs that will make you mouth-​gasm.» Maybe that does not give off a family-​friendly vibe that Liberty is going for. This is literally their only mistake.
There are many reasons that I love Liberty Crab Legs & More.
First, this neighborhood is adorable. There is fun project housing, many rabid dogs, and last time I went, I saw a father and son getting housed on Bacardi & Coke on their front stoop. Talk about ambiance.
Third, the seating is abysmal. But, with this quality of seafood, you won’t even mind standing as you shove crab cakes into your dirty little «crab cake hole.»
Second, the menu is extensive in a manner that would usually make me nervous for a store the size of my college-​aged girlfriend’s studio apartment. (Suck it, Nancy). However, Liberty just brings that primo quality that lets you forget about food-​borne illness and seafood freshness. You can get a quesadilla, crab legs, chicken wings, steamed salmon, a buffalo chicken Stromboli, a whole pound of cream cheese, scallops, raw oysters, raw oyster quesadillas, raw clams, and even raw chicken here. The works. And, honestly, nothing that I have tried here has been less than amazing. Other than the raw chicken. That was a rough month at the Trouble Household.
All-​in-​all, order the Teriyaki Salmon Sticks with a side of fresh tartar sauce mixed with old ketchup, or as I like to call it, «Special Charlie Sauce.» (note: You cannot order this by name at Liberty). And, you know what, get the raw chicken. Live a little, man.

Wish i could rewind time 2 hours and order from somewhere else. 2 hours is how long delivery took… 7 blocks away. When checking in after 90 minutes, they blew me off and wouldnt give me an eta. The food showed up 30 min later. I wish they kept it.
Buffalo chicken (rated on Foodler as a 4.0) was disgusting. Sweet and sloppy. The cheese wasnt melted on the stromboli and the chicken looked like it came out of a can. Fries were soggy and the hoagie looked like a 3 year old slopped it together. Good thing the food made me lose my appetite, because this stuff was barely edible. Horrible

My friends and I placed an order on seamless and it was set to take an hour. Over an hour later we called to check in and the woman on the phone wasn’t very helpful at all. She had no idea what was going on with our order until we pestered her to further look into it. The address had been typed into the order wrong (thats on us, fine). Our neighbors were having a party and thought their friend who couldn’t attend sent them pizza, BUT why did the driver not confirm when dropping off the pizza who the order was for AND the driver had our phone number, why weren’t we called when our confused neighbors were given two large pies.
We called Liberty back to let them know we needed to place a new order, apologized for giving the wrong address, and inquired why the order wasn’t even confirmed with us. She said fine and that they would resend our order.
At this point, we are over it and just want to eat pizza. A half hour goes by and the phone rings. We assume our order is here, nope. It’s Liberty Pizza calling back to tell us they aren’t going to send our order because the original order was placed online. How did they not know this when they confirmed the order was being resent to us?
Overall, the entire process was a headache. I understand that it was our mistake for entering the wrong number, but it seems a little unprofessional they way the staff dealt with it. They should have confirmed the order with us and after that, should have known policy on take out orders before promising a new order and then taking it back a half hour later.
Never ever ordering here again. Don’t even care how good the food is, I’d rather eat mediocre food from a place with professional staff.

I wish that I could give zero stars on this review. I had the most ridiculous experience when I ordered through GrubHub. I ordered a pizza and they gave me the wrong one so I called grub hub to ask for a refund. Not only did they not give the refund the driver came by to question me why they should give me a refund!!! How creepy and scary is that!!! Please guys go to another location because these people do not know how to run a business

Stromboli is ok
Pizza sucks
Wings are ok
Cheesesteak is flavorless
Stuff shells with sausage is good if you ask for extra sauce

The pizza is not great but they are fast an close by. Tryin out a veggie wrap, no cheese — high hopes for this. Its mostly a takeout place but there are two tables… If you had to eat in a hurry you could. The ambiance is extremely lackluster though, super plain.

Actually not bad! Pizza is good, basic, what we call skating rink pizza at my house. Curly fries are decent; they are totes frozen but who cares. It’s cheap and they get here quick.

Ordered through Grubhub, prices were good, delivery wasn’t bad for a Friday night, only took an hour. Delivery guy was nice but forgot soda. We called and he did come back with the soda which was awesome… but then I found a short black hair in my pizza…

1 Grilled Chicken Quesadilla $ 7.95
1 2 Egg Breakfast Sandwich $ 2.75
The sandwich was great, the croissant was very buttery and delicious. I didn’t get meat on my sandwich, but I would recommend that for next time.
I was also in the mood for a Quesadilla. The portion was huge and deliciously greasy and came with a side of sour cream and a side of salsa. The quesadilla came with lots of other items inside it besides chicken and cheese which made it very filling. Also they use a Mexican blend of cheeses unlike lots of pizza shops that use mozzarella.

Great little corner pizza shop for take out. Portions are huge. Try the steamed seafood platters for a treat! The crab legs and the shrimp are tasty and come with three sides — I usually opt for all three of their offerings — potatoes, corn on the cob, and broccoli. Salads are made with romaine lettuce, and usually include cucumbers, peppers, olives, tomatoes and onions. Meatball sub is delicious. Pizza is good but the supreme has too many toppings and they use canned mushrooms. Overall I prefer sandwiches and seafood here.